Pochettino has a big reputation but not enough on his CV to back it up - The Telegraph

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from The Telegraph (telegraph.co.uk). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
Mauricio Pochettino’s poor record in finals was laid bare in Chelsea’s League Cup defeat by Liverpool at Wembley in 2024 Credit: Getty Images/Chris Lee Jamie Carragher Show biography Jamie Carragher is a former professional footballer who successfully transitioned into one of the...

Mauricio Pochettino’s poor record in finals was laid bare in Chelsea’s League Cup defeat by Liverpool at Wembley in 2024 Credit: Getty Images/Chris Lee Jamie Carragher Show biography Jamie Carragher is a former professional footballer who successfully transitioned into one of the UK's leading football analysts and columnists. A one-club man, he is the second-longest serving player in Liverpool FC history and a Champions League winner. Jamie contributes a regular column for The Telegraph and provides coverage for CBS Sports' Champions League broadcasts in the US. He also serves as a leading pundit on Sky Sports' Monday Night Football alongside Gary Neville. His X handle is @Carra23.

It is ironic that in their latest attempt to rejuvenate and restore some of their old fire, Manchester United have turned to a manager whose career needs a similar reawakening.

Having dismissed Michael Carrick so early in the season, United can consider themselves fortunate that a figure of such clout and experience as Mauricio Pochettino was available and willing to leave his role with the United States.

Pochettino can be even more grateful that a club of United’s stature have turned to him in their moment of need.

United need a saviour to first ease them from the relegation zone and then revive their Premier League and Champions League credibility. Pochettino, meanwhile, needed a club like United to save him from a managerial career that promised more than it delivered.

The most successful relationships are often built on good timing. If United and Pochettino thrive together, a mutually beneficial alliance born out of circumstance rather than grand design might finally bring stability to Old Trafford.

Pochettino could not have imagined such an opportunity to achieve what he could not manage during his first two stints in the Premier League: evolving from a brilliant coach into an elite one who can win the biggest trophies.

Pochettino was unable to end Tottenham Hotspur’s trophy drought during his five years at the club Credit: Getty Images/Tottenham Hotspur The Argentine returns to England with a big reputation, but not enough on his CV to back up glowing testimonials. This must be one of his motivating factors – the chance to end any sniping and justify the claims of those who are adamant he is one of the most talented coaches of his generation.

It is indicative of how Pochettino’s career was going, and how quickly football’s landscape can change, that United overlooked his claims for the job on previous occasions.

Erik ten Hag was appointed ahead of Pochettino in 2022, and retained when Ineos considered its options in 2024. Then, sporting director Jason Wilcox preferred Roberto De Zerbi and Thomas Tuchel over Pochettino. United could not be criticised for focusing their attention elsewhere.

In Premier League and Champions League terms, Pochettino was in serious danger of becoming yesterday’s man, no longer perceived to be the slick, vibrant coach who so impressed at Southampton and led Tottenham Hotspur to the Champions League final.

Ten years ago his best team were the embodiment of him, full of energy, style and ambition. Time will tell whether this version of Pochettino is the one turning up at Old Trafford.

Pochettino’s Southampton caught the eye of Sir Alex Ferguson (above) and an unforgettable fightback in Amsterdam took the Argentine’s Tottenham side to the Champions League final in 2019 (below) Credit: Getty Images/Alex Livesey Credit: Reuters/Matthew Childs Cynics may look at Pochettino’s CV since he left north London and wonder whether the fire still burns. Arriving in Manchester might be the spark he, and United, have been waiting for.

The South American certainly needs to prove himself again. Although the United States impressed as World Cup hosts, United are not turning to Pochettino because of his international management career. In 2025 his side lost to Panama in the Concacaf Nations League semi-final, and Mexico in the Gold Cup final.

A recurring issue with Pochettino, which continued with the US team, is an inability to get over the line in the most consequential, winnable matches, resulting in a lack of big trophies.

An ongoing debate centres on whether his work at Spurs deserves to be acclaimed for the manner in which he built a side who were in contention to be English and European champions, or scrutinised more critically because they won nothing.

Pochettino knows better than anyone there was a moment towards the end of the last decade when he and Jürgen Klopp seemed to occupy the same space, most likely to go head-to-head with Pep Guardiola’s Manchester City. Klopp had enjoyed success in Germany, but in terms of taking the next step the question was who could win a Premier League or European Cup?

Their meeting in the 2019 Champions League final was a turning point. It is argued, with justification, that where Klopp had the backing of Liverpool’s owners to sign Virgil van Dijk and Alisson Becker, Pochettino’s board failed to show the same ambition.

Pochettino operated within a tight budget at Spurs under Daniel Levy Credit: Getty Images/Chris Brunskill While that explains Spurs failing to keep pace at the very top, it does not excuse their failures in the cup competitions – they could and should have taken at least one trophy. A team including Harry Kane and Son Heung-min simply had to win at least an FA Cup, League Cup or Europa League, or face being considered serious underachievers.

Among the teams who beat Pochettino in the cups were Crystal Palace (twice), West Ham United and, just before he left, Colchester United.

Whenever Spurs came up against Liverpool, Chelsea, Arsenal and United in knockout football, they could not get the job done. The same could be said when Leicester City lifted the title in 2016, Spurs finishing third when they had looked most likely to stop Claudio Ranieri’s fairy tale.

Pochettino won the league and cup at Paris St-Germain, but his reign was brief after struggles in the Champions League, his high-profile charges suffering disappointing results in Bruges and Leipzig, before a last-32 exit to Real Madrid in 2022.

Although his spell at Chelsea seemed to be on an upward trajectory towards the end, a sixth-placed finish did not convince the Stamford Bridge hierarchy that he had the mojo to bring the biggest honours back.

This history does not make Pochettino the wrong man for United. On the contrary, at 54 he is young enough to add to his story, and the wealth of knowledge he has accumulated might make him a better appointment now than he would have been five years ago. During his prime Spurs years, you could count me as a member of the Pochettino fan club.

What United are getting is a coach who looks and sounds the part. They have turned to someone who knows and understands English football, who will not be intimidated by the surroundings and size of the task and club, and who will stand on the touchline at Old Trafford absorbing the atmosphere with complete confidence that he belongs.

At clubs like United, that is a prerequisite which too many of their recent appointments have lacked.

Pochettino embraces United forward Bryan Mbeumo at the club’s Carrington base this week Credit: Getty Images/Ash Donelon Pochettino also has the benefit of joining at a point in United’s history where the bar is so low, he has time to make a few improvements in the knowledge it can have a transformative effect on the season. Had he taken over last summer with United having just finished third, the expectation would be much higher for a flawed team.

Bad as they have been so far, there is no reason why United cannot go on a winning run and at least challenge for a European place.

Beyond that, the question will linger as to whether Pochettino has the capacity to achieve more than steering the team away from trouble and thrust himself back into a position where he is considered one of the most talented coaches in the world, leading a team playing some of the most exciting football.

For now, one of the greatest and proudest moments of Pochettino’s coaching career is being appointed United’s head coach. This is his chance to write a glorious new chapter, relegating the near-misses to something of a distant past.

Original Source
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/football/2026/11/20/pochettino-big-reputation-not-enough-on-cv-back-it-up/
Visit The Telegraph ↗
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in Sports