Niagara region paramedics may be on the brink of strike action - CBC
CUPE Local 911 members, including paramedics, emergency dispatchers and occupational therapists, rally together outdoors. Contract talks with Ontario's Niagara region began in January. (Submitted by CUPE 911)Social SharingThe head of the union local representing paramedics, emergency dispatchers and occupational therapists in Niagara says 48-hour strike notice could be given at any time if an agreement with the Ontario region isn't reached.
The union has already chosen a strike date, but hopes to reach an agreement before taking that action, said Dave Barnett, president of Local 911 of the Canadian Union of Public Employees (CUPE).
"We have a date picked in our minds, but I'm not sharing it because it could change," he told CBC News. "It all depends on the temperature within the workplace, but at any time, we could be giving a notice of 48 hours."
Negotiations began in January, with higher wages, improved mental health benefits and guaranteed meal breaks among the main demands.
The union received a 99 per cent strike mandate from voters in March and is scheduled to meet again with the region on Nov. 30.
Paramedics and dispatchers are required to maintain essential services during strike action.
Barnett said that under the essential services agreement, only 14 to 15 per cent of paramedics could be off duty during a strike. In Niagara, that means 119 paramedics on the job, down from 138, and one emergency dispatcher able to walk off the job per shift.
In a written statement to CBC News, Niagara EMS chief Karen Lutz-Graul said the region has contingency plans in place and that emergency calls would continue to receive responses regardless of negotiation outcome.
"Niagara region remains hopeful that an agreement can be reached with CUPE 911 and is committed to continuing to work toward a resolution through the bargaining process," Lutz-Graul said.
Barnett, however, said Niagara's geography adds a layer of complexity not experienced by other services. Whereas other Ontario regions may be able to call upon ambulance service from neighbouring communities if needed, Niagara’s lake shores and international border could limit the number of neighbouring ambulance services available to provide backup in the event of a strike.
"We're in a peninsula, right? Like there's nobody coming across Lake Ontario. Buffalo is not coming to save us," he said.
For Oliver Gaskin, a Niagara paramedic since 2014, it’s about more than money.
Gaskin said 12-hour shifts can stretch to 14 or 15 hours, sometimes with just one 30-minute meal break near the beginning.
According to Barnett, paramedics are allowed one 30-minute break during a 12-hour shift, but heavy call volume sometimes means they don’t have time for it.
"I'm tired of hearing my co-workers say, 'I feel like I'm going to pass out,' because we will drop everything to go help somebody," said Gaskin, who became a paramedic with the idea of making it his career.
"I just hope that the region provides us a deal that allows me to continue my career here, because it's gotten to a point where I don't see a future at Niagara EMS for myself."
In this winter file photo, union members hold up signs as they seek a new contract. (Submitted by CUPE 911)
Mental health supports are also a major topic at negotiations.
Anastasia Fricke, an emergency dispatcher in Niagara since 2019, said she regularly takes the emotional toll of her work home with her.
"You can hear the voices. You hear the phone call playing over in your head and think, 'Did you do everything you could for them?'"
Fricke said dispatchers receive $3,000 annually in mental health benefits, an amount she says can quickly be used by therapy appointments. She wants more support to help workers proactively manage trauma they experience on the job, rather than having to seek treatment after burning out.
"Sometimes that's enough for me … 15, 20 minutes to myself to cry it out and kind of move on," she said, describing what happens after a difficult call. "There's other times where you may need to take a couple hours off the floor. There's times you might need to go home."
Barnett said mental health supports are particularly limited for part-time paramedics, who he says receive no mental health benefits, even as some individuals work full-time hours.
Barnett said paramedics in other regions — including Peel, Waterloo and Haldimand — recently negotiated new contracts, but Niagara workers are still waiting for a deal.
When CBC News spoke with him, Barnett was in Peterborough supporting striking paramedics there, who are involved in a similar dispute.
He said Niagara is losing experienced paramedics to better-paying jobs in other regions, including Waterloo and Peel. One paramedic who recently left told him they're now making more as a new recruit than they would have as a fully "waged-out" paramedic in Niagara.
Lutz-Graul, however, said the service isn't struggling to keep its workers.
She said voluntary turnover has stayed between four and six per cent annually, and sits at 3.87 per cent so far this year. Applications are up 12.6 per cent from 2025 and 29.6 per cent from 2024.
"We continue to attract a strong pool of candidates and are proud to bring the best people onto our team," Lutz-Graul said.
Barnett said he wonders whether more applications necessarily translates into more paramedics being hired. He said the latest recruitment class had just 12 paramedics, the smallest since 2023.
He also said more than 200 people have joined the union since 2020, but its net membership has grown by only about 80.
Asked about the discrepancy, Lutz-Graul said the number of CUPE 911-represented positions at Niagara EMS has increased by approximately 24.5 per cent since 2020. She did not provide a breakdown of hires and departures.
"If someone's willing to become a paramedic and they're good at it, we need to find every reason to keep them here," Barnett said. "We can't be giving them reasons to leave."
Coleman Molnar is a CBC reporter and editor based in the Niagara Region. Previously he served as an associate producer with CBC Radio in B.C.'s Interior. He also works as a freelance writer, contributing regularly to publications like GQ and Autostrada Magazine. You can reach him at coleman.molnar@cbc.ca.
