The curious case of Laura Brand and why some people still feel sorry for her - The Independent
Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later? Start your Independent Membership today.
When a woman stands by a rapist, you ask questions. How could she rationalise his behaviour? Why would she believe his incessant lies? Perhaps she has been lobotomised? In most cases, these questions cannot be answered, and so we resort to the assumption that she must be just another one of his victims. It’s the only explanation that makes sense.
Because how else could any woman who is, presumably, of sound mind, support a man who has been convicted of committing the most heinous acts of sexual violence against not just one woman, but four? And who knows how many more, as allegations against others continue to emerge?
In light of his conviction and sentencing of over 10 years, how can Laura Brand continue to defend him so relentlessly, after the judge’s damning remarks about his predatory and abusive behaviour, and knowing the distress this causes his victims? Unless, as some are now suggesting, she too has been placed under his deeply manipulative spell?
During her husband’s trial, the 39-year-old children’s book author was constantly by his side and was often pictured walking into Southwark Crown Court holding his hand. Occasionally, Brand would leave the court with his arm around his wife, whose gaze was usually fixed on the floor, her eyes hidden behind large sunglasses.
It was easy, then, to assume, as many people did, that Laura was just another woman he’d coerced, someone who was silently suffering at the hands of a predator, her body literally and metaphorically ensconced within his clutches.
After all, this was a woman who’d met Brand at the tender age of 19 following an introduction from her sister, broadcaster Kirsty Gallacher. He was 31, raising questions about whether any adult man in his thirties can date a teenager without some kind of toxic power dynamic. Still, the relationship didn’t last. After a few months of dating, the couple split due to Brand’s infidelity. The pair reconnected a decade later and now have three children together, whom Laura will now parent on her own while her husband serves his prison sentence.
I can see why some people would think of her as a victim. On Tuesday, former Met detective Laura Richards told the Daily Mail she believes Laura is being “coercively controlled” by Brand, a view that is being echoed by others on social media, where video clips from the couple’s podcast, Sunday Service, have been widely shared as “evidence” of her submission to her husband, even after his conviction.
But reflecting on her latest appearance, delivering a message from Russell behind bars, I’ve reassessed the idea that she, too, has been captured by her rapist husband. The more I hear, the more she appears to be a true believer – a willing participant in the court of Kingpin Russell, a happy juggler in his circus of revolting ideas.
Consider Laura’s behaviour in court. On the day of her husband’s sentencing, the court listened to victims’ harrowing impact statements. One victim who was assaulted described herself as “losing any love for myself for a long time, thinking that I was damaged goods”. The woman Brand raped following a 2009 comedy gig said she spent years terrified she had contracted HIV and had been living under constant trauma ever since.
According to The Mirror, Laura was shaking her head while the statements were read out. Another report claimed she raised her eyebrows and shook her head as she listened to one of the victims’ testimonies, even whispering to a woman nearby while one victim broke down in tears after recounting how other people “didn’t try to stop him”.
The Times reports that Laura even rolled her eyes at one point and mouthed “for goodness sake” as she listened to victims giving deeply upsetting evidence. At one point, when a complainant described Brand as having greasy hair, and one suggested he wasn’t well-endowed, Laura is said to have “smirked scornfully”.
This is even more shocking when you remember the details some of these testimonies included. There was the woman Brand anally raped and ordered her to clean up her “mess” of blood and faeces before turning on the TV and sending her tearfully on her way. Then there was the woman who said she was “repulsed” when Brand put his head so deep into her lap she felt his breath on her vagina.
And yet, Laura not only listened to these testimonies with brazen insouciance, but she has also doubled down on her husband’s innocence despite him being convicted by a jury which heard evidence from 100 witnesses and reviewed 400 witness statements, and 1,400 documents.
On Sunday she broadcast a letter from her husband, written in prison, in which he said he was not guilty of the offences he had been jailed for. Laura shared the message on Sunday Service, the weekly YouTube podcast she has hosted with her husband since January.
“I don’t know which other men here are not guilty,” the letter stated, referring to other inmates, “and the ones that are, they are people that Christ died to save, like you and me; let us all love, pray for, and forgive one another as God forgave us.” Justice secretary Alex Norris has called the broadcasting of the message “completely unacceptable”, while No 10 has confirmed it will take action if Brand is found to have broken prison rules. Those rules do not give him an unrestricted platform to broadcast messages through his wife, particularly where they may cause further distress to the women whose evidence led to his conviction. Brand is entitled to challenge that conviction, but through the proper legal channels.
There was also an exclusive report on The News Agents podcast yesterday that prison authorities have told Russell Brand he cannot have contact with his wife, Laura, until an investigation has been fully conducted.
It’s one thing to privately believe your husband is innocent, and another entirely to deliver a message from him saying as much to the world, where she will have known it would re-traumatise his victims. Why then did Laura do it? What is she thinking? Is this her way of telling us the victims are lying? The opening sentence of her broadcast message from her husband reads: “As you know, I am not guilty for the offences I have been jailed for...” So does that mean she thinks their stories and all those who corroborated them weren’t real? That they just… made it all up?
All this becomes even murkier when you consider the financials at play. Sunday Service is a podcast that makes money; in 2024, it was reported that the videos, which continued throughout the trial, were making Brand around £25,000 per week, though the figure will arguably be higher as the show’s viewership has risen. At the time of writing, Laura’s solo episode of the podcast, in which she read the letter, has been viewed Sunday Service, at the time of writing, has been viewed 663,000 times on YouTube. Clicks mean cash for the Brand brand. In England and Wales, there is a law specifically designed to stop convicted criminals profiting from telling the story of their crimes.
Then there’s the property. Ahead of the trial, Brand transferred sole ownership of his home near Henley-on-Thames to his wife – some reports estimate the value of that home at upwards of £6m. This move has been viewed as one designed to reduce the disgraced comedian’s total net value to prevent the home from being seized to compensate victims – according to The Times, a further six women have accused Brand of sexual misconduct following his conviction. At the time of writing, it should be pointed out that none of the four women whose evidence led to Russell Brand’s convictions has submitted a compensation claim.
So, if Laura is £6m richer, or potentially even more due to the podcast earnings, and she has retraumatised her husband’s victims by telling them that he maintains his innocence, well, I cannot fathom why this woman is worthy of anyone’s pity.
Online, some have described Laura’s behaviour as “cult-like”, while others argue that she must have relied on a powerful degree of cognitive dissonance to survive what is objectively a horrific experience. To accept even a fraction of the abhorrent acts committed by her husband, the argument goes, would be to see her entire internal world collapse. Russell Brand still has more than 16 million followers and subscribers across his main social media platforms. I have little doubt that many of them are now enabling and reinforcing the belief system she appears to have built around him.
But perhaps the “why” of it all is not really the point. Four women have already had their lives irrevocably altered, collapsed even, by sexual trauma. As far as I’m concerned, they are the ones deserving of our sympathy now. They are the ones our attention should be on – particularly if Laura has become their biggest online troll.
At The Independent, our mission is to deliver unbiased, fact-based journalism. Journalism that's free from political allegiances and the influences of shareholders and commercial interests.
But we need your help. Your support enables us to uncover crucial stories that would otherwise have gone untold, hold power to account, and amplify voices often unheard.
Whether $5 or $50, every contribution counts. It fuels our reporting, invests in investigations, and maintains our independence.
It’s a reminder that our trusted, fact-based, free-thinking journalism remains available to everyone thanks to the generosity of our readers. To show your support and help us tell more of the stories that matter, please make a donation today.
Not ready to donate? Choose 'Maybe later' to start reading.

