Michael Higgins: Carney's expropriation plan for Alto creates second-class citizens - National Post

Opponents of the Alto high-speed rail project in Quebec and Ontario meet on the Alexandra Bridge before marching toward a rally on Parliament Hill on Wednesday June 10, 2026 in Ottawa, Ont. Photo by Elliot Ferguson /The Kingston Whig-StandardArticle contentWhen Mark Carney and his ministers talk about nation-building projects they are always at pains to talk about respecting Indigenous rights and ensuring there is a “dialogue.” 

But “non-Indigenous people from Turtle Island” — to quote one woke archeologist — are finding a different reality.  

Farmers, businesses and homes in the path of the proposed Alto high-speed rail project from Toronto to Quebec City are facing forced expropriations and a truncated appeal process before a single track has been laid. 

By amending the Expropriations Act, the prime minister has created a two-tier consultation process, one where the rights of the Indigenous community are respected and another one where the rights of other people are trampled over. 

Columnist Jesse Kline keeps you up to date with what’s happening in Israel and the effects of antisemitism on life here in Canada. Friday mornings.

A welcome email is on its way. If you don't see it, please check your junk folder.

The next issue of Channel Israel will soon be in your inbox.

We encountered an issue signing you up. Please try again

When Carney talked about nation-building projects last September, he said that to build quickly meant “getting out of the way.” 

He was referring to government regulations, but he could easily have been speaking to the more than 100 communities in the path of the Alto high-speed rail. 

“For too long the construction of major infrastructure in Canada has been stalled by arduous, inefficient approval processes, uncertainty, red tape, duplication and complicated review processes,” said Carney. 

The prime minister tried to reduce those problems with C-15, a controversial, massive omnibus bill that also stripped people of some of their property rights. 

C-15 amended the Expropriation Act making it faster and easier for the federal government to take people’s homes, lands and farms if needed for the rail project. 

Before the amendments, the federal government would first have to try to negotiate with landowners for their property. If those negotiations failed the government could then try expropriation. 

This has now been removed. If the Carney Liberals decide they want the land for high-speed rail they can take it.