Sonia Exelby ‘told friend she was being held at gunpoint before murder by pagan’ - The Telegraph

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from The Telegraph (telegraph.co.uk). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
A British music tutor messaged a friend to warn that she was being held at gunpoint hours before her murder by a pagan worshipper, a court has heard.

A British music tutor messaged a friend to warn that she was being held at gunpoint hours before her murder by a pagan worshipper, a court has heard.

Sonia Exelby, a 32-year-old musician from Portsmouth, flew 4,000 miles to the US last October to meet Dwain Hall, a 54-year-old self-avowed sadist.

Ms Exelby, who suffered from severe mental health problems, met Hall on a fetish website called Motherless and arranged to spend a weekend with him at an Airbnb in the forests of central Florida where she would end her life, prosecutors have said.

On Oct 11, Ms Exelby messaged Ari Petursson, a friend, via the social media website Discord to say that she was being held captive at gunpoint in the cabin.

In the disjointed message, Ms Exelby, who never directly named Hall, said: “No one will find me in time.”

The message continues: “I’m sorry he keeps taking my phone… he doesn’t trust me with it.

“He made it clear there was no way out unless I shoot him. I was questioning it last night. I can’t kill anyone. He always has it on him… There’s wifi but it’s s----.

“He’s watching me every time he gives it back except now I gained some trust.”

Dwain Hall, a 54-year-old married roadside mechanic from Florida, on the first day of trial on Tuesday Credit: Court TV The message ended with Ms Exelby describing how she was “so, so scared”, in “so much pain” and that her “time is up”.

Two days after her arrival in Florida, Ms Exelby was stabbed to death and her body was buried in a shallow grave by the side of a highway.

Hall was arrested five days later and is on trial at Marion county judicial centre in Ocala, Florida, for kidnap and murder.

Ms Exelby’s sister Sara, who lives in Australia, described to the court how Mr Petursson had forwarded the desperate message to her, but said that she had not seen it until Oct 16 – four days after her sister’s death.

She described her sister to jurors as a “beautiful soul” and said she was in disbelief to think “anyone could hurt her”.

“She felt she was a burden, which she absolutely wasn’t, she just had such a beautiful nature, she just wanted us all to be the best.”

The October weekend Ms Exelby flew to Florida was the same weekend that she had planned to see her sister in Portsmouth.

On the second day of the trial, Amy Berndt, the prosecutor, revealed to jurors the messages exchanged between Hall and Ms Exelby on Motherless in the months before her death.

Ms Exelby went by the username AlreadyYours and Hall went by AlphaSadist, a moniker that the prosecution argued demonstrated his enjoyment of women being tortured and abused.

In one message, dated April 5, 2025, Ms Exelby wrote: “I got worried about you, I’m lost without my alpha sadist.”

Another said: “Like so happy my cheeks ache from grinning. I’ve missed my alpha more than I could imagine… Absence does make the heart grow fonder. I can’t be without you.”

Hall was arrested a week after Ms Exelby’s arrival in Florida  Credit: Florida department of law enforcement The prosecutors have accused Hall of preying on Ms Exelby’s fragile mental health for his own gratification and wanting to take on the role of her “executioner”.

Hall, who worshipped Anubis, the Egyptian god of death, is said to have financially extorted Ms Exelby by agreeing to kill her in exchange for $4,000 (£3,000).

Ms Exelby had attempted to take her own life twice between the ages of 24 and 26, her fiancé and partner of 16 years, Stevie Hunt, 36, told the court on Tuesday.

She had suffered since her teenage years with bulimia, self-harm and bipolar disorder, jurors were told.

Hall was arrested by the Florida department of law enforcement (FDLE) a week after Ms Exelby arrived in Florida.

Police had identified Hall as the main suspect in Ms Exelby’s disappearance after he allegedly used her Tesco debit card to charge $1,200 (£900) to his roadside mechanic business and had bought a rope and gun cleaner just before he picked her up from the airport.

Rebekah McKinzie, a special agent from the FDLE who led the investigation, explained to jurors how she succeeded in getting Hall to admit to being involved in Ms Exelby’s death.

Asked how she approached the defendant before the five-hour interrogation, Ms McKinzie said: “Prior to going into the interview, it was important for me to engage in conversation with Dwain Hall.

“So I went in being non-confrontational and nonchalant in an effort to get him to speak with me.

“I felt that if I was able to get him to speak with me in the beginning then ultimately I would be able to get information which would help me find out what happened to Sonia and where Sonia was.”

Ms Berndt replied: “In the interview, you made statements that indicated that it was okay if he killed Sonia because she wanted to be killed, and you thought that was okay.

“Was that true? You told him that?”

Ms McKinzie said: “It wasn’t, it was a tactic I used so that he would feel comfortable talking to me about what he had done with Sonia.”

Hall has pleaded not guilty to the charges of kidnap and murder. Junior Barrett, his defence barrister, has offered little in the way of mitigation or a thorough defence of the charges.

Mr Barrett told jurors on the first day of the trial: “We believe that when you listen to all the facts and evidence in this case you will arrive at a decision that Dwain Hall did not murder Sonia.”

Original Source
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/world-news/2026/11/18/sonia-exelby-told-suspect-she-could-not-live-without-him/
Visit The Telegraph ↗
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in Crime