Macron admits he is a child who never grew up - The Telegraph
Emmanuel Macron has admitted he is “still a child” and never grew up, in a biography detailing his political rise and fall.
The French president was incapable of admitting when he was wrong, his old friends told Catherine Nay, the veteran political biographer.
His extraordinary self-belief ultimately contributed to his political downfall, Ms Nay argues.
Drawing on personal conversations with Mr Macron, his wife, Brigitte, and childhood friends, Ms Nay traces his character to a grandmother, who wanted to make him her “masterpiece”.
Nay recalls telling Mr Macron during a four-hour meeting at the Élysée Palace that she was travelling to Amiens to interview his former teachers, including Marc Defernand, who had been his director of studies.
“I like Mr Defernand very much,” the president replied cheerfully.
He then paused, his face breaking into what the author called an “ecstatic smile”, before adding in a low voice: “Me, I’m still a child!”
Emmanuel Macron as a child The book also reveals that Mrs Macron no longer feels as protected by her husband as she once did, amid growing signs of the couple’s isolation as his presidency unravels.
In This Country Whose Prince Is a Child, Mrs Macron recalls meeting an astonishingly self-assured young man. “I had never met anyone so strong,” she told Ms Nay. “He was a raw diamond.” At 20, she said, he made her feel “protected from everything”.
But in November 2024, after his disastrous snap election, in which his party lost power, Mrs Macron admits: “I felt much more protected by him then than I do today.”
Brigitte Macron thought Emmanuel was a ‘raw diamond’ Credit: AP Photo/Christophe Ena Nay alleges the couple have endured difficult times. Mrs Macron, 73, confided that after the dissolution, her husband, 48, spent evenings in silence, scrolling through social media to read criticism of himself.
“She’s been feeling down for a while,” Nay told The Telegraph, citing the toll of malicious, baseless claims about Mrs Marcon’s gender. The couple, she said, were “very much on their own”.
Such seclusion is nothing new, she adds. The book says Mr Macron has led his life in an ivory tower, with three successive phases of isolation: his childhood with his grandmother, his unconventional romance with the older Mrs Macron, and finally his years in power.
His grandmother Manette, a former headmistress, effectively “sequestered” him in a world of books, determined to make him her “masterpiece” – a predicament the grandson embraced, Nay stresses.
At 14, when he started dating a girl, Manette threw his belongings onto the landing and sent him back to his parents. He returned with a promise: “I won’t look at girls any more.”
“I still live in my grandmother’s spirit,” Mr Macron told Nay. In Mrs Macron’s words: “Emmanuel still hasn’t buried his grandmother. He hasn’t even replaced her. He ought to be psychoanalysed.”
Manette fed his dream of becoming a great writer, an ambition he grudgingly abandoned when his novel failed to find a publisher. She was his first “political coach”, getting him to read French classics out loud, fuelling his oratorial skills and huge self-belief.
“Introspection doesn’t enter his intellectual world,” Nay said. “Even when he apologises, he comes back later to explain that he was right.”
“Emmanuel is never wrong,” recalled Gaspard Gantzer, a former fellow student at the elite ENA school.
Emmanuel Macron meets children as he visits sports facilities in Loudenvielle, south-western France, on July 10 Credit: Reuters/Lionel Bonaventure Ministers emerged from meetings despairing after he demonstrated encyclopaedic knowledge of their dossiers. “I felt like crying,” one minister told Nay. During Covid, he similarly challenged medical specialists on new American research.
The president himself recognises his lost adolescence. “I have never been a teenager. I don’t like teenagers. I don’t understand them. My wife does,” he told writer Emmanuel Carrère in 2025, according to the book.
His romance with Mrs Macron, his drama teacher and 24 years his senior, brought a second period of isolation amid family disapproval.
Nay provocatively calls it a “seduction of an adult”, rather than a minor, arguing that it was the teenage Mr Macron who made the first move by suggesting they write a school play together.
“We’re going to write,” he declared. “Who’s ‘we’?” Mrs Macron asked. “You and me.” He even insisted that they would work at her house on Friday afternoons.
“The real courage was hers,” Mr Macron told Nay. “She had three children and a husband. And I was a pupil and nothing more.”
Mrs Macron later told a friend that she had asked whether he wanted a child of his own. His reply, according to Nay’s book, was: “No, I want you to look after only me.”
Nay argues that such seclusion deprived him of everyday experiences of friendship, disagreement and compromise. But he had a secret weapon.
Unlike his predecessor Nicolas Sarkozy, who fought and bossed his way to the top, Mr Macron charmed older, powerful figures into opening doors for him.
“He looked at them with those lagoon-blue eyes, as if he’d never heard anything so intelligent,” Nay said. “They fell for it, like the raven in La Fontaine’s fable: they let go of the cheese.”
Jean-Michel Darrois, a lawyer who helped him secure a job at Rothschild bank, confessed with hindsight: “We too were a little in love with this gifted young man.” After winning over prospective supporters, Mr Macron sometimes asked colleagues: “I think I’ve hooked him, haven’t I?”
But many admirers later felt spurned. Xavier Fontanet showed Nay years of texts with Mr Macron before telling her: “When he was elected, he never replied to my messages again.”
Gilles Finchelstein, director of the Left-wing Jean-Jaurès Foundation, suffered a similar fate after Mr Macron asked him about his chances of becoming president.
“You’re not ready. There are subjects you’ve never worked on, and you don’t know the country,” he warned.
“He didn’t like what I said. I never saw him again,” Mr Finchelstein told Ms Nay, adding that Mrs Macron was the only person who could criticise her husband.
Nay said that Mr Macron regarded the stretching of rules, including punctuality, as an expression of personal freedom – even when it came to royalty.
She told The Telegraph she had challenged him over his late arrival at the British Normandy Memorial in June 2024, where the King and British veterans had been attending D-Day commemorations.
“The King! That’s not on,” she recalled telling him after he arrived at least 15 minutes late while proceedings were under way.
Mr Macron explained that people had approached him wanting to talk, so he “stopped to speak to them”.
Emmanuel Macron turned up late because he believes breaking rules is an expression of personal freedom, Nay claims Credit: Getty Images/Eddie Mulholland As economy minister in 2016, Mr Macron infuriated France’s interior minister by suggesting migrants would no longer be held at Calais after Brexit.
“He meddled in everything,” Nay said.
Despite his confidence, she said, he was unprepared for office, having benefited from extraordinary political luck, which he took as further proof of his prowess.
He barely campaigned for re-election in 2022. When Nay asked why, Mr Macron replied: “Because I was exhausted.” Mrs Macron, Nay added, had not wanted a second term.
She believes his determination always to be right culminated in his ill-fated decision to call a snap election. A poll last week put public confidence in him at just 13 per cent, below even François Hollande’s record low in 2016.
His second and final term ends in May, the political centre he championed is in disarray, and the nationalist Right and radical Left are in pole position.
Nay compares him to Julien Sorel, the ambitious hero of Stendhal’s 19th-century novel Le Rouge et Le Noir, Mr Macron’s favourite, who ends up on the guillotine.
She concluded: “By dissolving parliament, he guillotined himself. He thought that once he’d spoken, things were done. But he isn’t a manager.”

