The political class risks losing all sense over Russell Brand - The Telegraph
Russell Brand arriving at Southwark Crown Court with his wife Laura during his trial Credit: REUTERS Annabel Denham Senior Political Commentator Show biography Annabel Denham is a Columnist and Senior Political Commentator at The Telegraph. Previously she edited the newspaper's Comment and Opinion pages. Annabel formerly worked at the Institute of Economic Affairs, City AM, and as a Parliamentary researcher for Lord (Peter) Lilley. She can be reached at annabel.denham@telegraph.co.uk / @AnnabelDenham1.
Britain is succumbing to Brand-Walliams Derangement Syndrome. The Ministry of Justice has called for an investigation into Russell Brand maintaining his innocence following conviction, something that is hardly out of the ordinary for the recently convicted. Accusation and guilt are turning into synonyms, as evidenced by the apparent interchangeability with which we now seem to be treating Brand and David Walliams.Whatever lessons Britain ought to learn from these scandals, be confident our political establishment will draw the wrong ones. Bandwagon-jumpers of every party are now scratching around for ways to convert justified public indignation into another assault on the freedoms of millions. We know this, because we have been here before.Cast your mind back to 2017, when allegations of rape and sexual assault against Harvey Weinstein galvanised women around the world into sharing their own experiences of harassment and abuse, giving rise to the #MeToo movement. Weinstein was convicted and imprisoned in 2020, a victory for the courageous women who had spoken out and the journalists whose tenacity helped bring his behaviour to light.
Harvey Weinstein appearing in a New York court in March Credit: REUTERS Yet somewhere along the way, MeToo was co-opted by those intent on expanding the definition of abuse to cover an ever-broader range of dodgy encounters and tacky advances. Conduct that was neither criminal nor, sometimes, particularly sinister, was presented as evidence of abuse – whilst the recipient of a crass remark or ill-judged lurch adopted the status of “survivor”.Eventually the frenzy subsided, and MeToo’s celebrity crusaders found new causes to champion. The practices it spawned, however – trial by social media, disregard for due process – endured.
With alacrity, politicians translated MeToo demands into law. The Conservatives amended the Equality Act to impose a duty on employers to take “reasonable steps” to prevent sexual harassment, an obligation Labour inevitably embellished in its employment rights act. Employers now risk liability for harassment by customers and other third parties if they have failed to demonstrate the required superpowers of precognition.
The parliamentary inquiry which helped lay the groundwork for these new regulations sought to “harness the momentum of MeToo”, using surveys conducted at its height to establish the scale of the problem. Now Brand-Walliams outrage threatens to produce another legislative spasm. Ministers are contemplating a tiered age of consent, restrictions on non-disclosure agreements, and curbs on the use of complainants’ previous allegations and sexual histories in court. These proposals are not all new, but the enthusiasm with which they are now being pursued should alarm us.Take the proposed tiered age of consent, which would introduce further restrictions on relationships involving 16 and 17-year-olds according to the age of their partners. According to the latest Census, 31 per cent of married couples in England and Wales have an age difference of at least five years, rising to 34 per cent among cohabiting couples. Age disparities are an entirely ordinary feature of adult relationships. Where do you draw the line without creating anomalies?
The state has already gone too far in the direction of policing intimacy, with the private sector pushing things further under HR pressure. A defensible provision of the Sexual Offences Act 2003, prohibiting teachers and others in positions of trust from having sexual relationships with 16 and 17-year-olds in their care, has been followed by some universities banning relationships between staff and students of any age. Companies are doing the same: McDonald’s prohibits romantic relationships between employees in direct or indirect reporting relationships, which is why in 2019 it dismissed its CEO for breaching company policy by having a consensual relationship with an employee. Yet workplaces have historically been among the most common places where people meet their future spouses. YouGov research found that nearly a fifth of Britons met their current or most recent partner through work. Must all employees now retreat to the digital cesspits of dating apps? “Power imbalances” might sound nasty but if differences in wealth, seniority or age are sufficient to cast doubt on consent, will the rich only be permitted to sleep with the rich and the poor with the poor? Cinderella should stay in her lane and marry Buttons.We can condemn wrongdoing and demand justice for victims without turning the intimate relations of millions into another realm of state regulation. The proper response to scandal is to punish those responsible, not to treat us all as though we require constant supervision.


