Mark Carney has surprise meeting with Donald Trump in China, but no progress on U.S.-Canada trade deal - Toronto Star
Carney and Trump discussed 'the work underway to reach a mutually beneficial trade agreement,' according to an official readout from the Canadians.
Prime Minister Mark Carney meets with U.S. President Donald Trump on the margins of the 33rd APEC Leaders’ Summit, in Shenzen, People’s Republic of China Wednesday.
SHENZHEN, China — A surprise meeting between Prime Minister Mark Carney with Donald Trump in China led to no resolution of the Canada-U.S. logjam only agreement to keep working on it.
An official readout from the Canadian side reported that the two leaders discussed “the work underway to reach a mutually beneficial trade agreement that would create good jobs, boost affordability, and fully respect Canada’s languages, culture, and sovereignty. They agreed to continue the work and to stay in close contact.”
Hours before they met, Carney rejected criticism by certain advisers to the U.S. president about Canada’s increased ties with China, defended his crusade to diversify Canada’s trading partners, and invited more Asian investment, including in Canadian ports.
Canada pales in comparison to America’s courting of Beijing to stabilize trade, Carney said, dismissing such complaints uttered at different times by Trump’s commerce secretary Howard Lutnick, trade adviser Peter Navarro and even chief negotiator Jamieson Greer. He said they are not top of mind for Trump when the two leaders talk, which he said they do often.
This evening, I met with President Trump in Shenzhen. We discussed the work underway to reach a mutually beneficial trade agreement that would create good jobs, boost affordability, and fully respect Canada’s languages, culture, and sovereignty. We agreed to continue the work and to stay in close contact.
“In my conversation with the President, he’s tried to understand where we are with China, where we’re going with China,” Carney said. “But it’s not — I shouldn’t speak for him — but in his hierarchy of issues, it’s not the top issue at all.”
In a week when Carney struck a new deal to further lower Chinese tariffs on Canadian pork and seafood shipments in exchange for Ottawa agreeing to extend tariff waivers on select Chinese-made steel and aluminum items in short supply in Canada, Trump trade adviser Peter Navarro slammed Carney’s dealings with China, particularly the prime minister’s suggestion that Canada could increase automotive trade with China if trade talks with the U.S. fail, calling the notion “offensive in the extreme.”
“China is going to eat Canada alive,” Navarro said.
Asked if believes the president shares that view, Carney pushed back at a news conference in Shenzhen, following a speech where he pitched Asia-Pacific CEOs on more investment in Canada.
Canada is exporting more canola, pork, seafood, liquefied natural gas, oil and iron ore, among other goods, to China, Carney told reporters, but the scale of trade relative to the size of the Canadian economy, and the nature of the Canadian sectors that ship to China are nowhere near the same level as the “commercial, technological, strategic relations between the United States and China.”
“These are important industries, (but) these are not cutting edge semiconductors,” Carney said. “These are not the types of trade relationship that the United States has with China.”
Carney made no direct reference to the questions swirling around Trump circles after the ouster of Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang under a cloud that led the company to cease its sale of advanced chips to China amid an alleged spy scandal.
As if to punctuate Carney’s characterization of the much closer China-U. S. relationship, President Xi Jinping went to the airport to personally greet Trump on arrival here Wednesday evening — a formal gesture that Xi did not extend to the Canadian prime minister when he arrived Monday to hold a meeting with the Chinese president before the summit start.
U.S. President Donald Trump, centre, walks with China’s President Xi Jinping, right, after arriving at Shenzhen Baoan International Airport to attend the APEC summit in Shenzhen Wednesday.
Carney and Trump later met on the sidelines of the summit here Wednesday for about 20 minutes, a meeting that was not initially on the schedule.
A senior Canadian official said it was a “pull-aside” not a formal sit-down, along with Trump’s chief of staff Stephen Miller, Greer, Lutnick and Secretary of State Marco Rubio, while Carney’s chief aide Marc-André Blanchard and Foreign Affairs Minister Anita Anand accompanied the prime minister.
Carney and Trump speak often by phone, but they have not had any extensive face-to-face time since attending a World Cup tournament soccer game in July. That was before Canada-U. S. talks collapsed, and Trump imposed new tariffs, threatening more to take effect January. Sources say trade talks remain in a weird state of suspension — no formal negotiations but lots of texts and phone calls between the two sides.
Trump, however, is to have a major formal meeting with China’s Xi and with Russian President Vladimir Putin at the Shenzhen summit, which the American president said he wants focused on non-proliferation of nuclear weapons, not on Ukraine, when the leaders of the world’s three top nuclear-armed nations sit down Thursday.
”(I) fully respect the United States engagement with China and the efforts of President Trump to stabilize that relationship and use that relationship for positive outcomes such as the initiative around denuclearization,” said Carney. “Guess what? Canada is in favour of denuclearization. … If the relationship can be used towards that end, we’re very much supportive of it.”
But Carney harshly condemned Putin’s war in Ukraine, and said the Russian president is “lying” when he claimed after meeting Xi that sanctions are a thing of the past. “Mr. Putin can ask his financial institutions, he can ask his oligarch friends, he could ask his hockey players whether or not sanctions are a thing of the past. I think he’ll find out that they’re very real, they’re biting, they are absolutely necessary because of his illegal and unjustified war.”
Carney said if he found himself next to Putin, he’d make Canada’s opposition to the Ukraine war absolutely clear.
Carney later found himself entering the summit’s opening dinner Wednesday night after Putin and just before Trump, in that order, with Chinese President Xi Jinping the last, according to a pool report.
The prime minister’s entire past week — which spanned four summits and two continents — has been a massive push on investment to diversify Canada’s trade options away from overreliance on U.S. markets and to amplify his Davos call to “like-minded” partners to form strategic alliances against the hegemonic superpowers’ flouting of international trade and security norms.
Carney said that since January’s recalibration of the Canada-China relationship — years after it collapsed over Canada’s arrest of a Huawei executive at the behest of a U.S. arrest warrant and China’s retaliatory arrest of two Canadians — Canadian exports to China have risen by more than a third.
Carney said Canada will continue on that path all while placing “guardrails” on Chinese investment in certain areas.
He told several hundred business leaders gathered at an APEC CEO summit that, “We are turning global uncertainty into national opportunity. In a more dangerous and divided world, Canada is choosing a path toward a stronger, more prosperous, more resilient future. Our goal is greater sovereignty.”
“And that sovereignty is built on strength at home and diverse partnerships abroad.”
Carney has set out no-go zones for Chinese access to Canada’s markets. Those include critical minerals, artificial intelligence and quantum computing, and the defence sector. He told reporters that the Chinese government respects that he has been clear on those guardrails.
He said he is open to more Chinese investment in agriculture, food security, clean and conventional energy security, and “some aspects of financial services.” He has opened the door to Chinese EV manufacturing in Canada via joint ventures with Canadian investors, on condition that the plants are substantial manufacturing processes with Canadian components (not ready-to-assemble EVs mainly fabricated in China), including secure software that protects Canadian data, critical minerals from Canada, and high labour standards for workers.
Carney said he and his ministers are “clear” in private with their counterparts when it comes to discussing “human rights, issues of foreign interference, issues of transnational crime, narcotics trade — we raise them with our counterparts, including part of my discussions with President Xi. My experience has been that the most effective way to deal with these issues is to have open frank conversations, not to give a running dialogue on them.”
Carney noted there are already big foreign investors in Canadian infrastructure like ports, and said his government is open to more partnerships. “The calibration depends on the values that we share with the countries,” he said.
Carney sat down Tuesday night with Mexico’s President Claudia Sheinbaum to take stock of progress in the Canada-Mexico efforts to boost bilateral trade in the face of Trump’s onslaught of tariffs against America’s closest trading allies. No three-way meeting of the North American leaders is planned, but Sheinbaum and Trump met separately Wednesday, according to White House pool reports.
Error! Sorry, there was an error processing your request.
There was a problem with the recaptcha. Please try again.
You may unsubscribe at any time. By signing up, you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google privacy policy and terms of service apply.
Tonda MacCharles is Ottawa Bureau Chief and a senior reporter covering federal politics. Follow her on Twitter: @tondamacc.


