More trees axed from parklands as MotoGP legal challenge continues - ABC News & Headlines – Australian Broadcasting Corporation
Protesters witness the removal of a tree near East Terrace in Adelaide CBD on Wednesday morning. (ABC News: George Yankovich)
Protestors gathered in Adelaide's eastern parklands on Wednesday morning when more trees were axed as part of early works on the city's MotoGP track.
To make way for the $96 million circuit, a total of 377 trees are slated for removal.
A city resident group has mounted a legal challenge to stop the works, arguing that motorsport legislation does not grant the SA Motor Sport Board power to cut trees down.
More trees have been cut down in the Adelaide parklands as part of early works on the city's MotoGP track amid an unresolved legal challenge to the plans.
Three trees were removed from the eastern parklands today, after an initial four were lopped last week.
The first trees to go would allow work on utility infrastructure.
A total of 377 trees, 42 classed as significant, are slated for destruction to make way for the $96 million circuit, with construction due to officially begin next month.
The South East City Residents Association (SECRA) has launched a legal bid to halt the works, arguing that motorsport legislation does not grant the SA Motor Sport Board power to remove trees.
An artist's impression of the new Adelaide circuit, which will require the removal of 377 trees in the city parklands. (Supplied: SA Government)
In a hearing before the state's Supreme Court yesterday, SECRA counsel Brian Hayes KC added the laws allow for motorsport events on the parklands "on a temporary basis, from time to time".
But he said plans involving "structural activity" would "complicate the restoration of the parklands at the conclusion of each event".
Alison Doecke KC, for the state government, said the legislation did not support SECRA's argument.
"What we see is relatively clear language which makes it plain that the board has ample powers to pursue its statutory function," she said.
"There is no doubt here that the provision of … the MotoGP is within its statutory function."
Earlier this year, Peter Malinauskas revealed the state was set to host the Australian MotoGP from 2027. (ABC News)
At a media conference later on, South Australia Premier Peter Malinauskas said the government would respect the court process.
"I'm very glad that every time this has been tested, and a decision has been made, that courts have erred on the side of the action we are taking as a government because they look at the full picture," he said.
Another challenge to the MotoGP plans, lodged in the Federal Court by Queensland man Joshua Hogan, was discontinued earlier this month.
The track will need to be finished by November next year, when Adelaide is due to host its first MotoGP event.
In October, the Federal Court rejected a case brought by public servant Edwin Kemp Attrill and Kaurna woman Janette Milera opposing the North Adelaide Golf Course redevelopment.
The government's legal costs in that case were estimated at $450,000-$550,000, but an offer was made for the pair to pay $150,000.
Edwin Kemp Attrill will return to court today for another costs hearing. (Supplied: Edwin Kemp Attrill)
That was not taken up by Mr Kemp Attrill and Ms Milera, who returned to the Federal Court today for another costs hearing.
In today's hearing, Ms Doecke said the state maintained it was entitled to its full costs.
"This case is not of the exceptional kind where high public importance or substantial controversy extends beyond matters of local or regional environmental concern, so as to embody the public interest exception that would justify departure from the usual," she said.
But Ms Doecke said it was open to Judge Natalie Charlesworth to only award $150,000 in costs, given the government's previous offer.
"That would not be an error of discretion," she said.
Barrister Arturo Dal Cin, for Mr Kemp Attrill and Ms Milera, argued the case was "purely in the public interest" and special circumstances should be weighed in the awarding of costs.
Justice Charlesworth will hand down her decision on Thursday.
Before today's hearing, Mr Kemp Attrill said the case was about accountability.
"These costs would force me to liquidate my house, and would bankrupt Janette Milera for standing up to protect Pirltawardli," he said.
Mr Malinauskas said the protesters were aware of the financial risk before they lodged the case.

