The make-or-break scene that decides who plays Bond - The Telegraph
Tom Fordy is a features writer and culture journalist specialising in cinematic profiles, media commentary, and broad cultural reporting.
There’s one test that all would-be James Bond actors must pass. It’s not a physical, not target practice, not driving a gadget-laden Aston Martin at 100mph, and not escaping a laser gun pointed below. No, all prospective Bonds – from also-rans Sam Neill and James Brolin to the anointed likes of Pierce Brosnan and Daniel Craig – must audition by acting out a seduction scene from Sean Connery’s second Bond adventure, From Russia with Love (1963).
It’s reportedly the scene that won Robert Pattinson the role of Bond after Josh O’Connor apparently backed out of potentially playing 007. According to Deadline, producers of Bond 26, tipped to release in 2028, began to panic that they didn’t have a clear-cut Bond contender from the various auditions, so director Denis Villeneuve suggested they should look at Pattinson – to see what he could do with that scene.
The scene comes midway through From Russia with Love after Bond goes to Istanbul to meet Soviet agent Tatiana Romanova (Daniela Bianchi), who plans to defect and pass a Lektor decoding device to British intelligence. She is, of course, a honeytrap who’s been sent to seduce Bond. In his hotel bathroom after a hard day’s spying, the half-naked Bond hears a noise and goes to investigate – gun in hand, towel around the waist – and finds that Tatiana has decided to introduce herself by slipping into his bed.
“My friends call me Tania,” she says. “You look surprised, I thought you were expecting me,” she adds. Bond is naturally quick with the compliments. “You’re one of the most beautiful girls I’ve ever seen.” To which she says, “Thank you, but I think my mouth is too big.” “No, it’s the right size, for me that is,” before leaning in for a kiss and pressing her for details on the Lektor decoding machine.
Speaking at a BFI event in 2022, long-time Bond producer Michael G Wilson, stepson of Albert “Cubby” Broccoli and half-brother of Barbara Broccoli, confirmed that the scene is always used to test an actor who’s in serious consideration for 007. You can see examples of Bonds-who-never-were acting out the scene. “Anyone who can bring that scene off is right for Bond,” Wilson said. “It’s tough to do.”
Indeed, having the required charm and presence for Bond is one thing – screen tests show that delivering a seduction scene with a glamorous actress while half-dressed is another. Among the potential 007s who played that scene were American actor James Brolin and New Zealand actor Sam Neill. Brolin was in contention ahead of Octopussy (1983) when Roger Moore was making noises about leaving the series. Brolin auditioned with Octopussy herself, Maud Adams.
Brolin was obviously game to be the first American Bond – he did the scene wearing just a towel – but the accent doesn’t sit right. He also did a screen test of fisticuffs to show he had the action man credentials too. According to Brolin, he was all but hired and was working with stuntmen, though he never signed a contract. Moore ultimately decided to return and made two more films.
New Zealand actor Sam Neill did the scene in 1986, ahead of Timothy Dalton being cast in The Living Daylights. Neill acted the scene opposite Fiona Fullerton, who had just appeared in A View to a Kill (1985). Neill, who died this year, was spared the towel and performed the scene with just an open shirt. He remains one of the most intriguing “what ifs?” in Bond history. His delivery of “Bond, James Bond” was pitch perfect.
In 2023, Neill told Lorraine Kelly that he was “bullied” into the audition by his agent. “I found myself auditioning for a part that I never really wanted to do. Because no one wants to be the James Bond that no one likes.” He also noted that his friend Pierce Brosnan wanted the part. “I wanted Pierce to do it,” Neill said.
Brosnan remembered having to do the scene back when he originally auditioned in 1986 but his memory was hazy. “It involved a woman, and a bed, and a bit of kissing, and a bit of Walther PPK,” said Brosnan back in 1999, mistakenly recalling it as a scene from Thunderball.
Director Martin Campbell, who oversaw two new Bonds – Brosnan in GoldenEye (1995) and Daniel Craig in Casino Royale (2006) – has previously described why the scene works for auditions.
“The word is effortless,” Campbell said. “You never see Bond fumble. He’s very economic, efficient and effortless. That scene covers all the bases, basically.”
Campbell has given further detail on how it works. “They build the set,” he said, referring to the hotel room in which the scene takes place. “You have a day’s shoot for each person,” he added. “That’s the scene I think that’s been used in probably every audition for Bond.”
From Russia With Love was only Sean Connery’s second outing as James Bond Credit: Pictorial Press/ Alamy From there, the producers watch all the screen tests and vote on their favourite. “It’s a very democratic process,” said Campbell. “You all put up your hands as to who you think.” Only when an actor is cast does he get to film the trademark “gun-barrel” sequence that announces their arrival in the eventual film.
It’s unclear who to fully credit for the scene other than James Bond creator Ian Fleming. From Russia with Love is credited to screenwriter Richard Maibaum while Johanna Harwood gets an adaptation credit. Maibaum was aggrieved that Harwood got the credit, believing that she’d only made “several good suggestions”. But Harwood claimed she’d been assigned a mission to adapt Fleming’s From Russia with Love before the first Bond film, Dr No (1962), had even hit cinemas.
Harwood worked on a faithful adaptation of the book but walked away when director Terence Young kept making changes. That particular scene, though significantly chopped down, comes directly from the Fleming novel, including the banter about her mouth.
The BBFC demanded some cuts to the scene to ensure it got an “A” certificate (the equivalent of a 12A now). They trimmed a shadowy shot of Tatiana jumping into bed naked (the scene was restored for future home versions) and some snippets of dialogue, including Tatiana saying “I hope I came up to expectations” and Bond apparently trying to search her for “concealed weapons”. The kissing was also cut down.
Daniela Bianchi describes the filming of the scene as ‘rather comical’ Credit: Collection Christophel / Alamy Italian actress Daniela Bianchi was a Miss Universe runner-up before playing Tatiana Romanova. She recalled being in a bit of a vulnerable position while filming the scene, in which she was supposed to be wearing nothing but a ribbon around her neck.
“I was very concerned about keeping the sheet tight around me because underneath I was dressed in a body stocking,” she said. “Sean naturally did everything he could to complicate things. Then Terence made us repeat the scene so many times. It was rather comical.”
Decades later, the scene remains the benchmark for would-be Bonds. When testing for the role that eventually went to Daniel Craig, a young Henry Cavill, as well as reading a scene from GoldenEye, acted out the scene in From Russia with Love. He recalled that Martin Campbell told him, “Looking a little chubby there, Henry” as he came out wearing the towel. “I probably could have prepared better,” Cavill said. In every way possible it seems, the From Russia with Love scene is for Double-O calibre actors only.

