Reverse NI tax raid or watch 40,000 jobs disappear, Burnham warned - The Telegraph

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from The Telegraph (telegraph.co.uk). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
Szu Ping Chan is The Telegraph's Economics Editor. She has covered the main events that have shaped the global economy over the past 15 years, from the financial crisis to Europe's debt crisis and the fallout from the pandemic, breaking stories and interviewing many of the key pl...

Szu Ping Chan is The Telegraph's Economics Editor. She has covered the main events that have shaped the global economy over the past 15 years, from the financial crisis to Europe's debt crisis and the fallout from the pandemic, breaking stories and interviewing many of the key players along the way.

Tens of thousands of jobs in pubs, restaurants and hotels will be lost unless Andy Burnham reverses Labour’s jobs tax, hospitality bosses have warned.

UKHospitality, an industry trade body, urged the Prime Minister to back tax cuts that would benefit almost a quarter of a million jobs and help tackle Britain’s youth unemployment crisis.

The warning follows a landmark review by Alan Milburn, the former health secretary, who criticised the barrage of higher employment costs and regulations imposed on businesses.

Mr Milburn called on ministers to make it “cheaper and less risky” for businesses to hire young people, including by cutting employers’ National Insurance bills.

However, the proposals face resistance from the Treasury, despite sympathy from John Healey, the Chancellor, for efforts to tackle youth unemployment.

The trade body warned that another 40,000 hospitality jobs could disappear over the next year unless the Government reduces the cost of hiring workers.

More than 15,000 of those jobs are expected to be held by young people, worsening a crisis that has already left nearly a million 16 to 24-year-olds not in employment, education or training (Neet).

Mr Milburn proposed doubling the earnings threshold at which employers start paying the tax for workers aged 21 to 24 in hospitality, retail and leisure, from £5,000 to £10,000.

It would represent a partial reversal of Rachel Reeves’s £25bn raid announced in the former chancellor’s maiden Budget.

UKHospitality has estimated that the measure would benefit around 240,000 jobs in the sector and save businesses £170m a year.

Writing for The Telegraph, Allen Simpson, UKHospitality’s chief executive, warned that the Government risked condemning thousands more young people to unemployment unless it acted.

He said: “Let’s be clear, there is no Milburn review without the National Insurance cut it recommends. We will not get jobs for young people flowing without the high street and the high street won’t start hiring again without costs coming down.”

Mr Healey is said to be sympathetic to efforts to tackle youth unemployment, though Treasury officials are understood to be resisting plans to cut taxes for businesses hiring under-25s over concerns about the cost to the Exchequer.

However, Mr Simpson warned that refusing to act would cost the Treasury even more as young people are pushed on to benefits.

Nearly 100,000 hospitality jobs have already disappeared since Labour came to power, accounting for 45pc of all jobs lost across the economy during that period, according to the business group.

Mr Simpson said: “I would estimate, extrapolating the past two years of employment data, that we could see another 40,000 people lost from hospitality alone in the next 12 months unless we start to repair the damage. More than 15,000 of those, statistically, are likely to be young people.

“That’s more doomscrolling in bedrooms. More young people’s lives on hold and more benefits for the taxpayer to fund.”

He urged Downing Street to overrule Treasury objections and implement Mr Milburn’s recommendations.

Mr Simpson added: “This is a time for courage against intransigence. Downing Street need to face down the opponents of the review.”

The Treasury has been contacted for comment.

The UK faces a Neets crisis. That much is obvious. The real question is: does the Government have the courage to make the tough decisions urged by Alan Milburn in his review this week?

Young people across the country have been left without a route into work, education or training. Left doomscrolling in their bedrooms, according to Milburn, without any real hope of building the lives previous generations have taken for granted.

The review was absolutely clear on what needs to be done. Yes, young people need better support. We spend a fraction of the money to help young people into work that we did 40 years ago.

And yes, there has to be a bit of stick with the carrot. If a young person doesn’t engage with the system, there should be consequences.

But Milburn was clear too that for much of the economy, the cost of employing a young person has simply become too high. We have priced employers out of business and young people out of work.

His solution was a targeted cut in National Insurance costs, only for hospitality and retail, and only for young people.

Unsurprisingly, that’s the bit it seems the Government is less keen on.

In 2024, Rachel Reeves used the first Labour Budget in 14 years to raise employer National Insurance contributions.

She did it by lowering the threshold at which pay starts to be taxable, which meant that the effect on lower earners – young people and people working part-time – was more than twice the effect on people earning six-figure salaries.

The result was immediate and crushing. In hospitality alone, around 100,000 jobs were lost. The same story in retail. The high street as a whole lost more jobs in two years than mining lost in the entirety of the 1980s.

It was an unprecedented attack on a single sector.

For 20 years, hospitality has been a rare protection against the Neets crisis becoming a disaster – creating jobs where other sectors were automating roles away.

But consecutive Budgets in 2024 and 2025 all but reversed that.

Three things need to be true for a young person to get a job. First, the businesses which actually employ them need to be viable. Second, the cost of hiring a young person needs to be affordable. And third, you need to be able to hire and develop them easily.

Hospitality businesses pay 82pc of their profits in tax, which is higher than any other sector and twice the rate of banks. That figure has gone up significantly in recent years.

The cost of employing a 21-year-old is now 77pc higher than before the pandemic.

And the Employment Rights Act has made employers nervous of taking a risk on people without a track record.

Milburn’s solution of a targeted reversal of the National Insurance increase is modest against the scale of the problem, especially if introduced gradually over five years.

It will be a fraction of the tax grab of the past two years and easily recouped from higher tax receipts and lower benefits by moving young people back into work.

But the word from the Treasury has been that they oppose even this small step towards making first jobs viable.

Alan Milburn’s recommendation to ease hospitality’s NI burden is believed to be opposed by the Treasury Credit: Marcin Nowak/Anadolu via Getty Images White smoke in the press and to businesses has been that they are just not willing to make the investment needed to deliver job opportunities and a reduced benefits bill.

But let’s be clear, there is no Milburn review without the National Insurance cut it recommends. We will not get jobs for young people flowing without the high street and the high street won’t start hiring again without costs coming down.

I would estimate, extrapolating the past two years of employment data, that we could see another 40,000 people lost from hospitality alone in the next 12 months unless we start to repair the damage. More than 15,000 of those, statistically, are likely to be young people.

That’s more doomscrolling in bedrooms. More young people’s lives on hold and more benefits for the taxpayer to fund.

I know that the Prime Minister does not see the world this way and I’m not convinced the Chancellor does either.

This looks from the outside like a classic case of Treasury brain, where officials are more comfortable weighing the direct receipts of a tax than calculating the negative impacts, or indeed the positive ones from a cut.

It is the same mentality which led to them taxing away jobs in the first place.

This is a time for courage against intransigence. Downing Street needs to face down the opponents of the review.

Milburn was asked a question by the Government and he gave the right answer. It needs to be implemented without delay.

Allen Simpson is the chief executive of UKHospitality.

Original Source
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2026/11/20/failure-reverse-jobs-tax-cost-40000-jobs-hospitality-bosses/
Visit The Telegraph ↗
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in Technology