Senators grill Davao accountant on VP firms

MANILA, Philippines — Senator-judges yesterday zeroed in on the relationship of defense witness, Davao City accountant Vingelin Bajan, to the companies being linked to Vice President Sara Duterte in her alleged undeclared assets and hidden wealth.

During Day 41 of the impeachment trial, Bajan testified about the P64,194.72 “salary differential” paid to Duterte from her increase in 2020 and 2021 salaries as Davao City mayor that was belatedly paid to her in 2023 when she was already Vice President.

But upon the prosecution’s cross-examination, senator-judges learned that Bajan was a partner in the accounting firm Ampil, Elises, Ciudadano, and Co. CPAs while she was already a Davao city hall employee, constituting a conflict of interest.

The prosecution pointed out the link to cast doubt on her credibility as defense witness.

The firm turned out to be an external auditor for Duterte-linked firms GenCorp Industries Inc., Metro City Chow Foods Corp., Town Times Square B, City Hall King Chow Foods Corp. and Great Jolly Times Food Corp.

Senate President Sherwin Gatchalian flagged Bajan’s connection to the Duterte firms because of her double job as Davao city accountant and an external auditor partner.

Sen. Francis Pangilinan pointed out Bajan became a regular employee of the Davao City Accounting Office in 2004, while she was a partner in the accounting firm. She resigned from the accounting firm only in 2015 and was appointed Davao city accountant in 2017 by the Vice President herself when Duterte was mayor.

Senator-judges were irked by Bajan’s initial hesitation to answer questions about her double job as city hall employee and accounting firm partner by feigning ignorance about her signature on the partnership’s papers.

“My patience is wearing thin. Forgive me. If you were part of an accounting firm, it’s probably difficult to forget that,” impeachment court presiding officer Francis Escudero said.

Sen. Raffy Tulfo warned Bajan that she could be cited in contempt for her refusal to answer the questions directly.

Tulfo compared her to the defense witness on Monday, Davao city assessor Jaime Adalin, who also irritated the senator-judges for smirking at the court while dodging questions about an all-expenses paid trip to China.

“Yesterday, the witness was laughing his ass off. This one is very evasive, feigning ignorance. Why don’t we slap them with contempt so they will have some respect for the impeachment court,” he said.

Sen. Panfilo Lacson had earlier warned witnesses that they can be cited in contempt anytime if they continue their “mockery” of the trial.

Sen. Bam Aquino, meanwhile, appealed to Bajan to just answer questions directly, saying the senator-judges were not implying that she had committed a crime, although he warned her of being in “dangerous territory” by being evasive.

Sen. Risa Hontiveros said she found it hard to believe Bajan would not remember affixing her signature in her partnership with the accounting firm, as she also cast doubt on Bajan’s ignorance on the auditing services to Duterte-linked firms.

Bajan turned emotional during the interjection of Sen. Joel Villanueva, who asked her to convince him that she had good intentions as a government official despite moonlighting in an accounting firm.

Bajan said she had earned her keep by being a hardworking city hall employee in Davao, telling the senator-judges that she almost became a nun and was grateful she entered public service instead.

Sen. Lito Lapid, for his part, said he commiserated with Bajan, who was starting to look distressed at their questions on the alleged conflict of interest.

Lapid asked her if she was being used by testifying for the defense in the Vice President’s impeachment trial, to which Bajan said no.

In her interjection, Sen. Imee Marcos took up the cudgels for the defense witness, saying she was being asked about “collateral issues” not related to her testimony about the Vice President’s salary differential.

Meanwhile, the prosecution flagged what they described as “glaring discrepancies” in the testimony of Duterte’s witnesses regarding her alleged concealed properties.

Private prosecutor Benjamin Tolosa Jr. questioned the defense’s claim that the properties in Davao City had been declared in Duterte’s statements of assets, liabilities and net worth (SALN).

The issue first arose during the testimony of Adalin on Nov. 9, whom the defense presented to prove that a property in Matina Crossing, Davao City had been declared in Duterte’s SALN.

The prosecution maintained that the property, registered under Duterte’s husband Manases Carpio, had not been disclosed. The defense claimed, however, that it was listed under a different location description.

Tolosa said a similar issue had emerged over another property registered under Carpio’s name in Barangay San Isidro, Kaputian, Island Garden City of Samal.

During cross-examination, Tolosa established that Duterte’s 2025 SALN listed an acquisition cost of P4 million and an acquisition year of 2013 for the property cited by the defense.

But the deed of absolute sale for the property registered under Duterte’s husband showed a selling price of P3.4 million and was executed five years later on March 15, 2018.

“You will admit that the purchase price indicated here, it’s not P4 million. It’s P3.4 million?” Tolosa asked Island Garden City of Samal assessor John Kenneth Enumerables yesterday.

“Yes, correct, sir,” the witness replied.

The Samal property, covered by Transfer Certificate of Title number 142-2019013134, has an assessed value of P346,960 and a market value of P4.9 million.

“This property also, there are glaring discrepancies,” Tolosa told the court.

The disputed property forms part of the prosecution’s evidence supporting its allegation that Duterte accumulated at least P817.87 million in undeclared assets and unexplained wealth from 2022 to 2025.

Enumerables confirmed that the land titles he presented contained no annotation of a contract to sell. The property, covered by Transfer Certificate of Title No. 142-2019013134, is officially located in Barangay San Isidro, Kaputian, Island Garden City of Samal.

But the property cited by the defense in Duterte’s SALN was listed under Barangay Matanos, Kaputian. The witness earlier acknowledged that the two locations did not match.

He said he relied on the matching assessed value of P346,960 and market value of P4.9 million to link the property to Duterte’s SALN. — Delon Porcalla, Neil Jayson Servallos, Daphne Galvez

abtestabtest Defense: Sara did not get double pay By Bella Cariaso | 14 hours ago After presenting the Davao City accountant as witness before the Senate impeachment court, Vice President Sara Duterte’s... Headlines If VP quits, will impeach trial continue? By Ghio Ong | 14 hours ago It would be up to the Senate impeachment court to decide whether to continue with the trial of Vice President Sara Duterte,... Headlines LIST: Over 300 flights affected by ASEAN Summit in Manila Nov. 13–19 By Alyana Uy | 1 day ago Changes affect flights by AirAsia, Cebu Pacific and Philippine Airlines. Headlines Sara Duterte received ‘return of capital’ of 2.14 million from GenCorp. — witness By Ian Laqui | 20 hours ago Vice President Sara Duterte has received a “return of capital” from a corporation tied to her, according to the... Headlines Witness: VP got P2.14 million ‘return of capital’ from GenCorp By Neil Jayson Servallos | 14 hours ago Vice President Sara Duterte received a total of P2.14 million as “return of capital” from 2022 to 2025 from GenCorp Industries Inc., a corporation tied to her and her husband, its legal counsel said at... Headlines Latest More in Headlines ASEAN Summit: Metro Manila road closures, alternate routes, traffic advisories Philippines faces difficult mix of high inflation, sluggish growth — BSP NPC confirms data breach in 10 government agencies Marcos Jr. ratings down, Sara steady – poll abtest Philippines, Australia to sign defense deal By Michael Punongbayan | 14 hours ago The Philippines and Australia are scheduled to sign a landmark defense cooperation deal on Sunday ahead of next week’s... Headlines Sandigan junks Revilla bid to dismiss malversation rap By Daphne Galvez | 14 hours ago  The Sandiganbayan has denied former senator Ramon Revilla Jr.’s petition to dismiss the malversation case against... Headlines Macalintal appeals SC ruling on BSKE reset 14 hours ago The Supreme Court (SC) may uphold the constitutionality of the law fixing the term of barangay and Sangguniang Kabataan officials... Headlines Adjusted mall hours start next week By Andrew Ronquillo | 14 hours ago Mall operators in the capital will adjust operating hours to ease holiday traffic, the Metropolitan Manila Development Authority... Headlines Philippines ready to welcome ASEAN leaders By Pia Lee-Brago | 14 hours ago The Philippines will welcome heads of state and government to Manila for the 49th Association of Southeast Asian Nations Summit and Related Summits from Nov. 15 to 17 as the 10-member bloc faces many challenges in... Headlines Recommended If VP quits, will impeach trial continue? 14 hours ago It would be up to the Senate impeachment court to decide whether to continue with the trial of Vice President Sara Duterte,... HeadlinesIMPEACHVP Witness: VP got P2.14 million ‘return of capital’ from GenCorp November 12, 2026 - 12:00am Vice President Sara Duterte received a total of P2.14 million as “return of capital” from 2022 to 2025 from GenCorp Industries Inc., a corporation tied to her and her husband, its legal counsel said at...r HeadlinesSARA DUTERTE Defense: Sara did not get double pay 14 hours ago After presenting the Davao City accountant as witness before the Senate impeachment court, Vice President Sara Duterte’s... HeadlinesSARA DUTERTE Democrats won the midterms; that won’t change much for American allies November 12, 2026 - 12:00am Shortly after the Democratic Party won back the House and Senate in the US midterm elections, House Democratic Leader (and likely the next Speaker of the House) Hakeem Jeffries announced, “America is back...r HeadlinesCHINADEMOCRATIC PARTY Sara Duterte received ‘return of capital’ of 2.14 million from GenCorp. — witness 20 hours ago Vice President Sara Duterte has received a “return of capital” from a corporation tied to her, according to the... HeadlinesCORRUPTIONDAVAO CITYIMPEACHMENT next Recommended If VP quits, will impeach trial continue? It would be up to the Senate impeachment court to decide whether to continue with the trial of Vice President Sara Duterte, in case she opts to resign to avoid the penalty of perpetual disqualification from public office in case of conviction, a former law dean said. 14 hours ago IMPEACH VP Witness: VP got P2.14 million ‘return of capital’ from GenCorp Vice President Sara Duterte received a total of P2.14 million as “return of capital” from 2022 to 2025 from GenCorp Industries Inc., a corporation tied to her and her husband, its legal counsel said at the resumption of her impeachment trial yesterday. 14 hours ago SARA DUTERTE Defense: Sara did not get double pay After presenting the Davao City accountant as witness before the Senate impeachment court, Vice President Sara Duterte’s defense team believes that it was able to disprove that she received double compensation in 2023.  14 hours ago SARA DUTERTE Democrats won the midterms; that won’t change much for American allies Shortly after the Democratic Party won back the House and Senate in the US midterm elections, House Democratic Leader (and likely the next Speaker of the House) Hakeem Jeffries announced, “America is back.” 14 hours ago CHINA DEMOCRATIC PARTY Sara Duterte received ‘return of capital’ of 2.14 million from GenCorp. — witness Vice President Sara Duterte has received a “return of capital” from a corporation tied to her, according to the fourth witness of the defense panel. 20 hours ago CORRUPTION DAVAO CITY IMPEACHMENT OK Are you sure you want to log out? Yes No X Login Philstar.com is one of the most vibrant, opinionated, discerning communities of readers on cyberspace. With your meaningful insights, help shape the stories that can shape the country. Sign up now!