On welfare, Labour is suffering from political ADHD - The Telegraph

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from The Telegraph (telegraph.co.uk). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
Milburn insists investment must come first and savings later, while the PM is paralysed by fears of a backbench rebellion Credit: PA/Temilade Adelaja Camilla Tominey Associate Editor Show biography Camilla Tominey is an Associate Editor of The Telegraph and co-host of the Daily T...

Milburn insists investment must come first and savings later, while the PM is paralysed by fears of a backbench rebellion Credit: PA/Temilade Adelaja Camilla Tominey Associate Editor Show biography Camilla Tominey is an Associate Editor of The Telegraph and co-host of the Daily T podcast with Tim Stanley. She also hosts a Sunday morning politics show on GB News. During her 25-year career, she has covered major news events including 9/11, seven general elections and Brexit alongside being one of the world's leading Royal commentators. Her exclusive story breaking the news of Prince Harry’s relationship with Meghan Markle was nominated for Scoop of the Year at the 2016 British Press Awards.

I’m beginning to wonder whether the Government is suffering from a political version of one of the conditions it claims to want to tackle via Alan Milburn’s report on Neets.

The number of working-age people claiming benefits for conditions including anxiety and ADHD has gone up by over 50 per cent since 2005. Milburn wants private clinics that are helping to fuel the astonishing rise in such diagnoses, particularly among the young, to be defunded. But judging by the goings-on in No 10, the Government itself appears to have developed a particularly acute case of political attention deficit disorder.

I don’t mean that flippantly. I have considerable personal and familial experience of ADHD and understand that it is a complex condition. But it is difficult to think of a better description of the way this Government is operating. What we are witnessing is an almost adolescent combination of hyperactivity, impulsiveness and chronic inattention: bursts of manic activity, a succession of ill-considered interventions and an extraordinary inability to concentrate on the things that matter.

To be fair to Milburn, his report is a substantial and thoughtful piece of work. But it also faces two major criticisms: first, it doesn’t focus on what is perhaps the most pressing aspect of the Neet crisis, namely the growing cost of welfare for the young; and second, with its smorgasbord of new statist proposals, it will encourage Labour to ignore its own role in driving young people out of work.

With the Neet population having crossed the one million mark earlier this year, Milburn wants to get more young people into education, apprenticeships and employment, reduce the number who aren’t working or studying; and change the way benefits are paid to younger people.

The ambition is to get 440,000 more young people into sustained employment by 2036, increase apprenticeships by 100,000 a year to 270,000 and create 300,000 school-age work experience placements. Milburn also wants to halve the Neet rate from 13.4 per cent to 6.8 per cent. He proposes reforming disability and welfare support for under-25s, including a new means-tested youth allowance, an additional-cost allowance to replace PIP for eligible young people and new funds to support those with complex needs. He also recommends extending child disability living allowance from 16 to 18.

It appears quite radical until you drill into the figures and the familiar patterns emerge. The measures will save taxpayers just £200m a year… after a decade. As former work and pensions secretary Sir Iain Duncan Smith points out: “At £15bn a year, the annual welfare bill could be £150bn higher by the time Labour even begins to talk about savings in 10 years’ time.”

Milburn insists investment must come first and savings later. But that is just telling Labour what it wants to hear. Like Starmer, Burnham is paralysed by fears of a backbench rebellion, despite Labour’s sizeable majority. As a consequence, despite offering the illusion of activity, the Prime Minister is unable to take the bold and brave decisions needed to solve this crisis.

According to the Centre for Social Justice think tank, someone in work would need to earn over £33,000 a year to compete with someone receiving certain combinations of sickness and disability benefits. So where is the incentive to work? That is the first nettle this unfocused Government appears unwilling to grasp.

Overhauling our broken benefits system is a job for someone wielding a sledgehammer, yet instead we have schoolboyish Burnham showing off his pocket-sized Swiss Army knife. It’s the same with his £2 bus fares, clampdown on parking fines and action on “auto-renew” subscriptions. The Prime Minister is all over the place, listing a string of minor “icks” rather than facing up to the major challenges facing Britain.

Even Milburn has been forced to admit that Labour’s punitive employers’ National Insurance increase has been killing the very part-time and entry-level jobs we need to get young people off benefits and into work.

Yet is Burnham listening? According to James Reed, who has led Reed, Britain’s largest family-owned recruitment company, since 1997, hiring a young person has become virtually unaffordable under Labour. He calculates that the annual cost of employing a 21-year-old on minimum wage for 40 hours a week has risen from £17,035 in early 2020 to £29,654 today – an increase of about £12,600 a year.

Lionel Sheffield, who runs Rapid Recruitment in Cambridgeshire, has also crunched the numbers. Pointing out that the minimum wage has increased from £3.60 an hour in 1999 to £12.71 an hour today – an increase of 253 per cent – he rightly argues that higher employer National Insurance contributions have created a perfect storm.

Add in the additional health and safety regulations that have made it prohibitive to employ 16 and 17-year-olds during school holidays, along with employment rights legislation that has made bosses more wary of taking on those with no work experience and it’s a recipe for disaster.

To cut the cost of employing young people, the Milburn review has proposed some minor changes to employers’ National Insurance contributions. But its main idea is to pay businesses £3,000 for each eligible young person hired, with £2,000 premiums for certain harder-to-fill positions. Those hiring apprentices are being offered a measly £500 increase. It’s not enough. Thanks to three economically illiterate Labour Budgets, the cost of hiring a young person remains far too high.

So what we have in this report – as with almost all government policy – is tinkering around the edges rather than tackling the root causes of the problem. It’s a scattergun approach, with none of the proposals actually hitting the target.

And how long will this remain Burnham’s focus anyway? The Prime Minister will soon jet off to Brussels to engage in costly negotiations over a needless reset of our relationship with the EU.

Like a teenager putting off tidying their room, this Government is continually kicking decision-making into the long grass. To reiterate: there will be no savings for a decade under Milburn’s plan. It’s the same with Burnham’s much-trumpeted National Care Service, which doesn’t actually exist and cannot even begin to be put into effect until Dame Louise Casey delivers her final report and recommendations next summer.

And we still don’t know when we are getting the defence spending review. It’s all dog-ate-my-homework-style governance. It’s failing Britain badly.

Original Source
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/11/18/on-welfare-labour-is-suffering-from-political-adhd/
Visit The Telegraph ↗
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in Politics