The internet outages are not the end of the world – but something scarier - The Independent
Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later? Start your Independent Membership today.
Planes not flying, emails not sending, iPhones not working. It has been a big few days for things breaking, and it’s easy to feel like we are on the edge of everything falling apart. As with so many things, however, the easy thing might not be the right one.
As the outages pile up – yesterday alone saw Apple’s online services go down, just hours after a report that the US National Security Agency’s classified systems had broken – there is an increasing sense that they cannot just be coincidences but are connected in some hidden conspiracy. Social media and the real world are filling up with people suggesting that there is something uniting these outages.
There is, of course. The official explanations all point to one thing: ordinary human decisions. Planes were grounded because of old technology; both the Microsoft and Apple outages seem to be the result of internal, quotidian mistakes that cascaded into big problems.
None of this is to say there’s not some connection, or that people are entirely wrong to suggest that AI might be involved. Artificial intelligence is so widespread and so important that it usually is involved, in one way or another.
AI coding is making more work for engineers and less time to check it, for instance. (And you can even see its hand in other big human failings; the Jensen Huang scandal, another big contributor to the feeling that everything is going off the rails, was really made both possible and powerful by the importance of artificial intelligence, such that the technology’s magic makes it mean that it is about something more than the tawdry, human business of interpersonal relations.)
As with all jobs, work for engineers piles up at the end of the year, making it a particularly busy time for changes, and for those changes to go wrong. Our ever-increasing reliance on an ever-shrinking number of companies makes outages feel bigger. And narratives pick up their own steam: once you’re looking for outages, they seem to be everywhere.
That doesn’t feel satisfactory, however. And so come the conspiracy theories – and the associated feeling that this is all heading towards the Big Outage, which could destroy everything.
As with all conspiracy theories, it offers a slightly paradoxical comfort. Believing that everything has one very big, very terrible explanation should be scary. But in fact, there’s a kind of soothing solace.
If everything is breaking for one reason, then it implies there is only one thing to fix; if that one reason is being kept quiet, then it suggests there are people capable enough to keep it secret, and therefore perhaps capable enough to fix it. And if that one big problem is so powerful and dramatic that it can wipe us out, then at least we can throw our hands up and surrender to the apocalypse; if it’s going to destroy the whole world, then we can avoid the really hard work of thinking about what kind of world we would like to build instead.
It’s much scarier to look at the actual truth: that we live in a world full of actual people and not great machine gods, making important, dull decisions every day. That those decisions can go wrong not because of malice but because of mistakes. And that the going wrong will not end in some grand, transcendent End Times but in a variety of immediate, uncomfortable and unspectacular difficulties.
The really terrifying thing, in short, is precisely not that we are at the mercy of some great, unknown, coordinated power. The really terrifying thing is that we are all flawed people, depending in every moment on other flawed people.