Pagan worshipper found guilty of murdering Sonia Exelby - The Telegraph

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from The Telegraph (telegraph.co.uk). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
A pagan worshipper has been found guilty of kidnapping and murdering a British music tutor in Florida and sentenced to life in prison.

A pagan worshipper has been found guilty of kidnapping and murdering a British music tutor in Florida and sentenced to life in prison.

Dwain Hall, a 54-year-old roadside mechanic, groomed Sonia Exelby, 32, on a fetish website before luring her overseas to fulfil his sadistic desire to torture and kill her.

Sadist Hall persuaded Ms Exelby to pay him £3,000 to kill her after she had searched online for someone to do so.

During the four-day trial at Marion county judicial centre in Ocala, Florida, jurors heard how Hall manipulated Ms Exelby while she was suicidal into agreeing to travel to the US to be violently killed.

On Oct 10, 2025, Ms Exelby left the Portsmouth flat she shared with her fiancé and flew 4,000 miles to meet Hall at an Airbnb 90 miles north of Orlando.

Dwain Hall murdered Sonia Exelby in a rented cabin and buried her by the side of a highway After picking her up from Gainesville airport, Hall kept her captive in the rented cabin at gunpoint before fatally stabbing her two days later and burying her by the side of a highway.

On Friday afternoon, Hall was found guilty of first-degree murder and kidnapping by the panel of 12 jurors after just one hour and 20 minutes of deliberation.

He was impassive as the jury’s unanimous verdict was read out.

Ms Exelby’s two sisters and two brothers watched on in tears from the public gallery as the verdict was handed down.

Amy Berndt, prosecuting, said in her closing statement: “He took advantage of a severely depressed, mentally ill woman who was incapable of making any rational decisions for his own sadistic pleasure.

“That’s why we’re here today and this woman should be alive today.”

Ms Exelby, a “kind and beautiful woman”, was surrounded by friends, family members and had constant psychiatric and therapeutic support, Ms Berndt said.

“But no one could save her from the defendant, the ‘alpha sadist’ [as Hall styled himself online],” Ms Berndt said, pointing at Hall.

Dwain Hall, who styled himself online as the ‘alpha sadist’, faces life imprisonment when he is sentenced Credit: Florida Department of Law Enforcement / PA Gemma Isaj, Ms Exelby’s sister, told the court that Sonia shone a spotlight on the darkness of sadistic websites.

“A vulnerable person, a beautiful soul was taken,” she said. “Without Sonia, our lives will never be the same again. When this tragedy began to unfold Sonia really believed that she could stop others from getting hurt.

“Furthermore, she shone the spotlight on the darkness of such sites like Motherless. We will continue to fight for mental health in her name.”

Ms Exelby’s brother Barry Wilton said: “This last year has been one of the hardest of our lives. Losing our dear sister Sonia has had a profound impact on me and my entire family. I’m not sure we will ever be the same again.

Addressing Hall, he said: “Dwain, you pretended to care for Sonia. You didn’t at all. You used her to fulfil your sick fantasies. 

“You had her life in your hands. You had the opportunity to save her, but instead you preyed on her vulnerabilities and you took her from us.

“There will never be any forgiveness coming to you behind bars. May your actions weigh heavily on your mind for the rest of your pitiful life.”

The trial heard how Ms Exelby had struggled with bulimia, depression and self harm for all of her adult life.

In her final two years, Ms Exelby began seeking out men online who were willing to murder her.

“Unfortunately, there was no shortage of depraved men willing to kill her in the most torturous, vile ways possible,” Ms Berndt told the court.

Dr Jason Demery, a clinical neuropsychologist, explained how this compulsion to be killed served as a replacement for self-harm and was a desperate attempt at escapism from her mental trauma.

Sara Exelby and Gemma Isaj, who spoke to The Telegraph as part of a nine-month special investigation into the case, revealed that their sister had warned them in November 2023 of how she was being threatened by predatory men online.

They both testified to say the same during the trial.

The Telegraph can reveal the final message Ms Exelby sent to a friend on the first night she was held captive in the cabin.

Messaging her friend Ari Peturrsson, who lived in Sweden, she said: “I f---ed up really bad, I think it’s too late, I’m so scared.”

When Hall, wearing a starched light-blue shirt and pressed trousers, entered the courtroom at 8.20am, Ms Exelby’s sister turned away in disgust.

She jammed her fingers inside her ears to not listen to the four-minute video where Ms Exelby was forced to say she consented to the abuse in the cabin.

The cold rage on her face was visible when the prosecutor revealed that Hall had found it funny to record the video.

Original Source
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/world-news/2026/11/20/pagan-worshipper-found-guilty-murdering-sonia-exelby/
Visit The Telegraph ↗
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in Crime