Shiv Sena tears pages from Sonia Gandhi's book over Savarkar remarks, demands ban
The Eknath Shinde-led Shiv Sena on Wednesday launched a protest against Sonia Gandhi's memoir, tearing pages from the book over remarks on Hindutva ideologue VD Savarkar and demanding its withdrawal from circulation in Maharashtra. Accusing the Congress leader of insulting Savarkar and undermining Marathi pride, the party sought the removal of two contentious passages from the memoir, Belonging: A Journey of Love.
The party also demanded that circulation of the book be stopped in Maharashtra until the publisher makes the necessary corrections. Shiv Sena leaders Sanjay Nirupam, Shaina NC, Anand Dubey and others participated in the protest.
The controversy centres on remarks about Savarkar, who was from Maharashtra and the RSS in two passages cited by the protesters, appearing on pages 201 and 443 of the book.
On page 201, while mentioning Indira Gandhi's antipathy to the politics of the RSS, Sonia Gandhi wrote that while Congress freedom fighters were facing assaults and imprisonment under British rule, senior RSS ideologues such as Savarkar were writing mercy petitions to the colonial authorities.
"While Congress freedom fighters were enduring assaults and imprisonment at the hands of the British rulers, senior ideologues of the RSS like Vinayak Damodar Savarkar were writing mercy petitions to their colonial masters and their members were colluding with the British authorities as informers," the passage reads.
Another passage, on page 443, describes Savarkar as the founder of the ideology of Hindutva and says his vision viewed India primarily as a nation where Hindus were supreme. It further links this outlook to the RSS, the BJP and their affiliates, collectively referred to as the Sangh Parivar.
"That ideology dismisses the delineation of the country and the rights of its citizens set down in the Constitution as ideas opposed to the ethos of Hindu civilisation, ideas they dismiss as being derived from Western countries with fundamentally alien values," the book said.
Reacting to the passages, Shiv Sena leader Sanjay Nirupam launched a sharp attack on Sonia Gandhi, describing the book as "Belonging: A Journey of Hate" rather than Belonging: A Journey of Love.
"Sonia Gandhi harbours deep hatred towards the freedom fighters and revolutionaries of this country. She also has hatred towards the country and its Hindus," Nirupam said.
He accused the Congress leader of insulting Savarkar through her remarks and said the party had gathered to protest against the alleged disrespect.
"As a mark of protest, we tore out the page of the book that contains the insulting remarks about Savarkar," he said. "The Shiv Sena in Maharashtra will not tolerate any insult to Savarkar".
Nirupam outlined three demands on behalf of the party. First, HarperCollins should withdraw the book and remove all pages containing what the party considers derogatory remarks about Savarkar. Second, circulation of the book in Maharashtra should be stopped until the necessary corrections are made. Third, the party would take its protest to various online platforms.
Shiv Sena national secretary and spokesperson Shaina NC also launched a scathing attack on Sonia Gandhi, accusing her of attempting to undermine Savarkar's legacy.
"Sonia Gandhi humiliates Savarkar. She calls him a Hindutva exclusionary. But Balasaheb Thackeray always said that Savarkar is the soul of Hindutva," she said.
Drawing a comparison between Sonia Gandhi's citizenship and Savarkar's imprisonment, Shaina questioned her authority to comment on the freedom fighter's contribution.
"Sonia ji, it took you 15-plus years to even initiate the process of Indian citizenship. Savarkar gave 50-plus years of his life, not just in jail, but also for the cause of Bharat. Who are you to judge?" she said.
She added that while writing a book was welcome, attempts to rewrite history would not be tolerated. Shaina also demanded that HarperCollins eliminate pages 201 and 443, reiterating that Savarkar had spent 11 years in the Cellular Jail for India's freedom.
BJP MLA in Maharashta, Ram Ladam, also criticised Sonia Gandhi's remarks, questioning whether the book was an autobiography or an account of personal anguish.
"Mr Gandhi, is this Sonia Gandhi's autobiography or an account of her personal anguish? There is some controversy on every page," he said.
Ladam referred to Savarkar's imprisonment in the Cellular Jail in the Andaman Islands and his sacrifices for India's freedom. He said Savarkar had endured imprisonment and continued to live a life akin to that of a prisoner for another four to five years after his release.
The NDA leaders also invoked a 2004 incident, when Shiv Sena founder Balasaheb Thackeray slapped an effigy of Congress leader Mani Shankar Aiyar with a slipper during a protest at Mumbai's Shivaji Park over alleged disrespect towards freedom fighter Veer Savarkar.
However, while tearing pages from the memoir, Shaina NC ripped a photograph of Bal Thackeray, which showed the Shiv Sena founder hitting an effigy of Aiyar with slippers.SHIV SENA TARGETS UDDHAV THACKERAY
The protest also turned into an attack on Shiv Sena (UBT) chief Uddhav Thackeray, with the Shinde-led faction questioning his decision to accept a copy of Sonia Gandhi's book. Sanjay Nirupam said Uddhav Thackeray had accepted the book despite the alleged insult to Savarkar and Marathi pride.
"When action was proposed against Union Minister Mani Shankar Aiyar, Balasaheb Thackeray had launched a protest against him. Will Uddhav Thackeray now launch a similar protest against Sonia Gandhi?" he asked.
