No fiscal dominance while Central Bank stays active, Guillen says - Valor International

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from G1 Globo (globo.com). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
As long as Brazil’s Central Bank remains active, the country will not face fiscal dominance, according to Diogo Guillen, the new chief economist at Itaú Unibanco. Fiscal dominance occurs when public finances become so unbalanced that raising interest rates causes inflation to ris...

As long as Brazil’s Central Bank remains active, the country will not face fiscal dominance, according to Diogo Guillen, the new chief economist at Itaú Unibanco. Fiscal dominance occurs when public finances become so unbalanced that raising interest rates causes inflation to rise rather than fall. In such an environment, increases in the Selic benchmark interest rate make matters worse by heightening risk aversion and weakening the currency, thereby fueling inflation.

In his first interview since leaving the Central Bank’s board, Guillen expressed greater confidence in Brazil’s monetary framework than in the trajectory of public finances. He argued that fiscal adjustment should take center stage in economic policy discussions.

Guillen projects a challenging outlook for 2027. Economic growth is expected to slow to around 0.5%, while inflation is forecast to accelerate to 6.1% amid supply shocks and currency depreciation. Although the bar for further rate hikes appears high at this point, the current environment does not allow for discussion of Selic cuts either, despite signs of weaker economic activity already emerging in the bank’s proprietary indicators.

In an interview with Intraday, the financial markets blog of Valor, Guillen said there is growing urgency to address the trajectory of Brazil’s public debt. In his view, a credible fiscal adjustment would boost economic growth and allow market interest rates to fall, easing the burden of debt payments on household income.

“As long as it [the Central Bank] does the right thing and people believe in it, the risk of fiscal dominance is reduced. That does not eliminate the urgency of the fiscal situation. And the deterioration of the starting point every time the discussion resumes makes the situation more urgent,” he stressed.

Valor: How do you view the U.S. economic outlook?

Diogo Guillen: Long-term interest rates have risen. Part of this is related to [Donald] Trump’s tariff and fiscal policies, but another part is related to investment in artificial intelligence. For the U.S., we expect three more rate hikes, and there is considerable debate over whether they will come consecutively. We are having that debate internally in light of the Federal Reserve’s most recent communications and the state of the economy: activity remains resilient in the U.S., and inflation is high. Overall, we are seeing a world in which interest rates are rising in several countries. Some are more concerned about tighter financial conditions, others less so. Some central banks are responding more forcefully, others less so. But this is a world of tightening financial conditions, and it remains uncertain. This international environment makes monetary policy difficult to conduct.

Guillen: From the standpoint of how the Central Bank sees things here, the outlook is challenging on several fronts. On economic growth, we have lowered our forecast to 0.5% [in 2027], which is lower than in recent years. Several factors help explain it, but financial conditions and the more restrictive interest rate are particularly important. We have already incorporated into this forecast a scenario in which interest rates remain unchanged at 13.75% through the end of 2027. There are two effects here: the first is the interest rate itself; the second is the fact that rates stay high for a long time. Imagine a family having to cope with this interest rate and its cumulative effects in an environment where households and companies are heavily indebted. Debt levels are historically high, as is debt servicing.

Guillen: That is the other element of the challenging outlook: high inflation. We have raised our forecast from 4.6% to 6.1%. Several factors help explain this, including the 6x1 work schedule, tax reform, and our assumption that subsidies for gasoline and diesel, which are out of line with international prices, will be reduced. These three factors—subsidies, tax reform, and the 6x1 work schedule—account for a large part of this inflationary movement. As for El Niño, the risk of a corn crop failure has eased somewhat.

Valor: These are points mentioned by the Monetary Policy Committee (COPOM) in its minutes, along with the exchange rate...

Guillen: In the case of the exchange rate, we have to consider the underlying shock, because the exchange rate is endogenous; it is already a response to a shock. Is it a confidence shock? We have to think about that. When looking at these different supply shocks, the textbook approach says you should “look through” them. But some factors make that more difficult.

Guillen: The first is the inflation expectations outlook. When expectations are de-anchored, it is harder to look through these shocks. Expectations were already de-anchored and have become even more so. The second factor is that many shocks are occurring simultaneously. This also makes it harder to look through them, because they accumulate and can have second-round effects. The third point is that these shocks are very difficult to measure. With a gasoline price shock, you can examine the gasoline component of inflation and measure it. With the 6x1 work schedule and tax reform, we will see a widespread increase in services inflation, and it is much harder to break it down and determine whether a particular increase is or is not the result of a specific reform. Several academic papers say you should look through these shocks, but once they start affecting expectations, you have to respond.

Valor: Would keeping the Selic at 13.75% at least through the end of 2027 already represent a strong response by the Central Bank?

Guillen: There is no denying that the interest rate is restrictive. The 13.75% rate [projected by Itaú through the end of 2027] already incorporates this scenario. This is a difficult environment for conducting monetary policy, with a widening output gap [greater economic slack], high inflation, supply shocks, and currency depreciation. We continue to believe the Central Bank will conduct monetary policy appropriately. It has communicated its position and expressed what it believes. There is an understanding of its reaction function, and we believe that will continue.

Valor: Considering currency depreciation and its effects on the COPOM’s inflation projections, how far are we from a renewed discussion of rate hikes?

Guillen: Market pricing already reflects some probability of an increase. A discussion of rate hikes would be more likely if we saw a sudden exchange rate movement rather than just underlying inflationary pressures. In addition, another discussion that needs to begin is about how much of this reflects supply shocks and whether the Central Bank should respond to them. Our forecast is for inflation of 6.1% [in 2027]. If we remove some of the supply shocks described in the statement, we would be talking about inflation slightly below 5%, since I am including tax reform, which is not part of the COPOM’s communication. We will also need to discuss how to understand the supply shock, quantify its impact, and assess how it is transmitted across different time horizons, so that we can align our understanding of the Central Bank’s reaction function.

Valor: The market’s perception is that the COPOM’s communication does not signal much openness to further monetary tightening...

Guillen: The message is that the bar for a rate hike is high. The COPOM describes the Selic as “substantially restrictive.” The inclusion of supply shocks, based on the belief that they will not have second-round effects because activity is slowing, is another important sign that the bar for further increases is high. Obviously, the debate emerges when the currency depreciates, as it has to some extent in recent days. But the Central Bank’s communication has indicated that the bar is high. On the other hand, this is not a scenario that allows for a discussion of rate cuts. We are talking about de-anchored expectations and inflation above target, which makes such a discussion uncomfortable. Of course, everything will depend on how the economic slowdown unfolds. Our activity trackers for the third quarter are already negative. The IDAT [Itaú’s daily activity index] is showing negative figures for September, October, and the beginning of November. The slowdown in activity supports our scenario, but the inflation outlook rules out any discussion of rate cuts at this point.

Valor: Inflation expectations have become increasingly de-anchored. Does this reflect greater distrust of fiscal policy, or is there also a connection with the Central Bank’s credibility?

Guillen: When I was at the Central Bank, we went through a period of de-anchoring in 2023, during the discussion about the inflation target. The first phase of the Central Bank’s communication was an attempt to understand why expectations were becoming de-anchored and what the causes were. At some point, we said: “Look, expectations are de-anchored.” And given that they were, we needed to act. It was a communication process that moved from discussing the reasons for the de-anchoring, to acknowledging that expectations were de-anchored, to taking action in response. In the current situation, I am somewhere around that third stage. I do think we need to consider the causes of the de-anchoring in order to determine the best way to re-anchor expectations. But given that expectations are de-anchored, wages, for example, will be adjusted at those levels. That becomes the benchmark for price adjustments, and that is what the Central Bank has to work with. I do believe there is a fiscal angle here, and it points to something we have seen in recent years: contractionary monetary policy alongside expansionary fiscal policy. Under these circumstances, achieving the inflation target becomes difficult.

Valor: Is your main concern today the fiscal situation, or does the monetary framework also give you reason for caution?

Guillen: The fiscal situation is a concern. For me, the fiscal discussion is largely about what measures, both current and future, will be proposed to restore credibility. It is less about which budget line should be adjusted and more about identifying an adjustment that people will recognize as improving debt dynamics. That would allow long-term interest rates to fall, which brings us back to household indebtedness. It is through this reduction in market interest rates that families will pay less in debt servicing and devote a smaller share of their income to debt payments. For me, the discussion is about credible fiscal policy affecting the share of household income committed to debt and improving balance sheets. In fact, a credible fiscal adjustment package would boost growth because it would improve financial conditions.

Valor: And what about monetary policy?

Guillen: There is a lot of noise in the news about issues such as the inflation target, the monetary framework, and appointments. I prefer to focus on concrete facts and the historical record. Appointments have been based on technical qualifications. The inflation-targeting regime is a success in Brazil. Despite all the constraints imposed from every direction, the regime works and has been very successful. The monetary framework is very well designed: the decrees, the continuous target, all of it. So, I continue to believe it will remain in place, despite the stresses it faces. The same applies to appointments and the inflation target. The target is a continuous 3%. Period. The Central Bank takes this as a given. I support keeping the target unchanged.

Valor: At the end of 2024, there was considerable discussion about the possibility that Brazil was entering a period of fiscal dominance. Is that a cause for concern?

Guillen: One point I have been emphasizing is that people think we are discussing the fiscal issue all over again. This is not Groundhog Day, because the starting point is always worse. We are starting from higher debt, a larger nominal deficit, and a greater need for fiscal adjustment to stabilize debt. Things become more difficult every time we return to this subject. Regarding 2024, when I was at the Central Bank, I often said there would be no fiscal dominance as long as the Central Bank remained active. I still hold that view. I believe the Central Bank will continue doing what is right. As long as it does the right thing and people believe in it, the risk of fiscal dominance is reduced. That does not eliminate the urgency of the fiscal situation. And the deterioration of the starting point every time the discussion resumes makes the situation more urgent. This urgency is not just about the market “demanding” something. It is about the need to stabilize debt, allow interest rates to fall, improve household and corporate balance sheets, and revive private investment. That is the scenario that needs to be on the table.

Valor: With the low growth Itaú is projecting, is there any concern that the government might introduce additional stimulus measures?

Guillen: It is a false trade-off, because a credible fiscal adjustment will improve financial conditions, leading to lower interest rates and a recovery in investment. When I was at the Central Bank, I gave a presentation at the IMF [International Monetary Fund] on this subject, explaining how spending cuts can lead to higher growth. Of course, discussing fiscal adjustment in a slower-growth environment is more difficult. But we have to put things into perspective: fiscal adjustment must be credible to have an impact on financial conditions.

Valor: What about the fiscal package currently being considered by Congress? Is it a credible adjustment?

Guillen: It has a positive side, in that it allows the government to come closer to meeting or addressing the 2027 target. But the market response has not been a reduction in long-term interest rates. The package deals more with discretionary spending and less with recurring expenditure. When we want to genuinely discuss debt dynamics in subsequent years, we have to consider what happens during those years. There is some budget flexibility in the following years, which also raises further questions about the package.

Valor: Could the appointment of the next Finance minister generate some credibility gains?

Guillen: I think this is much more about learning what the main guidelines of the Lula administration’s economic policy will be than about the individual’s name. We need to see how the process of adjusting recurring expenditure, stabilizing debt, rationalizing spending, and improving spending efficiency will unfold. For me, the market will focus more on these major adjustment issues than on any particular name.

Valor: Is there room for the government to postpone the fiscal adjustment debate for another four years?

Guillen: The starting point keeps getting worse. We have a nominal deficit of 9%. That is why the situation is urgent. Fiscal adjustment must be addressed. This idea of kicking the can down the road and believing we can always resume the debate in a few years is becoming increasingly difficult, because the starting point keeps deteriorating. Fiscal adjustment is the issue at the center of economic policy discussions today. Monetary policy is not as prominent because it is currently being conducted appropriately. The focus is more on fiscal policy.

This article was translated from Valor Econômico using an artificial intelligence tool under the supervision of the Valor International editorial team to ensure accuracy, clarity, and adherence to our editorial standards. Read our Editorial Principles.

Original Source
https://valorinternational.globo.com/markets/news/2026/11/18/no-fiscal-dominance-while-central-bank-stays-active-guillen-says.ghtml
Visit G1 Globo ↗
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in Economy