Susan Smith denied parole 32 years after murdering her 2 sons - Newsweek
Susan Smith was unanimously denied parole on Thursday, 32 years after she murdered her two young sons by allowing a car carrying them to roll into a South Carolina lake.
Smith is now eligible for release from the life sentences imposed in 1995 and is making repeated attempts to leave prison.
Her ex-husband, David Smith, and relatives of the boys urged the board to keep her incarcerated, while Smith and her supporters argued that decades of treatment, maturity and rehabilitation have changed her.
Smith, 55, appeared by video from Leath Correctional Institution in Greenwood, South Carolina, for the November 19 hearing, her second parole bid after the board also rejected her release in 2024.
"I know that what I did to my children was horrible," Smith told the board, later adding: "They were innocent children. They did not deserve to die."
Her former husband offered a different argument about what the passage of time should mean.
"It wasn't an accident. It wasn't a bad mistake. She did it deliberately," David Smith told the board. "Even though it's been 32 years, that doesn't take away what she did to Michael and Alex."
The board said it had also received 10,845 statements from concerned citizens opposing Smith's parole.
Susan Smith became one of the most recognizable figures in a 1990s murder case after the disappearance of her sons, 3-year-old Michael and 14-month-old Alexander, known as Alex, prompted a massive search in South Carolina. For nine days in 1994, Smith publicly pleaded for their return while maintaining that a Black man had driven away with the children during a carjacking.
The account was false. Smith eventually admitted that her children were in her car when it entered John D. Long Lake near Union, South Carolina. She was convicted of two counts of murder in 1995 and received two concurrent life sentences with the possibility of parole after 30 years.
Smith's history before the murders also became an important part of her defense. Her father died by suicide when she was 6; Smith attempted suicide as a teenager and evidence presented by her defense detailed serious mental health difficulties and abuse during her childhood. At trial, her lawyers argued that profound depression and other psychological problems affected her state of mind.
She has spent more than three decades incarcerated and is now held at Leath Correctional Institution. Her prison record has included disciplinary infractions, among them drug possession, while two prison employees faced charges after sexual encounters with Smith in the early 2000s. She has also held several jobs in prison.
On October 25, 1994, Smith told police that she had stopped at a traffic light when a Black man forced his way into her vehicle and drove away with Michael and Alex still inside. The allegation triggered an extensive search and drew nationwide attention as Smith appeared publicly asking for help finding her children.
Investigators grew suspicious of her story. One problem involved the traffic signal where Smith said the purported carjacking occurred: investigators found that the signal would not have changed as she described without another vehicle triggering it from the intersecting road.
On November 3, nine days after reporting the supposed abduction, Smith confessed. Her car was found submerged in John D. Long Lake with Michael and Alex inside. The boys had been strapped into their car seats when their mother allowed the vehicle to enter the water.
The repercussions of Smith's false accusation remain part of the case more than three decades later. At Thursday's hearing, 16th Circuit Solicitor Kevin Brackett, who worked on the original prosecution, pointed to the investigators, volunteers and Black men who were scrutinized because of Smith's fabricated account as additional people harmed by her actions.
Smith was married to David Smith, the father of Michael and Alex. The couple's relationship ended, but the deaths of their children permanently connected them through a crime that became a national story.
David has repeatedly opposed his former wife's release. Ahead of her latest hearing, he told PEOPLE that freeing her would be an "injustice" to Michael and Alex. At the hearing, he told board members that more than three decades had not lessened what he carries from their deaths.
"For me, it's yesterday," David said. "I'm here to advocate for Michael and Alex."
His wife, Tiffany Smith, also opposed parole, telling the board that she has spent decades witnessing the effect of the killings on David. Their daughter, Savannah Smith, said that although she never met Michael and Alex, she grew up knowing she had two brothers who had been killed and seeing how their absence affected her family.
Why Smith killed Michael and Alex was bitterly disputed at her trial and remains contested more than 30 years later.
Prosecutors argued that Smith wanted to pursue a relationship with another man who did not want children and killed her sons because she saw them as an obstacle. Prosecutor Tommy Pope returned at Thursday's parole hearing and maintained that Smith had acted deliberately and selfishly.
Smith's defense offered a very different explanation. Her attorneys argued at trial that she suffered from severe depression and psychological problems. Her defense psychiatrist diagnosed her with major depression and dependent personality disorder, according to accounts of the trial.
At Thursday's hearing, Smith explicitly rejected the theory that another man drove her decision.
"This did not happen because of a man," Smith said. "That's just not true."
Her current attorney similarly argued that mental health issues and accumulated trauma were central to understanding the crime, while stressing that they were being presented as an explanation rather than an excuse.
Forensic psychiatrist Dr. Jesse Hill told the parole board that she had interviewed Smith three times over approximately six hours. Hill traced Smith's psychological problems to childhood trauma, including the suicide of her father and sexual abuse she said Smith experienced from her stepfather.
Hill said she believed Smith developed borderline personality disorder and suffered bouts of severe depression, including after the births of her children. She also argued that Smith's psychological stability had improved considerably in roughly the past decade, attributing the change to several factors including aging, medication and changes in her personal circumstances.
Smith told the board that she believed she had lost touch with reality when she killed her children. She said she is no longer the same person and wants, if ever released, to help others struggling with mental health problems.
The board acknowledged one element of Smith's recent record, telling her that she appeared to have remained discipline-free since her previous parole hearing.
David Smith's family centered its argument not on whether Susan Smith had changed, but on what could never change for Michael and Alex.
Tiffany Smith described the lives the boys never had, including birthdays, graduations and adulthood. Savannah Smith similarly told the board that her brothers were denied the chance to experience the milestones she has encountered as she grew older.
Officials connected to the original investigation also appeared in opposition. Pope, Brackett and Union County Sheriff Jeff Bailey urged the board to keep Smith incarcerated, with Pope arguing that a life sentence should continue to mean imprisonment in her case.
Pope also raised the emotional toll of recurring parole proceedings and said he would support exploring whether the time between Smith's hearings could be extended.
The unanimous decision means Smith remains at Leath Correctional Institution after her second unsuccessful attempt at parole. Her first hearing came in November 2024, when she became eligible after serving approximately 30 years.
Her supporters had presented the board with plans for her life outside prison, including structured housing, employment assistance and outpatient mental health care.
Supporters, including a former correctional officer who knew Smith in prison and members of Smith's family, also argued that she had matured and helped other incarcerated women.
The board was not persuaded to release her.
Newsweekโs reporters and editors used Martyn, our AI assistant, to produce this story. Learn more about Martyn here.
Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Samantha Beech, Cristina Diciu, Gray R. Thomas.


