‘She believed it was wrong’: The team staffer who spoke up against sandpaper
In the week before the third Test at Newlands in 2018, Australian team media manager Kate Hutchison dropped her own bombshell.
Over lunch in Stellenbosch, a famed wine region just east of Cape Town, she told reporters covering the series that she was resigning after six years with Cricket Australia.
She was leaving not as a result of the Australian team’s use of sandpaper to tamper with the ball, which we now know had been going on since the previous match in Port Elizabeth, now known as Gqeberha.
Instead, she had tired of their out-of-control behaviour, which had spiralled in South Africa, and of the demands of being on the road for more than half the year.
Eight years later, Hutchison has been cast by Cameron Bancroft as the lone voice of dissent against Australia’s ploy to cheat on the tour by using sandpaper to rough up one side of the ball.
In a blow-by-blow account of the scandal that has propelled CA and the Test captaincy of Pat Cummins into crisis, the former opener describes Hutchison “expressing her objection to what was happening” in a team huddle on the morning of day three in Gqeberha.
Kate Hutchison with then-captain Steve Smith at Adelaide Oval in 2017.Ryan PierseHis use of sandpaper late on day two was being discussed in the group at the time, Bancroft said.
“I recall her making it clear that she believed it was wrong, that she wanted nothing to do with it, and walking away from the discussion,” he said of Hutchison.
“I will never forget that. Somebody had spoken up. Somebody had demonstrated that being part of the team did not mean having to accept everything the team was doing. And I ignored it.”
Bancroft also referred to a conversation with Hutchison at training before the next Test in Cape Town, where he was caught with sandpaper on the field.
“I asked what would happen if I was caught tampering with the ball. She did not want to engage in that conversation because of the seriousness of the consequences, but her response was, ‘Not good’, and she walked off,” he said.
Hutchison, who went on to work for Swimming Australia and the AFL and is now head of corporate communications for the RACV, declined to comment on Thursday.
Sources who spoke on the condition of anonymity said she has no dispute with Bancroft’s account but is uncomfortable being presented as a moral compass of some kind after the fact. Like most media managers, she has no desire to be the story herself.
A straight shooter, it comes as little surprise to those who know Hutchison that she would have spoken up about what she thought.
Kate Hutchison (right) with swimmer Ariarne Titmus at the Australian Open last year.Getty ImagesAs a media professional, her role didn’t involve being present when the team was devising or discussing tactics.
But she would have been acutely aware that such brazen manipulation of the ball could backfire publicly if it was exposed, although even she could not have anticipated the extent of the fallout and for how long it would endure.
Hutchison, like many in the 30-plus touring party in South Africa of players, coaches and staff, has wrestled with the events of 2018 while abiding by an effective omertà in the years since, according to the same sources.
A New Zealander who joined CA in 2012 and handled media duties for an Australian under-19s tour and a women’s World Cup before joining the men’s team set-up, she had come under intense scrutiny at the time over the notorious press conference at Newlands in which Bancroft and Steve Smith lied.
Darren Lehmann (right) and bowling coach David Saker have been drawn into the scandal by Cameron Bancroft.APTheir dishonesty dug them into a deeper hole and was such a disaster that one leading television newsman said the media manager should be sacked.
However, it had long been suggested that Smith had been advised not to go to the press conference that day while in such an emotional state, and Usman Khawaja confirmed in his autobiography that he and Hutchison had tried to talk the captain out of it.
When it became clear that there was no changing Smith’s mind, it’s understood she was among those who urged him and Bancroft not to lie. This masthead revealed last week that bowling coach David Saker had allegedly told them “You can’t say sandpaper”, and Bancroft recalls Saker “specifically warning against identifying sandpaper as the material used”.
The fact that they followed that advice – and overlooked the counsel of others – is evidence of the culture of denial and the toxic bubble that existed around the team under the control of head coach Darren Lehmann.
Bancroft said he “cannot speak for Kate’s thoughts beyond what I remember her saying and doing” and that “she deserves the opportunity to give her own account”.
Having well and truly moved on from her stint with cricket, Hutchison has no intention of doing that.
There are no heroes in this whole sorry affair, but she at least comes out of it on the right side of history.
You have reached your maximum number of saved items.
Remove items from your saved list to add more.
You've used all of your gift articles. 3 more will become available on the 1st of every month.
