Supreme Court overturns in part and remands Han Duck-soo case for partial acquittal... “It does not mean he joined the martial law scheme simply because stopping Yoon Suk Yeol was difficult” - 경향신문

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from Kyunghyang Shinmun (khan.co.kr). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
Supreme Court overturns in part and remands Han Duck-soo case for partial acquittal... “It does not mean he joined the martial law scheme simply because stopping Yoon Suk Yeol was difficult”  경향신문

This article was translated by an AI tool. Feedback Here.

Former Prime Minister Han Duck-soo, who was indicted on insurrection charges, appears at the Seoul Central District Court in Seocho-gu, Seoul, on January 21, the date of the first-trial sentencing. Jeong Hyo-jin, reporter

The Supreme Court set aside in part and remanded the appellate judgment that had sentenced former Prime Minister Han Duck-soo, who was indicted on charges including performing critical duties for an insurrection, to 15 years in prison, indicating the intent for partial acquittal. The appellate court had treated his recommendation to convene a Cabinet meeting before the proclamation of martial law, despite recognizing unconstitutionality and illegality, as grounds for finding a purpose of subverting the constitutional order, but the Supreme Court did not accept this. The thrust is that he was trying to prevent former President Yoon Suk Yeol from proclaiming martial law, and it is difficult to view former Prime Minister Han as having participated in the insurrection.

The Supreme Court en banc panel (presiding Justice Oh Kyung-mi) reached this conclusion on the 19th at the Grand Courtroom in Seocho-gu, Seoul, at the final hearing on the case against former Prime Minister Han on charges including performing critical duties for an insurrection.

For the first time, the Supreme Court held that “the Dec. 3 martial law constitutes insurrection under the Criminal Act.” In earlier cases involving insurrection charges against former President Yoon, former Prime Minister Han, former Minister Lee Sang-min, and other cabinet members, both the first-instance and appellate courts had found an insurrection with the purpose of subverting the constitutional order, but this is the first time the Supreme Court has conclusively defined the Dec. 3 emergency martial law as an insurrection.

The Court affirmed guilt on the grounds that, after the proclamation of martial law, former Prime Minister Han sought countersignatures from cabinet members to confer procedural legitimacy, planned blockades of key institutions, and discussed orders to cut power and water to media outlets and others, all of which it deemed to constitute insurrection.

Han Duck-soo was indicted for, among other acts, recommending that a Cabinet meeting be convened to make it appear that former President Yoon had declared the unlawful Dec. 3 martial law after deliberation by cabinet members, and for attempting to obtain their signatures after the proclamation. In the first trial he was sentenced to 23 years in prison and was taken into custody in court. On appeal, some charges were overturned as not guilty, and he received a 15-year sentence.

However, the Supreme Court found error in part of the appellate court finding of guilt regarding some of Han's insurrection-related conduct. Specifically, as to his recommendation of a Cabinet meeting before the declaration of martial law, it held that “it is difficult to recognize the purpose of undermining the constitutional order, which is an element of the crime of insurrection.” Writing for the majority, Justice Kwon Young-jun stated: “The appellate court emphasized a series of acts in which the defendant checked on the Cabinet deliberations and treated them as grounds for recognizing a purpose to subvert the constitutional order. However, satisfying the quorum for cabinet members is a requirement that necessarily accompanies Cabinet meetings,” adding, “It is difficult to conclude that the defendant merely recommended a pro forma Cabinet deliberation that only met the numerical quorum in order to create an external appearance.”

He continued, “Whether and how the Cabinet deliberation proceeded could not have constrained the emergency martial law,” and pointed out that “once a quorum was present, Yoon distributed the proclamation immediately, before other cabinet members arrived, made a unilateral statement, and declared martial law.” He concluded that the fact the Cabinet meeting amounted only to a formal facade was due to the urgent circumstances, and it is difficult to view the conduct of former Prime Minister Han as participation in the insurrection.

It further held that, regarding the portion about Cabinet deliberation involving former Prime Minister Han, it is difficult to find that a purpose to subvert the constitutional order was proven beyond a reasonable doubt, and that the appellate court erred by failing to fully examine this issue.

Justices Oh Kyung-mi, Shin Sook-hee, and Kim Sung-soo dissented. Justice Oh wrote that “the proclamation of martial law by Yoon failed to satisfy substantive and procedural requirements, and it is gravely unconstitutional and unlawful in that it suspended the powers of the National Assembly by mobilizing the military and police. It bears the character of an insurrection in the nature of a so-called self-coup, in which an incumbent ruler abuses constitutional authority to nullify constitutional controls.”

She continued, “The defendant was in a position to provide checks to ensure that presidential powers were exercised lawfully. In a life-or-death moment as unconstitutional martial law bore down, he proceeded despite foreseeing the inevitable danger that the Cabinet meeting would be reduced to a mere tool,” and added, “He took no action to block the proclamation of martial law, focused only on meeting the Cabinet quorum, and did nothing else.”

Original Source
https://www.khan.co.kr/en/article/202611191719007/?utm_source\u003dkhan_rss\u0026utm_medium\u003drss\u0026utm_campaign\u003denglish_news
Visit Kyunghyang Shinmun ↗
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in Crime