Pagan worshipper ‘groomed Sonia Exelby to serve as her executioner’ - The Telegraph
A predatory pagan worshipper used a fetish forum to groom a vulnerable British music tutor into flying to the US so he could be her “executioner”, a court has heard.
Dwain Hall, a 54-year-old roadside mechanic, manipulated Sonia Exelby online for years, before arranging to meet her at an Airbnb in the woods of central Florida in October 2025 where he stabbed her to death, prosecutors said on the opening day of his trial.
Hall allegedly manipulated her into agreeing to pay him $4,000 (£3,000) in exchange for him killing her.
Ms Exelby, 32, suffered from severe mental health problems, including bulimia and depression, and had attempted suicide twice, Amy Beth Berndt, a prosecutor, told jurors at Marion county court on Tuesday morning.
Ms Exelby, the youngest of six siblings, was “unable to escape from the trauma of her childhood”, which was marred by her father’s drug abuse and her mother’s severe mental health problems, the court heard.
She was placed in foster care and then adopted at the age of two, alongside Sara Exelby, her older sister.
Ms Exelby had a history of severe mental health problems, including bulimia and depression Credit: Family Handout/PA Wire The court heard how she found an “outlet” by talking with people on an extreme fetish website, where she met Hall.
Hall, who had the online moniker of “alpha sadist”, met Ms Exelby on the Motherless site in 2023 and “manipulated her for years”, the court heard.
Prosecutors alleged that Hall was aroused “by the rape and torture of women”.
He allegedly targeted Ms Exelby “because of her mental illness” and “exploited her for his own sadistic pleasure”.
Ms Berndt said Hall “won the job of being Ms Exelby’s executioner”.
“She was brutally murdered by a predator, a man who called himself ‘alpha sadist’.”
Motherless, which has since been taken offline, contained videos of women being raped, tortured and murdered, as well as child sexual abuse material, the court heard.
Ms Berndt told the court that Ms Exelby had been talking with “many different men” and “trying to find someone to kill her”.
Addressing the court, Ms Berndt said: “She wanted to die and she knew she couldn’t do it herself. Unfortunately there was no shortage of depraved men willing to kill her in the most torturous, vile ways possible.”
Ms Berndt said that there were “many men competing for this job”.
Ms Exelby arranged to meet with Hall in March 2025; however, these plans fell through.
Stevie Hunt, Ms Exelby’s fiancé, who had been in a relationship with her since she was 17 years old and lived with her in Portsmouth, told the court that he had confiscated her passport for her own wellbeing.
Mr Hunt, giving evidence via video-link from the UK, described her as “the most incredible person I ever met, and I knew we would get through anything together”.
“She was the nicest, kindest person I ever met, her drive to overcome eating and mental disorders still inspires me to this day.
“She had so much love. She was an incredible musician and blew me away when she sang and played the piano.”
Mr Hunt, believing that his fiancée’s mental health had improved, gave her passport back so she could visit her sister Sara, who lived in Australia.
Mr Hunt described his fiancée as the ‘nicest, kindest person’ while giving evidence to the court via video-link Credit: Court TV Despite her family’s best efforts to support her with access to professional mental health services, Ms Exelby arranged to meet Hall at an Airbnb on the outskirts of Reddick in central Florida for the weekend of Oct 10 – the same weekend that Ms Exelby’s two sisters were due to visit her in Portsmouth.
Ms Exelby took a taxi to Heathrow airport and flew to Gainesville, Florida, arriving on the evening of Friday, Oct 10.
When Mr Hunt learned that she had not met her sisters, he informed police and gleaned from information left on her laptop that she had travelled to Florida to try and end her life.
Hampshire Police contacted Interpol, which alerted the Florida department of law enforcement (FDLE).
Gemma Isaj, one of Ms Exelby’s sisters, appeared in court to give evidence Credit: Court TV During the transatlantic flight, Ms Exelby emailed a letter to herself filled with “sorrow, depression, regret and death” that discussed her suicidal plans.
She wrote: “As soon as the wheels leave the ground, I can’t get off the plane, I want to beg for help so badly.
“Oh god, I feel so sick…why am I here, why? If I wasn’t numb I would have never got out of the house, this would be impossible, although I’m hurting more than I have ever done.”
Hall is said to have collected her from Gainesville airport after buying a length of rope, gun cleaner, a shovel and Paracord from a nearby Walmart store.
On Sunday, Hall allegedly fatally stabbed her four times with a seven-inch customised steel knife and posted the weapon to a friend in Ohio.
Police from the FDLE and the Marion county sheriff’s office detained Hall a week later by tracing a payment of $1,200 (£900) he made on Ms Exelby’s Tesco debit card.
They established that he had violent sex with Ms Exelby at the Airbnb, the court heard.
Jurors heard how Hall spent the first four hours of the interrogation “making up a wild, nonsensical story about why he was at the Airbnb and why he was with Sonia”.
Hall, the court heard, then “recanted” his entire statement, admitting: “I know Sonia. I have been communicating with her for years on Motherless, she came here to die.”
“He admits that he had sex with her in that Airbnb. He admits he hit her in the face, the breasts, the back, there was light choking,” Ms Berndt told the court.
“Ultimately he [Hall] says he helped Sonia ‘get what she wanted’,” Ms Berndt added.
Hall allegedly tried to erase “every trace of Sonia on his phone”, which included numerous nude photographs and videos of her, the court heard.
When police examined Hall’s phone, they found numerous images of women being raped, tortured, and murdered.
The prosecutor said that the evidence showed that the defendant had “beaten, stabbed, and murdered Sonia for his own sadistic pleasure”.
Hall has denied the kidnap and murder of Ms Exelby.
