Regulators move to curb conflicts of interest in bank product sales - Valor International

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from G1 Globo (globo.com). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
A year after Banco Master’s liquidation, a proposal by Brazil’s Central Bank and the National Monetary Council (CMN) to regulate the distribution of bank funding instruments is taking shape, marking a shift beyond traditional assessments of whether investments are suitable for cl...

A year after Banco Master’s liquidation, a proposal by Brazil’s Central Bank and the National Monetary Council (CMN) to regulate the distribution of bank funding instruments is taking shape, marking a shift beyond traditional assessments of whether investments are suitable for clients’ risk profiles, industry representatives say. The draft resolution put out for public consultation explicitly requires products to serve investors’ best interests and addresses conflicts of interest on several fronts.

The initiative is another regulatory step aimed at preventing a repeat of the excesses of the Master conglomerate, which sold large volumes of bank certificates of deposit (CDBs) through retail investment platforms and invested the proceeds in illiquid assets. When the bank was placed under a special regulatory regime a year ago, it left Brazil’s Credit Guarantee Fund (FGC) facing a bill of around R$58 billion.

The proposal fills a regulatory gap by establishing transparency requirements for banking products not covered by existing rules from Brazil’s Securities and Exchange Commission (CVM). These include CDBs and real estate and agribusiness credit instruments known as LCIs and LCAs.

One of the most significant changes would involve deferring compensation paid to distributors and sales teams, with provisions allowing for clawbacks. Industry participants understand that the rules would apply to securities issued both by the financial institution itself and by third parties.

The changes are outlined in Public Consultation 131/2026, launched shortly before the presidential runoff. The Central Bank will accept feedback until January 24, 2027, with the rules expected to take effect in early 2028.

The initiative broadly aligns with CVM Resolution 179, which introduced greater transparency requirements for products under the securities regulator’s jurisdiction and was implemented between 2023 and 2025. The regulation required investment distributors and advisers to provide greater disclosure of compensation received from securities sales.

Similar provisions were included in CVM Resolution 175, which overhauled the regulatory framework for investment funds. However, bank and financial institution funding instruments supervised by the Central Bank remained outside those rules.

Another change expected under the FGC reform aims to address investor behavior, discouraging investors from overlooking risks simply because an asset is covered by deposit insurance.

To prevent compensation structures from creating incentives that run counter to clients’ interests, the Central Bank’s proposal requires a balance between fixed and variable compensation. It also provides for reducing or entirely withholding variable pay in cases of inappropriate conduct by client-facing professionals. Commissions are expected to reflect product performance and risks.

The deferral of commissions came as no surprise. Such arrangements were already among the proposals discussed by associations representing banks and finance companies, along with major distributors, and submitted to the Central Bank, said a person involved in the discussions.

The source expects the impact on revenue to be temporary, particularly because the average maturity of funding instruments is little more than two years. “There may be an impact in the first few months, but things will then balance out. The earnings will still be there.”

The Central Bank also seeks to prohibit sales contests, bonuses, and non-financial rewards tied to specific periods. In principle, this would put an end to promotional campaigns offering upfront commissions of around 5% on sales of CDBs, structured notes known as COEs, or whichever product is being promoted at the time, as occurred during Banco Master’s rapid expansion. The draft also prohibits tied selling and cross-selling through inappropriate incentives.

“It is very clear that this represents a paradigm shift because the question is no longer simply whether the product is suitable, but whether it serves the investor’s best interests. It goes beyond transparency,” said Alessandro Chagas, a director of the Brazilian Financial and Capital Markets Association (Anbima) and an executive at Santander.

“The Central Bank also proposes ways to address conflicts of interest through incentive mechanisms and requires distributors to treat issuers on their platforms equally, and vice versa.”

To ensure compliance, the Central Bank will require two separate reports: one from distributors detailing their relationships with issuers, and another from issuers identifying the platforms through which their securities are distributed. Cross-checking the information will allow the regulator to map the market and identify excessive dependencies.

“The Central Bank is looking at this from the perspective of its responsibility for systemic risk. How dependent is bank X on distributor Y? If something goes wrong at distributor Y, bank X will face problems. So it continues to monitor all of this,” said Eric Altafim, an Anbima director and Itaú executive.

“I believe transparency helps the market mature, strengthens it, and creates room for further growth. The measure is a step in the right direction.”

Under the proposed resolution, clients would receive monthly statements detailing the total compensation earned by the financial institution, directly or indirectly, from their investments.

When distributing products issued by an institution within the same financial conglomerate, distributors must explicitly inform investors that the earnings accrue to the group that also compensates the distribution network.

Some operational concerns remain, however. One recommendation expected during the public consultation is to align reporting frequency with existing CVM requirements. The concern is that the new rules could result in duplicated work or redundant reports, Altafim said. Chagas added that there is clear scope for harmonization.

Despite the operational challenges, the Central Bank’s proposal is broadly consistent with discussions held across the industry since the Banco Master episode, said Everton Souza Gonçalves, director of economics and product regulation at the Brazilian Banking Association (ABBC), which represents smaller financial institutions.

“We had already discussed much of what is in these rules and submitted suggestions to the Central Bank, many of which were accepted,” he said.

“The biggest challenge now is implementation itself, understanding the details and assessing how to put the rules into practice. These are qualitative rather than prescriptive requirements, so they will need to be adapted to the size of each institution.”

Gonçalves noted that a key principle of the Central Bank’s proposal is to better align incentives in relationships between issuers and distributors, as well as between investment platforms and investors.

“There is also an underlying concern with competition and market contestability, to prevent barriers from emerging,” he said.

The measures complement rules already issued by the CMN, including leverage controls designed to prevent issuing institutions from expanding excessively by relying on FGC coverage. Regulators have also introduced the concept of a reference asset as a gauge of the quality, liquidity, and diversification of each bank’s assets.

The Brazilian Federation of Banks (Febraban), which represents major banks, welcomed the dialogue initiated by the Central Bank and said it shares the regulator’s goal of ensuring investors are properly served.

The association will work with its members to submit a “technical and constructive contribution that helps calibrate the rules in an effective and workable manner for the entire financial system,” it said in a statement.

This article was translated from Valor Econômico using an artificial intelligence tool under the supervision of the Valor International editorial team to ensure accuracy, clarity, and adherence to our editorial standards. Read our Editorial Principles.

Original Source
https://valorinternational.globo.com/markets/news/2026/11/18/regulators-move-to-curb-conflicts-of-interest-in-bank-product-sales.ghtml
Visit G1 Globo ↗
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in Finance