Nvidia scandal shows short sellers are the heroes we need - The Telegraph
Jensen Huang resigned as Nvidia chief executive after a series of extramarital affairs Credit: AFP Andrew Orlowski Show biography Andrew Orlowski is a technology journalist who writes a weekly Telegraph column every Monday. He founded the research network Think of X and previously worked for The Register. You can find him on Twitter @AndrewOrlowski
The Bank of AI is looking for a new boss.
Nvidia, the central cog in the tech boom, is rudderless after the exit of Jensen Huang, who led the company for more than three decades until his exit last week.
The scandal involved claims of an affair with an alleged Chinese spy, triggering a frenzy in Washington to examine whether Nvidia’s highly prized chips were being used by Chinese AI companies.
But the most remarkable thing about the journalistic scoop of the year is that a number of suspicions about Nvidia’s China business had been flagged months earlier by a three-man research operation called Culper, founded out of a flat in Brooklyn.
Christian Lamarco, Culper’s 31-year-old founder, suspected that there was more than meets the eye to Nvidia’s sales story in China.
However, his resources were so meagre he had to pause the team’s inquiries. As the most valuable company on the planet, Nvidia had plenty of eyeballs on its accounts already.
“It’s just highly unlikely that you’re going to find something that everyone else has missed,” he told the press last week.
But in May, Culper published the results of its investigations in a research note, and it had a devastating conclusion.
Culper had followed the flows of money through sketchy intermediaries and shell companies, interviewing Nvidia directors, confidantes and its distribution partners.
They were particularly intrigued by the relationship between Huang and Alice Huang (no relation), a senior executive at Megaspeed, a Singaporean distributor.
Nvidia “has a China problem”, Culper concluded. “We are short Nvidia and think shares are headed lower.”
China has historically been a huge market for Nvidia, with more than one fifth of sales coming from the country.
But after new trade embargoes were imposed in April 2025, Nvidia said these had fallen to nearly zero.
Culper’s digging claimed otherwise. The trade simply continued by “South East Asian intermediaries”.
Some chips, known as GPUs, had found their way onto the mainland, while others were rented to Chinese AI developers from facilities in Singapore or Malaysia.
It’s this, rather than the spying allegations, that caused Huang’s demise. Somehow all this had eluded the big blue-chip financial analyst firms.
Culper specialised in short-selling advice, highlighting stocks that are “mispriced”, which usually means they are overvalued. Short selling gave it an incentive to find the truth. It’s a practice that’s widely despised, but which has enormous value.
Short sellers unearth information the market needs. There are always signs something is not what it seems, but the consensus chooses to ignore them.
By contrast, the market bulls and the techno-optimists simply want “the line to go up and to the right” forever.
There is no richer or more informative movie on finance than The Big Short, a celebration of short-sellers based on Michael Lewis’s book. It’s also the story of how a short fund almost went bust betting against the mortgage boom, before being vindicated.
Like Culper, Michael Burry’s Scion Management undertook its own research to corroborate their hypothesis.
A peppery short seller called Marc Cohodes blew the whistle on the crypto finance darling FTX. Cohodes had noted how the team had almost no experience at all.
“Nothing here fits. Everything reads like it’s a complete scam,” he said. Months later FTX collapsed.
When something becomes a matter of religion, as AI is today, you need the shorts more than ever.
Burry is short on AI stocks including Nvidia, while Steve Eisman, a former colleague who broadcasts an excellent YouTube channel, assigns a 30pc risk to an AI-induced recession.
Michael Burry, the founder of Scion Asset Management, foresaw the 2008 collapse of the US housing market Credit: Jim Spellman Ultimately, Nvidia may be the most consequential short bet of all. George Noble, the hedge fund boss and pundit, explained: “Nvidia was the bank of the entire AI trade, and the bank is now closed,” he wrote last week.
“Every part of this boom depends on a never ending flow of capital into AI companies, and Nvidia sat at the center of it by financing the demand for its own chips.”
Advances by Chinese AI engineers have made expensive chips like Nvidia’s much less important. DeepInfer, DeepSeek’s new inference engine, is an accelerator that performs at a fraction of the cost of rivals.
The past few decades have made us bubble-weary, as it’s been one after another: dotcoms, the mortgage market, green capital, crypto finance and now AI.
Each time, shorts are the small boys who point out the emperor has no clothes.