Sara trial bares possible constitutional violation that SEC did not probe

MANILA, Philippines — The Securities and Exchange Commission has not concluded on its own whether Vice President Sara Duterte violated the 1987 Constitution by sitting on a company's board while in office, one of its officials said at her impeachment trial on Monday, September 21.

SEC Director Gerardo del Rosario said company filings list Duterte as a director of Metro City Chow Foods Corp. from 2018 through 2025. Duterte was elected vice president in 2022.

Del Rosario believes it is for the Senate, not the SEC, to decide whether her role breached the constitutional ban on the vice president participating in any business.

The SEC director was testifying as one of the prosecution's witnesses for Article II, which accuses Duterte of amassing wealth disproportionate to her lawful income and of having undeclared business interests. 

Senate President Sherwin Gatchalian raised the issue after Del Rosario confirmed that the filings for Metro City Chow Foods also list Duterte as a member of the company's compensation committee. 

Gatchalian asked whether this meant Duterte had "direct participation" in the management of the corporation.

"Ayon po sa report ng corporate secretary (Yes, according to the report of the corporate secretary)," Del Rosario replied.

Gatchalian then asked whether he can say it was a possible violation of the Constitution. "Kasi nakasulat ho dito bawal po 'yung participate in any business (Because it's written here that you're not allowed to participate in any business," Gatchalian said.

When Gatchalian asked again whether there was a violation, Del Rosario did not answer directly and carefully restated the provision instead: "Ang sinasabi po kasi ay 'wag kang magkaroon ng ibang opisina, you should not hold office, employment, and engage in other profession during the term of office, even to participate."

Asked whether the SEC had looked into the matter as an actual potential violation by Duterte, Del Rosario said they have not, as the SEC's investigative powers cover securities violations, not breaches of the Constitution by public officials. 

"Siguro po it's the Senate po ang bahalang maghusga kung talagang meron violation (Maybe it's the Senate who can judge if there is a violation)," Del Rosario said.

The issue first came up in the morning, when prosecution counsel Erwin Matib asked Del Rosario whether a vice president may sit on a company's board. The defense, represented by counsel Justin Nicol Gular, objected that the question called for an opinion from "a witness that is clearly incompetent."

Presiding Officer Sen. Chiz Escudero allowed the question, saying: "Because if it's indeed illegal, they should have flagged it."

Del Rosario first described the constitutional ban as covering business interests, not just businesses. After Matib read Article VII, Section 13 into the record, Escudero noted that the term does not appear in it.

"Wala po akong napakinggan sa binasa ni Attorney Erwin na business interest," Escudero said.

"Siguro po mali lang po 'yung aking pag-interpret in Tagalog po," Del Rosario replied.

Del Rosario earlier testified that Duterte was one of the company's incorporators and sat on its board from its founding in 2016.

She holds 20% of its subscribed shares, worth P50,000. She initially paid P12,500, and filings from 2022 to 2024 show her subscription fully paid. The company's amended 2025 filing, however, shows her paid-up amount back at P12,500. 

Del Rosario said the SEC only reflects what companies report.

He said the company posted a combined net loss of P3,154,676 from 2017 to 2025 and declared no dividends from 2018 to 2025.

abtestabtest Senate tackles today VP impeachment vote threshold By Neil Jayson Servallos | 1 day ago Senators are expected to go into caucus today in an attempt to resolve the question on the conviction threshold for Vice President... Headlines Legarda extends medical leave for sixth time until October 9 17 hours ago If she remains absent until then, she will have been away from the chamber for 72 days since her last plenary appearance on... Headlines ‘Sara briefed on sub judice rule’ By Evelyn Macairan | 9 hours ago Vice President Sara Duterte has been briefed on the impeachment court’s sub judice rule restricting statements outside... Headlines SEC witness: VP Sara a member of corporation’s board while in office By Ian Laqui | 16 hours ago Vice President Sara Duterte remains a shareholder and member of the board of directors of a Davao-based corporation despite... Headlines Latest More in Headlines DICT wants socmed sites to get congress franchise DOE admits no immediate solution to Visayas power crisis 6 new Philippines hotels awarded Michelin Keys DILG seeks to abolish access to nihilistic sites abtest Student cited for heroism during Cotabato shooting rampage By John Unson | 9 hours ago There might have been more casualties in the Banga, South Cotabato campus shooting rampage on Friday, if not for a brave student... Headlines LPA may enter PAR this week By Andrew Ronquillo | 9 hours ago A low-pressure area may enter the Philippine area of responsibility by tomorrow, state weather forecasters said. Headlines Feuding execs warned: Don’t use ombudsman By Ghio Ong | 9 hours ago State officials using the Office of the Ombudsman as an “arena” for mudslinging will be suspended. Headlines Government launches AI on eGovPH superapp By Rainier Allan Ronda | 9 hours ago The government has rolled out new artificial intelligence capabilities to the eGovPH superapp, meant to automate government... Headlines SC highlights importance of ‘justice zones’ By Ghio Ong | 9 hours ago The Supreme Court yesterday emphasized the need to enhance inter-agency coordination among government bodies handling... Headlines Recommended Sara retained business stakes after becoming VP 9 hours ago Despite constitutional prohibition, Vice President Sara Duterte retained her holdings in companies held by her family even... HeadlinesSARA DUTERTE ‘Sara briefed on sub judice rule’ 9 hours ago Vice President Sara Duterte has been briefed on the impeachment court’s sub judice rule restricting statements outside... HeadlinesSARA DUTERTE Who flags public officials' prohibited business roles? Not the SEC, says witness 15 hours ago Sara Duterte's trial surfaces a gap that SEC has no mechanism to flag officials’ corporate roles for constitutional... HeadlinesCORRUPTIONIMPEACHMENTSARA DUTERTE Sara trial bares possible constitutional violation that SEC did not probe 16 hours ago Did Sara Duterte violate the constitutional ban on a vice president participating in business? HeadlinesCORPORATIONSINDAY SARA DUTERTESARA DUTERTE'S IMPEACHMENT Legarda extends medical leave for sixth time until October 9 17 hours ago If she remains absent until then, she will have been away from the chamber for 72 days since her last plenary appearance on... HeadlinesLEVISTELOREN LEGARDASENATE next Recommended Sara retained business stakes after becoming VP Despite constitutional prohibition, Vice President Sara Duterte retained her holdings in companies held by her family even after her election in 2022, an official of the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) said at the resumption of her impeachment trial yesterday. 9 hours ago SARA DUTERTE ‘Sara briefed on sub judice rule’ Vice President Sara Duterte has been briefed on the impeachment court’s sub judice rule restricting statements outside Senate proceedings, according to defense spokesman Michael Poa. 9 hours ago SARA DUTERTE Who flags public officials' prohibited business roles? Not the SEC, says witness Sara Duterte's trial surfaces a gap that SEC has no mechanism to flag officials’ corporate roles for constitutional conflicts. 15 hours ago CORRUPTION IMPEACHMENT SARA DUTERTE Sara trial bares possible constitutional violation that SEC did not probe Did Sara Duterte violate the constitutional ban on a vice president participating in business? 16 hours ago CORPORATIONS INDAY SARA DUTERTE SARA DUTERTE'S IMPEACHMENT Legarda extends medical leave for sixth time until October 9 If she remains absent until then, she will have been away from the chamber for 72 days since her last plenary appearance on July 29. 17 hours ago LEVISTE LOREN LEGARDA SENATE OK Are you sure you want to log out? Yes No X Login Philstar.com is one of the most vibrant, opinionated, discerning communities of readers on cyberspace. With your meaningful insights, help shape the stories that can shape the country. Sign up now!