Sonia Exelby paid a man to kill her. I spent four unbearable days in court to find out why - The Telegraph
Sonia Exelby’s family came to Florida seeking answers.
Not about who murdered her – that much was known – but why, hard as it is to believe, she agreed to pay a man £3,000 to stab her to death.
Dwain Hall spent two years grooming Sonia on a fetish website, exploiting her lifelong struggles with depression and bipolar disorder for his own sadistic pleasure.
In October last year, she flew from her home in Portsmouth for a meeting with Hall in Florida that was to end in her torture and death.
Hall, 54, worshipped the Egyptian god of death and spent two years encouraging Exelby’s suicidal thoughts What was it, though, that made Sonia so vulnerable to Hall’s promises of a brutal and painful end to her life?
Having spent nine months looking into this uniquely tragic case, I too wanted answers – and hoped that by sitting through four days of almost unbearable evidence along with Sonia’s family, I might find them.
With courage that cannot be overstated, Gemma Isaj and Sara Exelby, Sonia’s sisters, and her brothers Luke and Barry Wilton, sat through every moment of Hall’s trial in courtroom 4C of the Marion county judicial courthouse in Ocala, Florida.
Sonia Exelby was murdered by a man she had met on a fetish website, who exploited her history of mental illness Gemma had said before the trial that nothing was going to stop her bearing witness to the evidence, and she was as good as her word.
Clutching her husband’s hand for support, she heard the unprintable details of what Hall did to her little sister. More importantly, she and the jury also heard of the mental anguish Sonia was suffering, through notes that she wrote while on her flight to the US.
“I’m screaming like I’m in a saw trap,” she wrote in a note that was shown to the jury, which she had written to herself as she tried to make sense of what she was doing. “I want to beg for help so badly, but there’s such a wall it will never happen.”
Later in the note, she said: “Everyone can give to the world except me, I just take. It almost looks like a perfect day above the clouds. Why do I still not feel like I’m going to die. I f---ed up so badly not leaving a trace at the end. I got too overwhelmed and forgot things. If I even manage to get to him, it’ll be so easy to find me I’ll be mutilated and disabled for the rest of my life.”
The next day, Sonia sent a disjointed note to a friend via social media. By then, she was being held captive in a cabin she had rented on Airbnb, where Hall was to act out his sadistic fantasies on his terrified victim.
She told her friend that Hall was in the shower, but that she was locked in the cabin and did not have the courage to take his gun and shoot him.
She wrote: “[I didn’t] think I’d be scared I thought he’d do it quick and not give my mind time to stew and realise this is the last thing I’ll ever [say] to anyone if I don’t take his offer of shooting him.”
She ended by saying: “I’m so scared I’m so broken and in so much pain all I can do is lay here and doing what [he] wants makes him respect me enough not to do the things I really hate… I’m sorry I don’t even know what I’m saying and I’m trying to be quick and My time’s up.”
The notes suggested that Sonia, a 32-year-old classically trained musician who would perform at open-mic nights, had decided she did not deserve to live, that she felt unable to ask for help, and that – even when she changed her mind about being murdered – she felt there was no way out.
Sonia, who lived with her fiancé Stevie Hunt, 36, had suffered from mental illness, including bipolar disorder, for most of her life after being placed in foster care as a child because of her father’s drug abuse and her mother’s mental health problems.
Childhood trauma led to bulimia, anorexia and a need for intensive therapy and medication. Her self-harm became so acute that she even resorted to using syringes to extract blood from her body. She had twice tried to take her own life between the ages of 24 and 26.
She fell prey to Hall after meeting him on a website called Motherless, on which he used the identity AlphaSadist.
Hall, 54, who worshipped Anubis, the Egyptian god of death, spent two years encouraging her suicidal thoughts and persuading her to meet him so that he could end her life.
A week after Sonia left Portsmouth, her body was found in a shallow grave next to a highway. She had been stabbed four times.
Sonia’s body was found in a shallow grave next to a highway a week after she had left Portsmouth Despite the overwhelming evidence against him, Hall pleaded not guilty to Sonia’s murder, forcing her family to sit through a trial that was only ever going to reach one conclusion.
Sitting four benches in front of Sonia’s family, Hall never looked at them during the trial. In a starched shirt and pressed trousers, he sat listening to the evidence impassively, save for the occasional nervous, childish giggle with his lawyer.
Behind him, Gemma bravely absorbed how the little sister she had nicknamed “Lamby” as a baby for her sweet nature had been lured to her death.
I had met Gemma and Sara in July as part of a special Telegraph investigation into Sonia’s murder.
“There will be nothing that stops me from going,” Gemma said at the time. She gave a brief smile in recognition from across the room as I took a seat alongside the smattering of other British journalists in the courtroom.
Gemma giving evidence at the trial Credit: Court TV Sara had told me about spending summer holidays caravanning with their paternal grandparents in the New Forest or at the coast in Poole. Sonia’s father and grandfather had instilled her love of music and taught her to play the guitar, piano and flute.
“We used to laugh, myself and my mum. We’re not musically talented... but Sonia had so much talent, she could pick it up,” Sara said at the time.
Sonia went on to excel at music at South Downs College in Waterlooville. Former classmates described her as a quiet and kind student who enjoyed performing in the choir.
She was also passionate about video games and animals. But privately, Sonia was struggling with her body image and depression. Throughout her 20s, her mental health became progressively worse – something upon which Hall preyed.
Ginger Stein, Hall’s wife, who claimed in an interview with The Telegraph that he was a “compassionate husband”, was nowhere to be seen in the courtroom.
Dwain Hall, whose online moniker was AlphaSadist, was found guilty of Sonia’s murder Credit: Florida department of law enforcement Each of the 12 jurors had been rigorously cross-examined before the trial for evidence of bias towards issues of assisted suicide and mental health.
On the opening day of the trial, presided over by Judge Timothy McCourt, Amy Berndt, the prosecutor, described how two people who were polar opposites in nature had ended up in a cabin in Reddick, 90 miles north of Orlando, together.
She said: “[Sonia] was brutally murdered by a predator, a man who called himself AlphaSadist. A man who was sexually aroused by the rape and torture of women...
“She was a beautiful, kind woman who was deeply loved by everybody who knew her, but sadly she suffered from mental illness for most of her life.
“Unfortunately, there was no shortage of depraved men willing to kill her in the most torturous, vile ways possible.”
The prosecution’s case was overwhelming, with more than 90 pieces of evidence and 30 witnesses, including Gemma and Sara.
In shaky but determined voices, the two sisters told the court that Sonia had warned them in November 2023 that she had been contacted by sadistic men online.
Sara, who had flown from Australia to attend the trial, said: “It was absolutely terrifying to think she was in such a vulnerable state that there were these awful people out there taking advantage of her – it was petrifying.
“We called the police about all the threats being made to her.
“She was such a beautiful soul, we didn’t think anyone could do any sort of harm to her.”
The Airbnb in the rural town of Reddick, in north Florida, where Sonia was held captive by Hall Credit: Florida Department of Law Enforcement Sara broke down when recounting that she had flown back to the UK to meet Sonia for a planned “girls’ weekend” with Gemma, only to find that Sonia had flown to the US in secret.
Gemma’s testimony echoed that of her sister, telling the court that Sonia said she had gone to suicide forums for support and that on these forums there had been people that were preying on Sonia and the friends she had made online.
Gemma said: “Sonia said she was trying to gather evidence because she couldn’t bear that people were being hurt, and she said she needed to do this so she could gather the evidence to stop these things happening to other people.”
Sara (right) with her sister Sonia, who she described during the trial as ‘a beautiful soul’ Meanwhile, Junior Barrett, the lawyer handed the impossible task of arguing that Hall was innocent, had no witness to justify his case. His opening statement to jurors lasted 67 seconds.
“We believe that when you listen to all the facts and evidence in this case you will arrive at the decision that Dwain Hall is not a murderer,” he told the panel, almost apologetically.
He argued that because Sonia was able to achieve day-to-day tasks and plan a trip to Florida, she was making an informed decision.
He could not explain or defend the horrific cache of images, presented to the court, that were stored on Hall’s computer and showed women being tortured and mutilated.
Much of the evidence presented by the prosecution was too graphic to report.
It included explicit messages exchanged between Hall and Sonia on a fetish website, photographs of Sonia’s remains and a four-minute-long forced consent video filmed by Hall the day before she was killed.
The CCTV footage of Hall buying the shovel he had used to bury Sonia caused Gemma to cast her eyes to the floor.
Hall was arrested after he was caught charging Sonia’s debit card £900 to his roadside repair business, and police discovered her DNA on his customised knife.
After a near five-hour interrogation, Hall finally revealed that he had been responsible for Sonia’s death but denied murder and kidnap.
Dr Jason Demery, a clinical neuropsychologist, told the court: “[Sonia] was conflicted and ambivalent, she was fearful, she was scared, she did not know for sure if she was going to follow through or not.
“She was a very beautiful person inside and out, and she brought a lot of joy to different folks.
“Ms Exelby was a highly vulnerable, mentally ill female. Her mental illness is quite clear, based on the correspondence I read – that would be clear to almost anyone.”
On Friday afternoon, Hall was found guilty of first-degree murder and kidnapping by the panel of 12 jurors after just one hour and 20 minutes of deliberation. He was sentenced to life in prison.
The conviction marks a moment of closure for Sonia’s family, who are now seeking to launch an organisation to protect others with mental health problems from being exploited.


