The £60bn legal bill crippling the NHS - The Telegraph
Among the many financial pressures on the NHS these days, few are as relentless or as maddeningly self-inflicted as the cost of paying for its own clinical mistakes.
Each year adds another dismal tally. In the latest, a record 15,236 patients brought legal claims against NHS hospitals, clinics and general practitioners in England after experiencing medical errors ranging from those with life-changing consequences, such as child brain injuries, to lesser failures such as inappropriate discharges from A&E.
Many were tragedies caused by little more than a medic’s misjudgment or moment of inattention. Take a notorious recent case involving a baby harmed in childbirth. Medical staff at the Queen’s Hospital in Romford neglected to monitor the baby’s heart rate during labour or to ask an obstetrician to review the situation. Thanks to those lapses, the girl suffered severe hypoxia-ischaemia – loss of oxygen to the brain – which left her severely disabled and in need of lifelong care.
The playwright George Bernard Shaw once defined success not as the avoidance of any mistakes at all, but as not making the same error again and again. By this measure, the NHS is doubly unsuccessful. Not only is it hurting patients such as the Romford baby more often than it should do; it is frittering away the resources needed to combat future mistakes.
Last year, the National Audit Office published a report that laid bare the sheer scale of the clinical-negligence bill the taxpayer faces. It is now the second largest provision on the Government’s balance sheet, with estimates of the future cost of cases, outstanding and settled, standing at an astonishing £60bn – up from £14.4bn in 2006-07.
The amount the health service shells out annually in settlements and their associated legal costs has also rocketed, more than tripling since 2006-07 to stand at £3.6bn in 2024-25, or around two per cent of NHS England’s total budget. On its present trajectory, the annual cost of damages alone is anticipated to be £4.1bn in just five years’ time, a further 32 per cent real-terms rise.
In January, Parliament’s patience finally snapped. The public accounts committee excoriated NHS bosses for failing to take “any meaningful action” to stop repeating the same clinical mistakes they’d been warned about for decades.
Its chairman, Sir Geoffrey Clifton-Brown, highlighted shoddy maternity care as an example of the Groundhog Day-style inertia that harmed patients, hit public confidence and haemorrhaged taxpayers’ money. Despite a series of maternity scandals since 2015, and numerous investigations proposing fixes, the NHS hadn’t acted. A report published this summer by Baroness Amos lamented still “way too many examples of poor care”.
Clinical negligence is a particularly insidious problem for the NHS because of its cumulative nature. When compensation is made for harm, it’s not always settled in a one-off payment. Should ongoing care be needed, or compensation for loss of future earnings, annual payments can continue for decades. It’s why child injury cases involve such massive sums. The Romford case, for instance, settled for £28m, a large chunk of which was for round-the-clock care and lost earnings over the rest of the child’s life.
Thanks to a recent Supreme Court judgment, these cases are getting even costlier. Until February, injured children with life-shortening conditions were only compensated for their expected life term. Now judges have decided that damages should include payment for the “lost years” covering a normal adult lifespan.
Concern about the ratchet effect has forced the Government to consider corrective action. Last year, the Department of Health and Social Care appointed a senior barrister, David Lock KC, to advise how to “improve the system”, with a focus on the legal aspects. Lock hasn’t reported yet, but his efforts have reignited a long-running debate about the nature of the problem.
Is it largely self-inflicted and thus for NHS bosses to resolve by improving procedures and running a tighter ship? That’s the version preferred by clinical injury lawyers. “If there is a statistical rise in the number of successful claims, it’s because patients are being harmed more than they ever were before,” says Elizabeth Maliakal of the Society of Clinical Injury Lawyers.
Others, however, see it as more multifaceted. The statistics don’t actually point to doctors and nurses getting worse at what they do. Clinical errors, albeit still unacceptably high, have come down as a proportion of total hospital patient actions over the past 20 years. There is also the disproportion between the rise in the number of cases (which more than doubled) and the cost of settling them, which is up four-fold.
“The way we resolve complaints is making things worse,” says one former NHS executive, who sees it as a legalistic quagmire. “The problem is the focus on individual negligence because this ignores the question: why did it happen in the first place?”
And this in turn prompts a troubling question, whether the litigation-based approach to settling cases, with ever-expanding fees for highly paid lawyers, is massively inflating the final bill.
In 2022, just as the Covid pandemic was subsiding, the chairman of the health select committee and former health secretary, Jeremy Hunt, popped up with a reform aimed at helping the NHS learn from past errors. “We need to make it much easier for patients to claim compensation,” he said.
The proposal was to switch from the current system – based on common law or tort – to a “no fault” approach. Instead of affected patients having to prove that medical staff had failed in their duty of care and that this had caused them harm – the current threshold for getting compensation – in future, harm alone would be enough.
Former health secretary Jeremy Hunt proposed a ‘no fault’ compensation system to help patients receive redress more quickly Credit: PA Media/Lucy North This, he argued, would prevent patient safety tragedies by focusing on “learning from mistakes so they are not repeated” rather than getting lawyers involved and “pinning the blame” on medical professionals. It would cut the unconscionable time spent on legal sparring under the current system – five to seven years, and often more than 10 in complex obstetrics cases. Instead, victims would receive a fixed tariff related to their injuries.
It was a bold idea and, needless to say, didn’t fly. Coming at a time when Britain’s finances were already under heavy pressure, there was little appetite to test the contention that opening the compensation sluice gates would reduce costs in the long run because fewer mistakes would be made.
What it did reveal was how little consensus there is around reform. While NHS bosses were wary of Hunt’s plan for budgetary reasons, doctors cheered it – perhaps in part because it could banish the professional stigma attached to litigation, although publicly they stressed lesson-learning. “If cases could be resolved in a few months, we could all correct mistakes quickly, rather than seven or more years,” says Dimitris Siasakos, a professor of obstetrics at University College London and a practising obstetrician.
The most strenuous opposition came from the lawyers. James Bell, head of medical negligence at Kingsley Napley, dismissed the fixed tariff as an affront to patients’ legal rights. “It might seemingly offer equality, but it would not offer equity,” he said. “It would [be] likely [to] result in the same quantum of funds being spread more thinly around more people.”
The inconvenient truth for today’s would-be reformers is that clinical negligence litigation took off in Britain mainly because it was almost the only way for injured patients to hold medical professionals to account for avoidable harm.
Following the foundation of the NHS in 1948, medics relied on the public’s natural deference towards white-coated doctors to preserve a culture of silence and defensiveness about clinical mistakes. Complaints procedures were cumbersome, with the health service ombudsman legally barred from examining most complaints relating to “the exercise of clinical judgment”.
It was only in 1980, when the BBC broadcast a television drama about a woman’s battle for redress after being severely injured during a routine operation, that attitudes seriously started to change. Minor Complications struck a chord with viewers who’d struggled for recognition after bad hospital outcomes. Deluged with messages, the playwright Peter Ransley set up a charity, Action for Victims of Medical Accidents, to make it easier for harmed patients to pursue complaints. It connected injured patients with solicitors, made it easier to source the medical reports that are the lifeblood of clinical litigation, and battled to give claimants access to legal aid.
These efforts helped to set Britain down the path to the present tort-dominated culture. In 1987, a 21-year-old student, Samir Aboul-Hosn, became the first patient to be awarded a £1m sum (equivalent to £3.6m today) after suffering brain damage during an operation. By the mid-1990s, with the NHS facing a bill for claims of £118m a year (£259m today), anxiety at the cost of the “compensation culture” moved up the political agenda. The NHS overhauled its complaints procedures and started putting more emphasis on averting clinical mistakes, while the Blair administration toyed with litigation reform, even passing (but not implementing) a law to establish a redress scheme for lower-value cases. But by then the ascendancy of the tort-based system was fixed.
The issue has now returned because of the terrifying rise in compensation since the 2000s, which has far surpassed even the most pessimistic expectations.
An increase in case numbers was always likely as the NHS’s workload expanded along with the nation’s population and the rising number of elderly Britons. But NHS bosses also spurred more activity through their 2014 decision to move to a system of “personalised medicine”. This gives patients much more say over how they are treated, as opposed to traditional “top-down” systems, where medical staff assess patients’ needs and put them on fixed treatment pathways.
Much of the spiralling compensation cost comes from cases involving maternity care, an area where personalisation has led to profound changes in treatment. Many more expectant mothers now demand procedures irrespective of whether the clinician would recommend them: a trend some doctors put down to “a growing distrust of medical services driven by the internet and social media”.
Along with mothers being on average older and having more complex underlying conditions (26.2 per cent were classified as clinically obese last year, up from 8 per cent in 1980), it’s one of the key reasons that the rate of caesarean sections has doubled over the past 20 years to stand at 45 per cent of all births, almost twice the European average.
Such interventions make childbirth more risky – both clinically and legally. “Put simply, you are more likely to cause problems to the baby by delivering by caesarean than if you didn’t,” says Andrew Weeks, professor of international maternal health care at the University of Liverpool and a practising obstetrician.
Caesarean sections now account for 45 per cent of births in England, amid growing concerns over the costs of maternity negligence claims Credit: Moment RF/Svetlana Repnitskaya Yet even if case numbers are up, they can’t on their own explain the vertiginous growth in damages. While Aboul-Hosn’s award caused a sensation four decades ago, multi-million-pound payouts are now unremarkable. For instance, the average amount paid out in the case of a child brain injury or cerebral palsy claim is £11.2m. The highest award remains the £37m paid out to a child in 2018.
These very high-value awards (those over £1m) are now moving the compensation needle across the entire NHS. In 2024-25, they accounted for 68 per cent of the total cost despite representing only 2 per cent of claims.
Awards in such cases split compensation into two categories. One is for pain and suffering, loss of amenity and past expenses arising from the injury. The other, larger one is forward-looking, for loss of future earnings and ongoing care requirements. These are supposed to be firmly anchored to need.
In a 2021 submission, the Department of Health and Social Care pinned the blame for rising damages not just on increasing life expectancy but critically on the escalating cost of ongoing care. However, with Sir Humphrey-style understatement, it added that these factors alone could not “fully explain the steep rise” and suggested that “precedent setting” by the courts might also have played a part.
Care costs have become a particular flashpoint. Thanks to a statute that predates the NHS, the Law Reform (Personal Injuries) Act 1948, these are automatically set by what the private sector charges – irrespective of whether the NHS could provide a free service. As well as adding substantially to damages, this leaves open the door to what critics argue is “double recovery”, where a claimant is awarded money to pay for future care costs from private sources, but subsequently seeks treatment from the NHS, which ends up effectively paying twice.
It’s not clear how frequently this occurs (the NHS cannot require claimants to account for how compensation is used, and care packages – once fixed – are almost never reopened), but a former NHS executive avers that it is “absolutely happening and wasting huge sums of taxpayers’ money that could be spent on better care”.
Other complaints revolve around the way most clinical-negligence cases are funded, which critics claim gives lawyers an incentive to inflate damages. Almost always this is on a “no win, no fee” basis, meaning that when claims succeed, solicitors stand to receive up to a quarter of those elements of damages unrelated to future loss of earnings or care costs. The terms of these compensation shares are disclosed to neither the courts nor the NHS.
“If you really want to know what’s driving the increase, you should look at the ‘schedules of claim’ lawyers submit for damages in high-value cases,” says a doctor. “You’ll find they have grown very creative at pushing up what they claim for.” The NHS just keeps paying, come what may.
Of course, higher damages represent only part of the financial burden that the tort system imposes. On top, there are the claimants’ lawyers’ bills that roll in for the 54 per cent of cases the NHS ends up settling with compensation payments.
Many have run for years, clocking up bills at private-sector rates where a clinical-negligence partner might charge more than £750 an hour, and a medical witness £300. One of the many bugbears is the time taken to assemble the medical evidence, often from NHS doctors who provide testimony as a side hustle. One frequently tapped source, Dimitris Siasakos, rises “at five in the morning on Saturdays and Sundays to write them”. Even so, because of the backlog he faces, it takes him between a year and 15 months from commission to deliver each detailed review.
Over the past 20 years, the NHS’s bill for claimants’ legal expenses has climbed by a staggering 260 per cent, reaching £538m in 2024-25, more than a third of which goes to a “magic circle” of just seven firms. It far outstrips the mere doubling of what the NHS paid to defend itself. According to a 2022 select committee report, the amount spent on claimants’ lawyers accounts for almost four-fifths of all legal costs within clinical negligence.
The full absurdity reveals itself in the ratio of legal costs to damages in the 50 per cent of settled cases where the NHS pays out the lowest level of compensation – £25,000 or less. On average, the lawyers receive £3.70 for every pound in compensation paid to claimants.
“If you ask at what point do damages exceed the costs paid to lawyers, I’d say it’s when they get to around £100,000 or more, and that’s only about two-tenths of claims,” a politician says. “Whichever way you cut it, it’s an extraordinary waste.”
The legal gravy train has resisted numerous attempts at reform since the 1990s. There is now a mountain of evidence that the system is failing and in need of repair.
The biggest concern is that the tort system fails to deliver what patients supposedly want. “Often in the first place, they’ll just want to understand what’s gone wrong,” says Guy Forster of Fieldfisher, the firm that handled the Romford case. “And if it has gone wrong, they want accountability – an apology – and for it not to happen to anyone else. Money is low down the list early on.”
Guy Forster, of law firm Fieldfisher, argues that preventing harm to patients should take priority over reducing compensation costs Credit: Geoff Pugh for The Telegraph Yet by initiating legal proceedings, patients make this less likely. “As soon as lawyers become involved, the management people say: ‘Oh God, what did you say? Did you say we made an error there?’” says one doctor.
Litigation also leads to parallel investigations as the NHS and the complainant’s lawyers both drill into the medical records looking for evidence to support their case. It’s not only a waste of resources, but gets in the way of lesson-learning. In her report on maternity care, Baroness Amos castigated the drawn-out process as “brutal” and “cruel”.
Many believe that the reliance on commercially driven solicitors to vet cases delivers haphazard outcomes, encouraging a focus on the most lucrative, while potentially failing to address valid but less profitable complaints. One consequence, as Clifton-Brown points out, is that Britain overcompensates high-value claims.
A similar arbitrariness infects the calculation of settlements. Take the way that injured babies are compensated for loss of lifetime earnings: the parents’ salaries are the yardstick. This entrenches the absurd “notion that the child of an investment banker should receive a higher compensation settlement than the child of a refuse collector”, observes the Medical Defence Union.
Whether the Government really wants to grasp this fistful of nettles is unclear. Having appointed Lock in June 2025 ahead of a review scheduled for that autumn, the Department of Health and Social Care has revealed neither his remit nor the timetable for his report to be issued.
Many, including Clifton-Brown’s committee, want a less adversarial approach. A frequently canvassed idea is the creation of an “administrative system” where experts would adjudicate cases and make quicker settlements based on fixed tariffs.
Often pointed to is the example of New Zealand, which in 1974 introduced a “no fault” system, and now settles more claims per head of population than England’s – but at less than half the cost. However, this has one feature that might not appeal to Britain’s well-remunerated lawyers: in all but exceptional cases, patients lose their right to sue.
What is clear is that any meaningful reform must wrap in high-value cases as they account for so much of the overall cost. Jeremy Hunt’s proposal foundered in part over their inclusion, and there’s no evidence that legal opposition has slackened. Yet without a blanket scheme, reformers must fall back on cruder expedients such as capping compensation or the fees that lawyers can recover in successful cases. (A plan to introduce fee caps for low-value cases was announced by the last Conservative government but was then abandoned.)
Behind everything lurks a stumbling block that has tripped so many reformers: that attempts to curb the cost disguise a more malign intent to deprive the injured of justice and skimp on the cash needed to put them back on their feet.
“We’re looking at the compensation issue through the wrong end of the telescope,” says Forster. “What we need to be asking is how can we minimise the risk of harm to children or anybody for that matter. It’s really frustrating that we keep talking about damages, claims and costs, when these are really the symptom of a crisis of patient safety that has just been allowed to snowball.”
Can this narrative be challenged? “Politicians need to decide what is the fairest use of public resources,” says the former NHS executive. “This has never been tackled in the UK. Whether this cohort of politicians can change that, I have no idea.”