There’s Still a War Against Boys | Opinion - Newsweek
It has been 26 years since philosopher Christina Hoff Sommers published her landmark book The War Against Boys. The book presented clear data showing that boys were falling behind in school, and that treating men and masculinity itself as the problem risked making things worse. Her warnings were largely ignored.
Today we are living with the results: boys continue to lag girls in literacy and academic achievement. Male suicide rates, alcohol abuse, drug addiction and other public health issues are a crisis nobody wants to talk about. Some young men are disengaging from school and struggling to find good-paying work. Others are angry and drifting toward online spaces that take advantage of it.
“When I wrote The War Against Boys in 2000, few people knew boys were in trouble,” Sommers tells me. “Today, their struggles are widely recognized. The problem is no longer ignorance but indifference. With some notable exceptions, the education establishment, government agencies and major philanthropies have responded with silence.”
When girls or women face obstacles and challenges, the cultural and institutional response is to examine systems, change expectations and expand opportunities. It’s understood that social norms and institutions are the problem, not girls as individuals or women as a whole. When boys or men struggle, they are told to get with the program and change their individual behavior. Boys and men are the problem, and they need to change for society, even if they are given no guidance or positive reinforcement in the process.
Disengagement from school and work, or the appeal of certain online influencers, is treated as evidence of boys’ deficiencies rather than as symptoms of long-running neglect. Doubling down on the idea that boys are the problem to be fixed only deepens the very conditions that produce alienation and disengagement. There’s no examination of social institutions or mainstream culture when boys experience struggle.
A recent viral Atlantic piece on boys’ reading argued that the lack of books with male protagonists was making it harder for boys to get into reading. Roughly 74 percent of the publishing industry is female, and the number of books written with young male readers in mind has declined. The most common reaction was an insistence that boys simply need to learn to enjoy the books already available that appeal to girls’ and women’s interests. Few voices called for more books written by men with the purpose of appealing to boys and their interests, like the great men of history or famous military conflicts.
Instead, the shortage of material was reframed as a failure of boys to adapt and a sign of a patriarchy that prevented boys from identifying with female characters. Here we have a clear case where boys are struggling. Yet, women are portrayed as the true victims.
The composition of books isn’t a minor cultural preference; literacy is foundational to academic progress and professional success. Boys cannot become men if they lack the intellectual capacity to read serious books and think deeply about growing in virtue and resilience. Men who lack sharp reading ability will not become thoughtful people or competent professionals. Systematically offering boys less engaging books will have predictable consequences and ensure that more of them fail to launch.
Today’s war against boys is visible in the United Kingdom, where concern over misogynistic content has led to new school programs aimed at teaching boys not to be misogynistic. The impulse is understandable and boys should not be misogynistic. Yet the framing positions boys as the primary problem. Young men who already feel that institutions view them with contempt are unlikely to respond well to classes that begin with that premise. Some will seek out alternatives online where they are treated empathetically and told their frustrations are legitimate. Treating that search as further proof of male defectiveness, and ignoring the reasons for it, simply accelerates the cycle.
Online influencers who exploit legitimate grievances exist. Harmful, misogynistic attitudes also exist. But fighting this requires distinguishing between root causes and symptoms. Boys who turn toward fringe content are often reacting to years of messaging that tells them masculinity is inherently bad. These same messages blame them for their academic struggles and tell them their futures matter less than getting girls ahead. Our cultural tastemakers do not examine the influence of mainstream culture or educational institutions when considering why boys lag and disengage. Without excusing bad behavior, we must recognize that sustained neglect and pathologizing boys are leading to these results.
A new survey from the American Institute for Boys and Men shows that 76 percent of men under 50 believe boys’ and men’s issues are not taken seriously. This idea is not just a fringe view in the “Manosphere”—this is how the vast majority of men feel. A separate survey published earlier this year by the Institute for Family Studies found that 69 percent of young men aged 18-29 believe manhood is viewed negatively by society. Alienation from mainstream culture is commonplace among young men, not an anomaly only traceable in fringe corners of the internet.
Republicans lost young men big time in this month’s midterm elections. This wasn’t a surprise to me. Andrew Yang and I warned back in September that the party dropped the ball when it came to addressing the challenges of young men after their historic win in 2024. Rather than make real policy changes to help young men, we saw Republican leaders side with Big Tech companies keen on exploiting them. An even bigger issue was the economy. Young men’s frustrations about affordability were not heard by Republicans heading into the midterms. The GOP simply assumed masculine messaging was enough to keep them around. They were wrong, and the last two years proved that the war against boys is not only coming from the left.
Sommers argued in 2000 that ignoring boys’ difficulties would carry costs. Those costs are now measurable in today’s increasing education gaps, mental health statistics and social withdrawal. If every new sign of male difficulty is met with further efforts to reshape boys, rather than examine the environments in which they are raised and educated, the trajectory won’t improve. A generation of boys that feels systematically devalued will not become more attached to the society that devalues them.
Ending the war against boys takes nothing away from girls. It’s applying the same diagnostic standard: when a large group is falling behind, look first at systems and incentives rather than at the group’s supposed flaws. It means writing books, designing classrooms, providing support and resources, building civil society and shaping public conversation with the recognition that boys are not defective girls.
There are many of us, including women like me, making these arguments today, just as Sommers did 26 years ago. Whether those arguments are heard today will shape the next quarter-century. The alternative is to keep dismissing the warnings, doubling down on the mistreatment of our boys, and then wondering why the boys burned down the village.
Lisa Britton is a writer and advocate.
The views expressed in this article are the writer's own.

