Mercedes C-Class EV review — is speed and 452 miles range enough? - The Times
Challenge yourself with today's puzzles.
Because I’m a journalist I can’t afford to buy new cars. Instead (and because I hate the idea of taking on the depreciation), I buy cars much further into their life. I have PCP-financed a three-year-old Ford Focus in the past, after the initial plunge in price had slowed somewhat, but that was during a period of historically low interest rates. Every time I look at finance deals on used cars now I wince. There are 0 per cent offers on some new cars, of course, but, again, I’m too tight to take that initial financial hit.
It helps that I get to drive box-fresh machines all the time, of course, but when I’m testing new cars for these pages, I do often think to myself, “Can I see myself buying this in ten years’ time?” You know, when it’s less likely to bankrupt me.
My current car, which I picked up in January, is a 2015 BMW 5 Series Touring (the F11, if you’re up on internal model designations, in 520d Luxury trim). It’s the first car I’ve owned that I remember testing when it was new, and recall driving along thinking that one day it would be fabulous to own. I was right. I love it. But I was also looking at Mercedes E-Class estates of its era, and it was a close call as to which I went for.
Today, some of the new long-range premium electric cars are definitely on my radar as decade-ahead driveway fodder, and once again it’s BMW and Mercedes-Benz duking it out for our attention.
The new Mercedes C-Class Electric is one of those cars that I could picture myself owning, but only much (much) further down the line, because at the moment it costs upwards of £57,995. But the C 400 4Matic has a claimed range of up to 452 miles from a 94kWh battery (428 miles in our test car’s trim), which is definitely competitive, particularly when you consider it’s four-wheel drive and goes like a rocket ship: 0-62mph takes four seconds dead thanks to the twin motors pumping out a combined 483bhp and 590 lb ft of torque. That’s more than a Porsche 911 Carrera GTS.
It’ll be particularly efficient on motorways, as EVs go, because of its slippery design and a two-speed gearbox, which switches from a regular ratio to a longer one at higher speeds, while the physical brake discs and pads are said to only be employed about 1 per cent of the time — almost all braking is by turning the electric motors into generators, to send energy back to the battery.
Which alls sounds very impressive, but there’s a BMW-shaped problem. Most people will compare the C 400 4Matic with the new i3 50 xDrive, which is both cheaper and goes further on a single charge. A lot further. Prices for the BMW start just north of 53 grand and it can manage up to 565 miles on the same range test. Game over for the Merc, then?
Well, hold your horses, because the BMW has fewer horses (463bhp) and significantly less torque (476 lb ft). Whether you would notice the difference when pulling away from the lights is another matter, mind you, as the BMW is only 0.7sec slower to 62mph.
The Merc wins on luggage space — 470 litres behind the rear seats and 101 litres under the bonnet, versus 420 litres and 31 litres for the BMW — and the rear of the cabin is beautifully appointed and especially roomy. Meanwhile the huge 39.1in Hyperscreen, which runs the full width of the dashboard and features 1,000 individual LEDs, combined with an astonishing Burmester 4D sound system are certain to grab attention.
It grabbed my attention while I was driving and my co-driver tried out YouTube, in fact. I glanced over from the driver’s seat and the onboard camera spotted me doing so the first time and shut off the video, as intended, but subsequent glances were not picked up and the video continued to play. Which is concerning. Not everyone will want to have a Cineworld in their car, but some will no doubt love it, and those people may not be at all concerned about such an issue. Do let us know if you have a new Hyperscreened Merc and this happens to you, by the way.
This has turned into a two-car buying guide rather than a straight review of the C-Class Electric, but it’s an obvious and useful comparison. And I’m going to continue in that vein because something else to consider is the clear difference in the way BMW and Mercedes have pitched their respective cars’ driving manners.
The BMW’s chassis, as one might expect, is about driver engagement, whereas Mercedes has engineered the C-Class Electric as a mini S-Class, with an uber-soft ride. In fact it’s so wallowy that in our range-topping Premier Edition test car — fitted with the optional Refinement Package (£2,500) that brings in Airmatic air suspension and rear-axle steering — we found the only way to get satisfactory body control (by our standards) was by keeping the car in Sport mode. This is not a car that enjoys being thrown around, despite its huge performance.
And while the 800v electric architecture is very impressive, with a charging capacity of up to 330kW, meaning you can add up to about 200 miles of range in ten minutes, the Merc has been put in the shade once again because the i3 charges up to 400kW.
That’s not the end of it, either, because the Premier Edition you see here actually costs more than £70,000. And even if you get the base-spec C 400 4Matic and are prepared to pay more for it than the entry-level BMW i3 50 xDrive, you may notice that you can get an even cheaper i3 — the 40 xDrive — that has almost as much range and starts at just £47,925. There must be some extremely frustrated folk at Mercedes-Benz HQ in Stuttgart right now. Not to mention global dealerships. Rumours suggest a single motor rear-wheel drive version of the C-Class Electric is in the works; it can’t come soon enough.
All of which means that unless you really want performance bragging rights, a giant cinema screen in front of you and a plusher ride, the C 400 4Matic is hard to recommend. I am guessing that in ten years’ time, when I start to look at cars like this, prices between the BMW and Mercedes on the used market will be much closer, which makes the choice harder. For now, though, what that also indicates is that the C-Class will depreciate more heavily.
I’m trying to think of a positive note to end this on for Merc. Erm… Oh, the electric CLA 250+ is brilliant, has a range of up to 484 miles and is currently on offer for under £44,000. Go and buy that.

