Nigeria-South Africa ties face fresh test over diplomatic conduct - The Guardian Nigeria News
The controversy surrounding Nigeria’s High Commissioner to South Africa, Femi Fani-Kayode, over the omission of his speech from a televised diplomatic ceremony has reopened debate about the fragile relationship between both countries and the conduct expected of ambassadors. While some analysts fault Fani-Kayode for allowing temperament to overshadow his diplomatic engagement, others defend his protest as a legitimate response to perceived disrespect against Nigeria, BRIDGET CHIEDU ONOCHIE reports.
Nigeria’s diplomatic relationship with South Africa faces another test following a public disagreement involving the newly appointed High Commissioner to Pretoria, Femi Fani-Kayode, whose reaction to the omission of his speech from a televised presentation of Letters of Credence has generated questions about diplomatic conduct, national dignity and the management of bilateral relations.
At the centre of the controversy is the balance between defending a country’s interests and observing the restraint, discretion and tact expected of its diplomatic representatives. While some Nigerians have applauded Fani-Kayode for challenging what they consider an act of discrimination against Nigeria, others believe his public confrontation with South African officials was unnecessary and could complicate efforts to rebuild confidence between the two countries.
The incident occurred during the presentation of Letters of Credence by representatives of 15 countries to South African President Cyril Ramaphosa at the Sefako Makgatho Presidential Guest House in Pretoria. The ceremony formally marked the commencement of Fani-Kayode’s diplomatic assignment.
According to the envoy, the livestream was interrupted during the address of the French ambassador, Antoine Michon, before switching to Ramaphosa’s address to the diplomats. He subsequently took to his official X account to complain that Nigeria was the only country whose presentation was excluded from the broadcast.
Fani-Kayode described the omission as particularly disturbing, considering that Nigeria had not had a substantive ambassador in South Africa for four years and that the occasion represented an important moment in the relationship between both countries.
He alleged that the exclusion suggested that some elements in South Africa were uncomfortable with Nigeria’s presence, insisting that he would not tolerate any perceived disrespect towards the Nigerian government or its citizens.
The envoy also disclosed that he raised the matter directly with Ramaphosa during a subsequent photo session, prompting the South African President to direct that the issue be addressed. However, Fani-Kayode maintained that the intervention came too late to restore Nigeria’s presentation to the original livestream. He also declined an interview request from the South African Broadcasting Corporation (SABC), citing the treatment of the Nigerian delegation.
The controversy subsequently took another turn when the South African government released the full recording of the ceremony, including Fani-Kayode’s address, about two hours after his complaint.
In his speech, the Nigerian envoy recalled his country’s historical support for South Africa during the struggle against apartheid, emphasising the sacrifices Nigeria made in the fight against racial discrimination and minority rule.
He described both countries as historic partners whose cooperation remained critical to Africa’s political and economic future. He also pledged to rebuild confidence, address existing concerns and establish stronger channels of engagement.
The South African government, however, took exception to the manner in which the envoy handled the complaint. President Ramaphosa’s spokesperson, Vincent Magwenya, described Fani-Kayode’s response as inappropriate, arguing that the envoy misunderstood the circumstances surrounding the broadcast disruption.
Magwenya also rejected any suggestion that Ramaphosa interfered with the editorial decisions or operations of the SABC, urging the Nigerian envoy to familiarise himself with South Africa’s institutions and constitutional framework. He further criticised Fani-Kayode for declining to speak with former international news editor of SABC News, Sophie Mokoena, who, he argued, could have helped clarify the circumstances surrounding the broadcast.
The presidential spokesperson described the incident as a minor operational issue that had been misunderstood and advised the envoy to establish a professional relationship with the broadcaster and pursue complaints through constructive engagement.
The SABC, in a separate statement, also denied failing to cover the ceremony, explaining that the event was aired on its SABC News LIVE channel on SABC+, while the High Commissioner’s arrival was featured during a live crossing on its DStv Channel 404. The broadcaster also published a video clip on its official X account showing Fani-Kayode interacting with Ramaphosa.
Beyond the disagreement over the broadcast, however, the incident has exposed the delicate nature of Nigeria-South Africa relations and the challenges confronting efforts to sustain a mutually beneficial partnership.
Both countries have had periods of tension over issues ranging from xenophobic attacks against Nigerians and other African nationals in South Africa to economic competition, immigration and diplomatic disagreements. Nigeria’s historical contribution to the anti-apartheid struggle has also remained an important reference point in its engagement with Pretoria.
Against this background, the conduct of the Nigerian envoy has attracted divergent assessments from foreign affairs analysts and diplomatic observers.
A retired ambassador, Ogbole Amedu Ode, questioned aspects of Fani-Kayode’s conduct, including his physical interaction with the South African President during the ceremony. He argued that patting the host President on the shoulder twice, even if the two had a cordial relationship, was diplomatically inappropriate in front of cameras.
For foreign affairs analyst, Paul Ejime, the controversy demonstrates how an otherwise legitimate complaint could lose its force when presented without the restraint expected of a diplomat.
Ejime argued that emotional intelligence, discretion and the ability to manage difficult situations are essential attributes of an ambassador, whose conduct carries implications beyond personal reputation.
He likened the situation to a student who, while reporting bullying to a school authority, loses the opportunity to be heard because of an uncontrolled reaction.
“What Fani-Kayode exhibited was lack of emotional intelligence, which a diplomat should have,” he said, stressing that ambassadors undergo training and orientation on diplomatic conventions before being deployed to foreign missions.
According to him, an ambassador cannot approach international assignments with the same temperament and style of engagement associated with domestic partisan politics.
He maintained that diplomacy is a rules-based discipline that relies on tact, engagement and soft power rather than public confrontation.
“The fact that you are the ambassador, the face of your country, means that a lot is on your shoulders. So, that will moderate and mediate your behaviour and utterances,” Ejime said.
further argued that Fani-Kayode ought to have established the facts surrounding the broadcast before making public accusations, noting that there was a fundamental difference between reacting impulsively and responding after carefully assessing a situation.
Ejime said the envoy should have channelled his complaint through appropriate diplomatic mechanisms rather than taking the matter to social media.
He also questioned why the disagreement had been allowed to degenerate into an exchange involving the South African President’s spokesperson, rather than being handled through established diplomatic channels.
According to him, the controversy could have been avoided if Fani-Kayode had exercised patience and sought clarification from the relevant authorities before going public.
“This is not Nigeria where he is known to be talking very erratically and becoming a rabble-rouser. This is not party politics in Nigeria. Once you have been appointed an ambassador, you must conduct yourself with decorum and follow what diplomatic convention says about how to complain when you are seeking remedy,” he said.
Ejime, however, urged the Federal Government to intervene and ensure that the disagreement did not undermine bilateral relations.
He noted that Nigeria made considerable sacrifices towards the liberation of South Africa and other countries in Southern Africa, but argued that historical contributions should not be used as a basis for demanding respect.
“Nigeria has contributed so much to the liberation of South Africa and many Southern African countries. So, even though they have not shown any gratitude, you earn respect; you do not impose it. That is what Fani-Kayode should understand,” he said.
However, global affairs analyst Anngu Orngu offered a contrasting assessment, defending the envoy’s response as a legitimate assertion of Nigeria’s dignity in the face of what he described as an inexplicable discriminatory treatment. Orngu argued that the circumstances surrounding the interruption of the livestream raised legitimate questions, particularly because Nigeria was the only country whose presentation was allegedly not broadcast live.
He maintained that Fani-Kayode was entitled to demand an explanation and should not be criticised for speaking out against an incident he considered disrespectful to the country.
According to him, the significance of the occasion made the omission particularly troubling, given the historical relationship between Nigeria and South Africa.
Orngu recalled Nigeria’s contributions to the anti-apartheid struggle, including political and financial support, as well as solidarity campaigns across the country.
He argued that South Africa should recognise the sacrifices made by Nigeria and accord the country the respect befitting a longstanding partner.
“Nigeria is not a country that should be looked down upon,” he said, adding that younger South Africans needed to understand the history of their country’s liberation and Nigeria’s role in it.
He also rejected the argument that the envoy should have remained silent in the name of diplomacy, insisting that the alleged slight had already occurred and warranted a response.
Orngu further argued that Fani-Kayode’s subsequent reaction was prompted by what he considered a misrepresentation of events by the South African President’s spokesperson.
He urged Nigerians to rise above partisan considerations when issues involving the country’s international standing arise, arguing that national interest should take precedence over domestic political differences.
His position reflects a wider sentiment among those who believe that diplomatic restraint should not be interpreted as an obligation to remain silent in the face of perceived discrimination.
Nevertheless, the controversy raises a more fundamental question about the responsibilities of diplomatic representatives and the extent to which public confrontation serves national interest.
An ambassador is not merely a representative of the government that appoints him but also the official face of the country in the host nation. His words and actions can influence perceptions, open diplomatic channels or complicate relationships that require careful management.
In this regard, the challenge for Fani-Kayode is not simply to establish whether Nigeria was deliberately excluded from the broadcast, but to demonstrate that he can protect the country’s interests without creating avoidable diplomatic friction.
Similarly, South Africa has a responsibility to address legitimate concerns transparently, particularly when they involve a country with which it shares a significant historical relationship. The release of the full recording and the broadcaster’s explanation may have addressed the immediate controversy, but they have not necessarily resolved the questions raised by the incident.
Ultimately, the strength of Nigeria-South Africa relations will depend less on public exchanges than on the willingness of both governments to address disagreements through established diplomatic channels.
For Nigeria, the priority should be to ensure that its envoy’s conduct advances rather than undermines the country’s foreign policy objectives. For South Africa, it is equally important to avoid actions or communication that could reinforce perceptions of disregard for a historic African partner.
The controversy may have started with a disrupted broadcast, but its implications extend to the broader question of how two influential African countries manage their differences while preserving a relationship that remains important to the continent.

