The Maple Leafs have the third-worst odds of making the Stanley Cup playoffs. So who’s to blame? - Toronto Star

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from Toronto Star (thestar.com). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
The GM? The coach? The goaltending? Maybe it's all of the above.

The GM? The coach? The goaltending? Maybe it's all of the above.

Goaltender Sergei Bobrovsky might be the face of the Leafs’ struggles this season but he’s hardly the only one to blame.

It’s not Brad Treliving’s fault. It’s not Craig Berube’s fault. 

The Maple Leafs have a 1.9 per cent chance to make the post-season, ahead of only Chicago and Vancouver.

Put another way, if 98 points is the cut-off for the second wild-card spot in the playoffs, the Leafs need 80 points from their remaining 61 games, or a record of 40-21-0. They are currently 8-13-2.

So whose fault is it that the Leafs have lost seven games in a row and have turned the 2026-27 season into a tire fire on ice?

He got the job because of his data-oriented background and because he told MLSE president and CEO Keith Pelley he could assemble a contending team around Auston Matthews and William Nylander.

Two of his key acquisitions — Sergei Bobrovsky and Darren Raddysh — are not performing to the levels expected. Raddysh has been a better all-round defenceman than expected, but one goal is not enough. Bobrovsky’s decline as an older goalie continues, and was predictable by any data expert.

Chayka’s other big move was trading for and extending Kirill Marchenko. The power forward is injured. He is missed. The team hasn’t won since he got hurt. Their fate might be different had he played the last seven games.

But the extension has handcuffed Chayka. He has plenty of salary cap room this season due to long-term injuries. It’s complicated but, basically, he can’t call up someone from the Marlies who is under contract for next season because would put them over the cap next year. That’s one of the reasons Ben Danford wasn’t recalled ahead of, say, Cole McWard.

Freddie Hamilton, Chayka’s chief of staff, appears to be taking the heat for this oversight. But Chayka fired assistant GM Brandon Pridham. Cap management was his specialty.

Sometimes he overthinks things, like not playing Gavin McKenna for two periods against Buffalo, or getting too cute with the deployment of his fourth line.

His “What are we doing?” comment after the loss in Chicago echoes Berube’s “Ask those guys” comment following an equally puzzling loss to Washington last season.

He talks a lot about plans, for Bobrovsky, for McKenna. That suggests there are a lot of cooks in the coaching kitchen.

In Edmonton, it could be suggested that there’s a plan to deploy Jake Walman, in the first year of a seven-year, $49-million (U.S.) deal. He’s minus-8 in 11 games and he has lost the trust of coach Mike Babcock. So he doesn’t play.

That sort of benching isn’t happening in Toronto.

If players can make an appeal to a higher power — Chayka or senior adviser Mats Sundin — and know Hiller’s not really in charge, do they have to be accountable to him? If they don’t play for Hiller on Thursday night against the Los Angeles Kings, the team that fired him, it will speak volumes.

Behind the scenes, the Leafs have done everything Bobrovsky has asked. He doesn’t like talking to the media, so most days he’s off limits even if the rules of the league say he should be available. It’s OK. He’s learned not to say much other than he feels good.

He is following his own training regimen. Multiple departments are involved, from goalie coach Curtis Sanford to sports performance vice-president Andy O’Brien, who was brought in based on his relationship with Bobrovsky.

In other words, there’s a lot invested in Bobrovsky beyond $21 million over three years.

But, boy, can he suck the air out of a team that pretty much has to score four or five times every time he starts. They’re “in” every game he plays, but no one lets in goals at more inopportune times than Bobrovsky. Yes, the players on the ice bear some responsibility, but big-money goalies are supposed to make big-money saves.

William Nylander seems a shadow of himself. He’s 12th on the team over the last seven games in terms of high-danger scoring chances with 14, unacceptable for a player with his talent. And he’s 20th on high-danger chances against at 26.

John Tavares finally looks like he’s showing his age, and time off for an injury didn’t help. He is minus-13 over 13 games.

Chris Tanev looks like he’s lost a step. He and Jake McCabe (42 per cent) have the worst possession numbers at five-on-five on the team.

Marchenko is back skating, a positive sign. He alone could heal what ails Tavares and Nylander. The Leafs were at a .563 points percentage when he was in the lineup. If they can duplicate that when he returns, they just might be good enough to play meaningful games in March.

Matthews has returned to health and to his form as a top-tier player. But the team’s current slump has Hiller relying on him too much defensively, as Berube did last year.

The Leafs’ metrics for possession, expected goals, and special teams aren’t bad. The number that stands out is goals-against above expected: a league-worst 11.18.

That suggests any kind improvement in goaltending, even average goaltending, could turn the season around.

(Statistics used in this story come from NHL.com, Moneypuck.com and NaturalStatTrick.com)

Error! Sorry, there was an error processing your request.

There was a problem with the recaptcha. Please try again.

You may unsubscribe at any time. By signing up, you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google privacy policy and terms of service apply.

Kevin McGran is a Star sports reporter based in Toronto. Follow him on Bluesky @kevinmcgran

Original Source
https://www.thestar.com/sports/leafs/the-maple-leafs-have-the-third-worst-odds-of-making-the-stanley-cup-playoffs-so-who-s-to-blame/article_ecd53f57-daf6-4f1e-9e66-6a050e9ccd16.html
Visit Toronto Star ↗
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in Health