Shari Franke Gives Mom Ruby Franke Advice Ahead of Parole Hearing - Newsweek

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from Newsweek (newsweek.com). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
Shari Franke has some advice for her mother, former family vlogger and “8 Passengers” creator Ruby Franke, as she prepares to go before the Utah Board of Pardons and Parole: take accountability for what happened beyond your business relationship with Jodi Hildebrandt.

Shari Franke has some advice for her mother, former family vlogger and “8 Passengers” creator Ruby Franke, as she prepares to go before the Utah Board of Pardons and Parole: take accountability for what happened beyond your business relationship with Jodi Hildebrandt.

“In her mind, all her problems started and ended with Jodi,” Shari Franke wrote in a statement sent to the parole board ahead of her mother's December 7 hearing. “Until she realizes that is not the case, and acknowledges she has issues that go way beyond Jodi, I don't think she can fully heal.”

Shari Franke, Ruby Franke's eldest daughter, is urging the board to deny her mother parole, arguing that three years is not enough time to address what she described as a lifetime of harmful behavior.

“I believe she probably thinks she's sorry,” Shari Franke wrote in the letter shared by local TV outlet KUTV. “But 3 years cannot fix a lifetime of hurt.”

Newsweek reached out to the Utah Parole Board by email Tuesday and to representatives for both Shari Franke and Ruby Franke by email Monday for comment.

Shari Franke said she will not be at the upcoming parole hearings but submitted a statement by email outlining why she believes both her mother and Hildebrandt should remain behind bars.

Ruby Franke and Hildebrandt pleaded guilty to four counts each of aggravated child abuse and were sentenced in February 2024 to four consecutive terms of one to 15 years in prison, resulting in an effective sentencing range of four to 30 years. Under Utah's indeterminate sentencing system, the Board of Pardons and Parole determines how long offenders remain incarcerated within statutory limits. Neither woman can be released before serving a mandatory minimum of 48 months. Ruby Franke's case stemmed from abuse involving two of her children while the family was closely associated with Hildebrandt.

In her letter, Shari Franke described the last time she spoke face-to-face with her mother, roughly four years ago, as “the most stressful experience of my life.”

“She told me that through my speaking out against her publicly, I didn't want to be part of the family,” Shari Franke wrote.

Shari Franke said she was then cut off from her siblings for about a year and became increasingly worried that something was wrong.

“I want them to know I fought for them,” she said. “I called the police, I called CPS, I spoke to lawyers. And Ruby and Jodi evaded all of them.”

Shari Franke also described allegations of abuse predating the conduct for which her mother was convicted. She alleged she witnessed Ruby beating her brother Chad when they were growing up and said the siblings had discussed calling child protective services.

Ruby Franke was not convicted over Shari Franke's allegations concerning her or Chad's childhoods.

Shari Franke said she believes recognizing that history is essential if her mother is going to change.

“I will never accept Ruby's apology for what she has done,” Shari Franke wrote. “She has been a monster her entire adult life, and there's no way that's changed in 3 years.”

Shari Franke said she would be unable to attend her mother's hearing, although she did not give a reason in the statement provided.

Rather than appearing in person, she sent her comments to the parole board by email, KUTV reported.

Much of the statement focused on the lasting effect Shari Franke says her childhood has had on her.

She said she has spent three years in therapy and continues to have nightmares “at least weekly” about being trapped inside her mother's home and trying to save her siblings.

Shari Franke also explained how she has come to define forgiveness following her experiences with her mother.

“To me, forgiveness means I get to live my life in a way where I am not held back by Ruby,” she wrote. “Every year, I am a little happier than the last.”

“But I try to live my life in a way where her voice in my head has no influence on the choices I make,” she added. “That is forgiveness for me.”

Shari Franke was unequivocal about what she wants the board to do: keep her mother in prison.

She argued that Ruby would not have stopped abusing her two younger children had her brother not escaped Hildebrandt's Utah home in August 2023 and sought help from a neighbor.

“Ruby would not have stopped what she was doing unless my brother had miraculously saved himself and my sister,” Shari Franke wrote. She then made the stark assertion: “Ruby would have killed them.”

That represents Shari Franke's belief about what could have happened, rather than a finding by prosecutors or a court.

Shari Franke also questioned the depth of her mother's remorse, claiming Ruby initially remained “stoic and silent” in interrogations and only began talking and apologizing after learning that Hildebrandt had turned against her.

She further alleged that her mother emptied her siblings' savings into “a literal bag of cash” to fund her defense.

The family is now happier without Ruby in their lives, Shari Franke told the board.

“For the first time in our lives, my family is happy,” she wrote. “We are happy without Ruby.”

Shari Franke said she fears her mother could attempt to reinsert herself into the family's lives, either directly or indirectly, if released.

“I ask that the parole board deny parole,” she wrote.

Shari Franke also called on the board to deny parole to Hildebrandt, who worked closely with Ruby through the ConneXions counseling program before both women were convicted.

“To Jodi, my feelings are more simple,” Shari Franke wrote. “She is not sorry, and she is one of the most dangerous people I know.”

Shari Franke said she previously went through counseling with Hildebrandt and accused her of making her “feel small and insignificant.”

“She taught me to doubt myself, and judge others,” Shari Franke wrote. “She is a master manipulator who is good at reading social situations and can convey whatever she feels will build people's trust in her.”

Shari Franke then offered Hildebrandt some advice of her own.

“My advice to her would be to follow her own teachings: be vulnerably humble, impeccably honest, and personally responsible.”

Shari Franke said she believes Hildebrandt has shown no genuine remorse or change and warned about the consequences she believes could follow if Hildebrandt were released.

“I would personally blame the state of Utah if she were released and did something like this again,” Shari Franke wrote.

“I ask that her parole be denied as well.”

Ruby Franke rose to prominence through “8 Passengers,” a family YouTube channel that documented life with her husband, Kevin Franke, and their six children.

Her case drew national attention in August 2023 when one of her sons escaped from Hildebrandt's home in Ivins, Utah, and went to a neighbor for help. Police said the child was malnourished and had injuries, and authorities subsequently found one of his sisters at the home.

Ruby Franke and Hildebrandt were arrested and each later pleaded guilty to four counts of aggravated child abuse.

Both women were sentenced in February 2024 to four consecutive terms of one to 15 years in prison. Under Utah law, however, the state's indeterminate sentencing system leaves the Board of Pardons and Parole with a significant role in determining how long an offender ultimately remains incarcerated, subject to statutory limits.

Ruby Franke's upcoming hearing therefore represents a significant moment in determining how much longer she will remain behind bars.

For Shari Franke, however, the question goes beyond the crimes that resulted in her mother's imprisonment.

“She is not in prison for what she did to me or my brother Chad growing up, but she has never taken accountability for that,” Shari Franke wrote.

Her message to the board was that accountability, rather than simply time served or an apology, should be central to the decision about her mother's future.

“But 3 years cannot fix a lifetime of hurt,” she said.

Newsweek’s reporters and editors used Martyn, our AI assistant, to produce this story. Learn more about Martynhere.

Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Hollie Silverman and Rhian Morgan.

Original Source
https://www.newsweek.com/shari-franke-gives-mom-ruby-franke-advice-ahead-of-parole-hearing-12730654
Visit Newsweek ↗
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in Crime