Police ‘failed to protect free speech’ at Oxford protests, say peers - The Telegraph

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from The Telegraph (telegraph.co.uk). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
Protesters clash with police during a demonstration outside Oriel College in Oxford on Tuesday  Credit: 2026 Getty Images/Leon Neal Tim Sigsworth News Reporter Show biography Tim has reported on major news events such as terror attacks and elections. He can be contacted at tim.si...

Protesters clash with police during a demonstration outside Oriel College in Oxford on Tuesday  Credit: 2026 Getty Images/Leon Neal Tim Sigsworth News Reporter Show biography Tim has reported on major news events such as terror attacks and elections. He can be contacted at tim.sigsworth@telegraph.co.uk or on X @tjsigsworth

Police have been accused of failing to protect free speech after protesters disrupted a talk by a “race realist” at an Oxford University college.

Hundreds of protesters blocked the entrances to Oriel College on Tuesday night to stop people attending the talk by Nathan Cofnas, an academic.

Mr Cofnas, a postdoctoral researcher at Ghent University in Belgium, who is a self-described “race realist”, made the first accusations of plagiarism against Jason Arday, the late Cambridge academic.

His talk went ahead in front of a diminished audience after dozens of ticket holders were physically prevented from entering the college by protesters, many with their faces covered by balaclavas and keffiyehs.

Thames Valley Police is investigating two reports of assault, including one against an officer, but is yet to make any arrests.

Protesters opposed a talk by Nathan Cofnas about diversity, equity and inclusion policies in higher education  Credit: Reuters/Hannah McKay Lord Young of Acton, the founder of the Free Speech Union, has written to Jason Hogg, the force’s Chief Constable, in which he claimed police “failed to protect the rights of ticket holders and failed to maintain public order”.

Signatories to the letter included 27 peers, among them Lord Frost, the former Brexit chief negotiator, and Baroness Deech, the former principal of St Anne’s College in Oxford.

The letter, seen by The Telegraph, said: “The right to peaceful protest is important and we would defend it. But it does not include a right to stop other people from hearing a speaker, to assault those trying to attend, or to break into private property.

“If the police allow a crowd to decide who may and may not speak in Oxford, then the heckler’s veto becomes the law of the land, and no amount of free speech legislation will make any difference.”

Lord Young questioned the lack of police officers present at the start of the protest, claiming that the risk of disorder, and of attendees being prevented from entering, was “entirely foreseeable”.

The protest had been advertised weeks in advance, and a petition calling for the event to be cancelled had attracted more than 32,000 signatures. 

Protesters face police outside the Oxford venue Credit: Story Picture Agency/Charlie McCaldwell A similar blocking tactic had been used by protesters during a visit by Tommy Robinson, the far-Right activist, to the Oxford Union in June.

Witnesses have told The Telegraph that only a handful of officers were present at the beginning of the demonstration and were unable to stop protesters from blocking multiple entrances to the college.

Violent clashes broke out between protesters and attendees of the event. Video footage showed one man attempting to push through a line of protesters before he was repelled and shouted at. No police could be seen in the footage.

Protesters also attempted to force their way in through college entrances, with private security guards and college proctors forced to block their entry. 

At least four climbed on top of a wall leading into the college and unveiled a banner.

Police later sent reinforcements after receiving reports that “some individuals prevented guests from attending”.  It is understood that the additional officers did not arrive until around two hours after the protest began.

They were forced to push back protesters who attempted to enter the college, which was placed into an effective lockdown.

Only around 25 people were able to attend the talk at Oriel’s Harris lecture theatre – which has a capacity of 120 – where Mr Cofnas discussed the impact of diversity, equity and inclusion measures in higher education.

Paul Bradford, the head porter at Oriel, was reportedly injured during the protest while “protecting students and college”.

Lord Mendoza, the provost of Oriel, wished him a speedy recovery in a letter to the college’s students, according to The Times.

Mr Cofnas left the event under police protection. Attendees were escorted out of the college by security staff, while protesters shouted “shame”.

Only around 25 people were able to attend the talk at Oriel’s Harris lecture theatre after the protesters’ blockade Credit: Getty Images/Leon Neal Frank Zona, a PhD student who was prevented from attending the talk, told The Telegraph: “The police came completely underprepared. They were outmanned.

“Finally, when they got reinforcements, there were about 15 people manning the gate. They were immediately shoved through the door as soon as somebody had opened it, and were clearly completely understaffed and underprepared for this.”

Lord Young has asked Mr Hogg to confirm several details about how the police operation was planned and what would be done to protect future events that attract significant protests.

A Thames Valley Police spokesman said the force was notified in advance of the talk and that “we worked closely with both the College and the University of Oxford before and during the event”.

They said: “Intelligence is an important part of any policing operation. We work with a number of partners and use a variety of tactics to develop our plans, but will remain dynamic to respond to changes during the operational phase.

“On the day of the event, officers were in the area from 4pm. As the situation changed and crowd numbers increased, more officers were deployed to support. One assault and an assault on a police officer are being investigated. No arrests have been made at this time.

“Our role is to police all communities fairly and impartially and maintain public safety. We will seek to balance the right to peaceful protest with ensuring disruption to our communities is kept to a minimum.”

It is understood that the force sought to engage with protesting groups prior to the demonstration, but its approaches were declined.

Nathan Cofnas was the first person to make public accusations of plagiarism against Jason Arday in July Credit: David Rose In July, Mr Cofnas claimed he had put Arday’s PhD thesis through plagiarism detection software, which found that “many passages are lifted with minimal editing, sometimes retaining copy-editing mistakes from the original source”.

Arday, 41, the university’s youngest black professor, subsequently faced weeks of scrutiny and resigned. He had denied the allegation of plagiarism, but acknowledged making mistakes.

After the death of Arday, Mr Cofnas was suspended by Ghent University pending a “preliminary disciplinary investigation”. 

The university said it opposed “discrimination, hatred and racism”. Mr Cofnas claimed he was under investigation “for discriminating against Arday”.

He was ultimately barred from teaching on the university’s campus for three months, but was allowed to continue his research position.

Cofnas was fired from a research affiliate role at Emmanuel College, Cambridge, in 2024 after he claimed in a blog post that black people would “disappear from almost all high-profile positions outside of sports and entertainment” under a true meritocracy.

Cambridge’s disciplinary body later found that his comments did not amount to discrimination or harassment.

Original Source
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/11/18/officer-assaulted-protest-against-professor-arday-claims/
Visit The Telegraph ↗
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in Crime