Senator-judges call out defense over ‘threats’ on AMLA records disclosure

MANILA, Philippines — Senator-judges of the impeachment court called out the defense panel for what they called veiled threats of criminal liability directed at the witness, the media and potentially the court itself over the disclosure of Anti-Money Laundering Council (AMLC) records.

This was after defense counsel Mark Vinluan on Monday, October 5, repeatedly asked witness AMLC Executive Director Ronel Buenaventura about the strict confidentiality provisions of Sections 8A and 9C of the Anti-Money Laundering Act (AMLA).

Vinluan, during his cross-examination of Buenaventura, even read the penal provisions of Section 14 of the law aloud, highlighting that unauthorized disclosures of confidential information carry prison terms of three to eight years, hefty fines, and absolute perpetual disqualification from public office for public officials.

He also pointedly noted that under Section 9C, members of the media who publish or report such confidential transactions could be held criminally liable.

Vinluan’s line of questioning did not sit well with several senator-judges, who accused the defense of attempting to intimidate the witness and silence the press.

Senator-judge Raffy Tulfo was the first to openly express his frustration, calling out the defense for repeatedly badgering the witness, who had been on the stand since 10:00 a.m.

"I can see this defense is repeatedly badgering the witness... and I don't see any reason why the defense is repeatedly threatening him, even threatening the media, mentioning the P500,000 [fine]," Tulfo said.

"We already ruled earlier that the disclosure of AMLA records is allowed in this impeachment court... Give us a break, okay?"

Following Tulfo, Senator-judge Kiko Pangilinan also raised concerns regarding the defense counsel's repeated emphasis on potential criminal liability for disclosing AMLA records, noting that the witness had already clarified that his disclosure was authorized pursuant to a subpoena.

Pangilinan also pointed out that the defense had similarly questioned the House prosecution over the disclosure of AMLA records during House proceedings, expressing concern that the defense might also attempt to raise the issue of possible criminal liability against senator-judges during cross-examination.

“If the defense wishes to raise this issue, bring it to the Supreme Court perhaps. But raising the issue of possible criminal liability for authorized disclosure in this impeachment court, I believe, isn't called for,” Pangilinan said.

Senator-judge Vicente Sotto III reminded the courtroom of the constitutional protections afforded to the legislature.

"The counsels in the impeachment court should be reminded of the term parliamentary immunity," Sotto said.

Senator-Judge Risa Hontiveros strongly echoed Tulfo’s sentiments, defending the role of the press in covering the impeachment trial.

“Tingin ko rin po mali rin na kahit indirectly bantaan ng media sa pagganap nila ng kanilang essential na tungkulin na i-cover 'yung mga proceedings na ito,” Hontiveros said.

(I think it is wrong to even indirectly threaten the media in the performance of their essential duty to cover these proceedings.)

“Dapat po walang chilling effect na either sa sadya or 'di sadya na lilikhain sa hanay ng fourth estate,” she added.

(There should be no chilling effect, whether intentional or unintentional, created within the ranks of the Fourth Estate.)

Vinluan’s questions during his cross-examination came after the prosecution team, through lawyer Mae Divinagracia, asked Buenaventura about details of several bank transactions of Vice President Sara Duterte that involved foreign currency.

This drew opposition from the defense panel and some senator-judges, citing confidentiality clauses under the AMLA.

However, Senate presiding officer Francis Escudero allowed the discussion of its details, citing Supreme Court rulings that say that the AMLC cannot invoke confidentiality clauses under the AMLA to prevent disclosure of information on covered and suspicious transaction reports.

abtestabtest VP on Trillanes claims: Same exhausted lies By Bella Cariaso | 2 days ago Former senator Antonio Trillanes IV “has been peddling exhausted lies since 2016,” Vice President Sara Duterte... Headlines Jinggoy’s Senate office stripped before turnover By Marc Jayson Cayabyab | 15 hours ago Sen. Vicente Sotto III was supposed to move this week into the office of the Senate president pro tempore, which was occupied... Headlines ‘AMLC disclosure a dangerous precedent’ By Bella Cariaso | 15 hours ago Allowing the testimony of Anti-Money Laundering Council executive director Ronel Buenaventura in Vice President Sara Duterte’s... Headlines AMLC exec bares P4.4 billion VP, spouse transactions By Delon Porcalla | 15 hours ago Spouses Vice President Sara Duterte and Manases Carpio had a total of P4.4 billion in “covered and suspicious bank transactions”... Headlines Chiz calls for civility in impeach proceedings By Marc Jayson Cayabyab | 15 hours ago Senate impeachment court presiding officer Francis Escudero urged the public and concerned parties to let “civility” prevail over hotheads as Vice President Sara Duterte’s impeachment trial entered... Headlines Latest More in Headlines WATCH: Sara Duterte says Marcos behind allegations against her Remulla flags Customs' alleged 'lack of data sharing' in smuggling cases PAGASA declares end of monsoon ERC: No power disconnection until December abtest Chinese embassy on funneled funds: False narrative By Pia Lee-Brago | 15 hours ago Allegations that China funneled funds to a political faction in the Philippines are a “false narrative” and “malicious,”... Headlines Marcos accepts resignation of Marina chief By Helen Flores | 15 hours ago President Marcos accepted yesterday the resignation of Maritime Industry Authority administrator Sonia Malaluan, who... Headlines Marcos vows better benefits, career growth for teachers By Helen Flores | 15 hours ago President Marcos vowed yesterday to further improve the benefits and career opportunities of Filipino teachers. Headlines PCG: China disrupts law enforcement vs dynamite fishing By Andrew Ronquillo | 15 hours ago Chinese coast guard ships disrupted a Philippine law enforcement operation against suspected dynamite fishing near Pag-asa... Headlines Velasco couple a no-show at NBI probe By Mark Ernest Villeza | 15 hours ago Former House speaker Lord Allan Velasco and his wife Rowena did not appear before the National Bureau of Investigation yesterday,... Headlines Recommended ‘AMLC disclosure a dangerous precedent’ 15 hours ago Allowing the testimony of Anti-Money Laundering Council executive director Ronel Buenaventura in Vice President Sara Duterte’s... HeadlinesAMLCCONFIDENTIALITY Jinggoy’s Senate office stripped before turnover 15 hours ago Sen. Vicente Sotto III was supposed to move this week into the office of the Senate president pro tempore, which was occupied... HeadlinesJINGGOY ESTRADA AMLC exec bares P4.4 billion VP, spouse transactions 15 hours ago Spouses Vice President Sara Duterte and Manases Carpio had a total of P4.4 billion in “covered and suspicious bank transactions”... HeadlinesAMLC Chiz calls for civility in impeach proceedings October 6, 2026 - 12:00am Senate impeachment court presiding officer Francis Escudero urged the public and concerned parties to let “civility” prevail over hotheads as Vice President Sara Duterte’s impeachment trial entered...r HeadlinesFRANCIS ESCUDERO IBC-13 launches Senate TV 15 hours ago The Intercontinental Broadcasting Corp.welcomed the launch of Senate TV, a high-definition channel dedicated to the work of... HeadlinesIBC-13 next Recommended ‘AMLC disclosure a dangerous precedent’ Allowing the testimony of Anti-Money Laundering Council executive director Ronel Buenaventura in Vice President Sara Duterte’s impeachment trial will breach confidentiality, violate the law and disregard the explicit warning by the AMLC, the defense panel warned yesterday. 15 hours ago AMLC CONFIDENTIALITY Jinggoy’s Senate office stripped before turnover Sen. Vicente Sotto III was supposed to move this week into the office of the Senate president pro tempore, which was occupied by Sen. Jinggoy Estrada. 15 hours ago JINGGOY ESTRADA AMLC exec bares P4.4 billion VP, spouse transactions Spouses Vice President Sara Duterte and Manases Carpio had a total of P4.4 billion in “covered and suspicious bank transactions” from 2007 to 2025, an official of the Anti-Money Laundering Council told the Senate impeachment court yesterday. 15 hours ago AMLC Chiz calls for civility in impeach proceedings Senate impeachment court presiding officer Francis Escudero urged the public and concerned parties to let “civility” prevail over hotheads as Vice President Sara Duterte’s impeachment trial entered its 33rd day yesterday. 15 hours ago FRANCIS ESCUDERO IBC-13 launches Senate TV The Intercontinental Broadcasting Corp.welcomed the launch of Senate TV, a high-definition channel dedicated to the work of the Senate, now available on IBC Digital TV Channel 13.3. 15 hours ago IBC-13 OK Are you sure you want to log out? Yes No X Login Philstar.com is one of the most vibrant, opinionated, discerning communities of readers on cyberspace. With your meaningful insights, help shape the stories that can shape the country. Sign up now!