Ringmaster Xi puts Putin in his place at Shenzhen summit - The Telegraph

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from The Telegraph (telegraph.co.uk). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
Xi Jinping’s wife stands between the Chinese leader and Vladimir Putin in Shenzhen on Wednesday Credit: Kyodo / Newscom / Avalon Adrian Blomfield Senior Foreign Correspondent Show biography Adrian covers defence, politics and conflict across the globe. He has previously worked fr...

Xi Jinping’s wife stands between the Chinese leader and Vladimir Putin in Shenzhen on Wednesday Credit: Kyodo / Newscom / Avalon Adrian Blomfield Senior Foreign Correspondent Show biography Adrian covers defence, politics and conflict across the globe. He has previously worked from Nairobi, Baghdad, Moscow and Jerusalem

Vladimir Putin had craved this moment for years.

At long last, the man once denounced as a pariah had not only come in from the cold but also taken his place in the sun.

Around the kind of oversized table that in Russia and China has long symbolised might, he sat with the world’s two most powerful men, and they bestowed upon him the singular honour of treating him as an equal.

Kremlin officials had cast the three-way meeting between Putin, Xi Jinping and Donald Trump as a reincarnation of the Yalta Conference of 1945, when Franklin D Roosevelt, Winston Churchill and Stalin divided Europe into what would become communist and capitalist blocs.

Sceptics scoffed that the summit in Shenzhen was little more than a pound-shop knock-off of the original Yalta and that its significance existed largely in Putin’s imagination. Perhaps.

The three superpower leaders’ trilateral meeting at Kylin Villa in Shenzhen on Thursday Credit: AP/Sergei Bobylev There were few tangible achievements beyond a platitudinous half-page document denouncing liberal institutions, affirming the importance of “energy flows” and reiterating the familiar mantra that “a nuclear war cannot be won and must not be fought”.

However, for Putin, substance was always going to be less important than optics. This was an opportunity to show his people back home that there were just three powers of consequence in the world, and Russia was one of them.

He told Mr Trump and Mr Xi: “Our three states are united, not only by the status of being the victorious countries in the Second World War, but most importantly by the joint responsibility for maintaining international peace and security.”

There is little doubt, therefore, that Thursday’s unprecedented trilateral summit at the secluded Kylin Villa in Shenzhen represented a triumph for the Russian leader and a moment of quiet satisfaction for Mr Xi.

Quite what Mr Trump secured from the meeting remains less clear. In the view of some, the summit did more to damage the reputation of the United States than enhance it.

Mr Trump did not see it that way. True, his hopes of persuading China to join Russia and the US in a new framework for nuclear arms control came to naught. Nor did China show much appetite for his proposal that Mr Xi join him in trying to end the war in Ukraine.

The US president, desperate for a breakthrough on Ukraine that could potentially distract from the stalemate in his war with Iran, tried to steer his Chinese counterpart in that direction during talks between the two men before the trilateral summit.

Mr Trump said at the outset of the meeting: “We’re looking to both help with respect to the war with Russia and Ukraine. I’d like to see it ended. I think I can speak for both of us very much.”

Yet Mr Xi declined to budge, refusing to put Ukraine on the agenda. There was no mention of it in the joint communiqué afterwards, either.

Undeterred, the US president presented his visit to China as a triumph anyway. Had not Mr Xi broken with decades of diplomatic custom to greet him at the foot of the steps of Air Force One?

Mr Trump pointed to the elaborate military welcome he had received, the thousands of children who had lined his arrival route and the fact that he had been given a seat at the head table at the grand banquet, during which the pair watched a performance of the Village People’s YMCA set against a backdrop of images of Mr Trump and Xi together. 

The US president told Fox News: “That’s a big win for us. It’s a big win for China, too. We get along.”

It is certainly true that Mr Trump was welcomed to Shenzhen with greater fanfare than the Russian leader, prompting some observers to suggest that Mr Xi had deliberately snubbed Putin.

Unlike the US president, Putin had to make do with a more conventional airport welcome, greeted by a tall Chinese official who towered over the 5ft 7in Russian leader.

At a family photograph of world leaders attending the Asia-Pacific summit, on the sidelines of which the trilateral meeting took place, and a grand banquet on Wednesday evening, Mr Trump was given pride of place beside his Chinese host, while Putin made do with a seat beside his wife, Peng Liyuan.

It was conceivable that the Chinese leader was subtly attempting to put Putin in his place, perhaps out of irritation with the Russian leader. The trilateral summit was Putin’s idea, floated in October.

Mr Trump was all too keen to make it happen. Mr Xi was reportedly rather more reluctant, not wanting his summit overshadowed or undermined by two men known for their unpredictability.

Yet even if that were the case, little is likely to change in the way China views its relations with Washington and Moscow.

Mr Xi regards the US as an equal but a rival. Russia, by contrast, is a junior partner, albeit one with which Beijing has a vital relationship. Sino-Russian ties are arguably closer than they have ever been.

Whatever passing irritation he may have felt with Putin, Mr Xi recognised opportunities of his own in the trilateral meeting that was foisted on him.

In front of a watching world, he sought to present himself as a force for stability, in contrast to his two guests, both embroiled in reputation-sapping wars of choice.

More importantly, the meeting symbolised a levelling of global power, casting the US as no longer the dominant player, but merely one of three equals.

For two days, Mr Xi played the emperor in his pomp, welcoming the world’s lesser powers to pay homage. They included not just representatives of the 21 economies that make up the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation forum, but leaders from further afield, among them Mark Carney of Canada.

Leaders of middle powers seeking to hedge against Mr Trump’s unpredictability and hostility towards Washington’s traditional partners are increasingly choosing to court China. Yet there is a price for such diplomacy, one Mr Carney paid by having little choice but to pose on a stage with Putin for the summit’s group photograph.

For the Russian leader, sharing a podium with leaders who have spent years condemning him over his war in Ukraine was another moment to savour. In Moscow, it will undoubtedly be interpreted as a sign that international resolve to counter Russian aggression is weakening.

Mr Carney and Anthony Albanese, the Australian prime minister, who was also on stage, said they had agreed to join the photograph out of respect for their hosts.

Sanae Takaichi, Japan’s prime minister, went one step further, holding a 30-minute meeting with Putin – the first face-to-face talks between Russian and Japanese leaders since the invasion of Ukraine in 2022.

She had less luck in her quest to normalise ties with Mr Xi, with whom relations have soured since she suggested last year that Japan could respond to a Chinese attack on Taiwan with force. A tense encounter and a brief handshake between the two suggested there was little prospect of dispelling those tensions.

China found other ways to signal its displeasure with its neighbour across the sea. As world leaders arrived at the summit banquet on Wednesday, each was serenaded by a band playing a patriotic song from their country.

Mr Trump, for instance, was treated to America the Beautiful. When Ms Takaichi entered, she was treated to the strains of Sukiyaki, a 1960s hit inspired by protests against the US military presence in Japan after the Second World War. Few observers believe that a song rooted in opposition to the US-Japan alliance was chosen by accident.

Such frissons helped underscore the extent to which the summit belonged to Putin.

Slighted he may have been, but the Russian leader had secured a meeting he knew he could present as his apotheosis: a return to the top table of a world turning its back on the rules-based post-war order in favour of the transactionalism of great-power politics.

He secured it courtesy of a US president who, wounded by electoral humiliation, saw an opportunity to burnish his credentials as a diplomatic disruptor, and sought nothing in return for bestowing the most extraordinary of favours.

Original Source
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/world-news/2026/11/19/ringmaster-xi-puts-putin-in-his-place-at-shenzhen-summit/
Visit The Telegraph ↗
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in International Relations