Pat Cummins cannot survive as Australia captain after Cameron Bancroft’s explosive account of Sandpapergate - The Independent

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from The Independent (independent.co.uk). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
Pat Cummins cannot survive as Australia captain after Cameron Bancroft’s explosive account of Sandpapergate  The Independent

Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later? Start your Independent Membership today.

There was an interesting digression during Pat Cummins’ 68-minute press conference last week, when he angrily pointed to Usman Khawaja’s claim that Australia wasn’t ready for “a brown captain” as the most egregious line in Khawaja’s new book. Perhaps, as the current Test captain, Cummins was genuinely offended. But it also served as a convenient way of pointing in another direction, painting Khawaja as an outsider, pitting Australia’s first Muslim Test player against the great institution of Australian cricket, as a man with an axe to grind.

It helped to pose a classic ‘your word against mine’ scenario. Cummins says unequivocally that he did not know Australia were ball-tampering in South Africa in 2018. Khawaja says “it was all of us” and tampering was openly discussed in changing rooms. Who should we believe?

Except the problem for Cummins was that it was never only Khawaja. Cameron Bancroft had mumbled to the Guardian back in 2021 that the bowlers knew he was tampering, saying: “Yeah, look, I think, yeah, I think it’s pretty probably self-explanatory.” Bowling coach David Saker said back then: “There were a lot of people to blame”. Wicketkeeper Tim Paine wrote in his book: “Everyone was part of it to some degree.” Bowler Jon Holland revealed the team had discussed who would “take the blame” and said Bancroft, David Warner and Steve Smith had been “hung out to dry”.

Over time, the weight of admissions gently pushed against the walls of Cricket Australia’s conclusion that only three men ever knew. Those walls have given way to a flood over recent days as players long since detached from the Test team have spoken frankly on their recollection of that infamous tour.

Khawaja’s account was backed up by Warner, who called it “the truth”. The bowler Chadd Sayers was brutally frank, detailing the team’s plans to use sandpaper after umpires dropped the ball by the boundary rope. “I believe everyone in that side knew what was going on and what was being used,” Sayers said.

Now Bancroft has written a full, devastating version of the Sandpapergate story, publishing a 4,000-word account in The West Australian. “It was not just the three of us – Steve Smith, David Warner and I – who knew about me using sandpaper on the ball in South Africa. It was the whole team.” He said the bowlers not only knew but gave him feedback on his tampering efforts. “The final straw for me to write this account was Australian cricket captain Pat Cummins’ press conference,” Bancroft wrote. “It made me feel angry, betrayed and alone.”

It is Cummins who stands alone now. No one has rushed to agree with his press conference remarks. The most unified moment in his favour was a joint statement released with fellow bowlers Mitchell Starc, Nathan Lyon and Josh Hazlewood in 2021, which always seemed oddly specific, when they insisted they “did not know a foreign substance was taken onto the field to alter the condition of the ball”.

Cummins began his press conference by framing Khawaja’s accusations in precisely the same way, saying: “When he says ‘we all knew’ – if by that he means we knew sandpaper was going out on the field, he’s 100 per cent wrong. I said that consistently for the last eight years. I did not know that was happening.”

The Independent understands that the bones of that claim are likely to be true, in that very few players or staff would have known Bancroft had a piece of sandpaper in his pocket in that particular session on day three of the third Test in Cape Town. Starc reiterated the line last month, saying: “I’ll stick to what I said five years ago … We weren’t aware of anything being taken onto the field.”

But when the semantics were set aside, Cummins was directly asked the broader question. Yes or no, Pat: were you aware of any plans at any stage on that tour of South Africa in 2018 to tamper with the ball by whatever means? “No,” he said.

Amid an hour-long inquest, that one word was the most significant of all. Cummins denied all knowledge, at any time, of tampering, a claim directly and independently rejected by Sayers and Bancroft, one that goes against the weight of evidence building over time.

Cummins has not responded. His manager Neil Maxwell said on Wednesday: “Whilst we feel for Cam and everything he’s been through, there’s nothing in [Bancroft’s article] that hasn’t been answered by Pat in his press conference.”

The irony is that his press conference may have done more damage than the ball-tampering scandal itself. This was an Australian team who were callow and damaged after the retirement of some key figures over the previous few years, who sought to turn up the intensity and aggression in an effort to unsettle opponents. Once it worked, they took their win-at-all costs methods further, and further, pushing the limits of legality.

Neither Khawaja nor Bancroft have suggested the 24-year-old Cummins was a ringleader in that toxic culture. That, Bancroft wrote, was Warner. He also named head coach Darren Lehmann and bowling coach Saker as participants in the scheme, undermining Lehmann’s long-standing claim that he didn’t have prior knowledge of the team’s ball-tampering. Lehmann has now stepped back from his commentary role with broadcaster ABC.

But it is hard to see how Cummins continues as Test captain. His press conference was an attempt to shut down the debate and he was hailed in some quarters as “convincing” and “impressive”. It was certainly bold, perhaps even brazen. But, eight years on, Cummins is the man with the most to lose, and his decision to reject collective responsibility in favour of self-preservation may prove extremely costly.

Original Source
https://www.independent.co.uk/sport/cricket/pat-cummins-sandpapergate-bancroft-australia-captain-b3087067.html
Visit The Independent ↗
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in Technology