This deal could actually mean an end to the war in Ukraine - The Telegraph

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from The Telegraph (telegraph.co.uk). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
Volodymyr Zelensky has revealed that US envoys Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner proposed Kyiv withdraw from Donbas in return for joining the alliance Credit: AP/Peter Morrison Hamish de Bretton-Gordon Show biography Hamish de Bretton-Gordon OBE was an army officer for 23 years, re...

Volodymyr Zelensky has revealed that US envoys Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner proposed Kyiv withdraw from Donbas in return for joining the alliance Credit: AP/Peter Morrison Hamish de Bretton-Gordon Show biography Hamish de Bretton-Gordon OBE was an army officer for 23 years, reaching the rank of colonel. In 1991, he saw active service in Iraq with the 14th/20th King's Hussars as part of the First Gulf War, was commanding officer of the UK's Joint Chemical, Biological, Radiological and Nuclear Regiment, and Nato's Rapid Reaction CBRN Battalion. 

US negotiators have reportedly floated a potentially seismic proposition: Ukraine could withdraw its remaining forces from the eastern Donbas in exchange for Nato membership, President Volodymyr Zelensky has revealed.

On the face of it, this could represent a significant breakthrough. But before anyone starts talking about peace, there are some very large questions that need answering.

Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff have, thus far, hardly covered themselves in glory as diplomatic intermediaries. Their apparent sympathy towards the Kremlin, coupled with a conspicuous lack of demonstrable progress in securing a just settlement, has done little to reassure either Kyiv or European capitals that Washington has a credible negotiating strategy. Ukraine and Europe have every reason to be deeply sceptical.

Zelensky’s comments followed meetings between US envoys and both the Ukrainian and Russian presidents as the Trump administration attempted to bring an end to Europe’s largest land war since 1945.

President Trump faces  pressure to push for a rapid end to the war in Ukraine following the Republicans’ midterms defeat Credit: Reuters/Aaron Schwartz Nato membership has always been Kyiv’s ultimate strategic objective. For Ukraine, it represents the only credible long-term guarantee against another Russian invasion. For Putin, however, Nato expansion has long been presented as the justification for his aggression, although the reality is that an independent, democratic Ukraine is arguably a far greater threat to his authoritarian model than Nato itself.

President Trump has historically dismissed Ukrainian Nato membership. However, following a bruising in the midterm elections and with a personal ambition to be remembered as the president who ended, rather than the one who initiated, a major international conflict, perhaps his thinking is changing. He may finally recognise that securing a lasting peace in Ukraine would be an extraordinary political achievement.

Indeed, many of his critics would be prepared to overlook a great deal if he could deliver a genuinely just and sustainable settlement. But the devil, as ever, is in the detail.

Russia launched its full-scale invasion on February 24, 2022 and currently occupies substantial parts of the Donbas. Zelensky has consistently maintained that Ukraine will not surrender sovereign territory. Yet the prospect of Nato membership, backed by credible security guarantees, may represent a sufficiently significant strategic prize to justify putting such a painful compromise to the Ukrainian people.

Speaking of the American proposal, Zelensky said: “The Americans raised a question: ‘What if Ukraine joins Nato? Would Ukraine withdraw from Donbas?’ This was the first time this had been raised.”

He added that, were a concrete proposal to emerge incorporating meaningful security guarantees, no restrictions on Ukraine’s armed forces and funding for national reconstruction, he would be prepared to put it to a referendum.

That is a substantial concession from Kyiv. But is it really a concession Moscow is prepared to reciprocate? There is a very real danger that this proposal represents double jeopardy for Ukraine. Moscow has repeatedly insisted that it will never accept Nato troops stationed on Ukrainian territory. At the same time, Russia is seeking a fundamental restructuring of European security arrangements, one that would weaken rather than strengthen Nato’s ability to defend the continent.

Could the Kremlin’s real objective therefore be to secure the Donbas fortress belt first, stripping Ukraine of its most formidable defensive positions, and then find another reason to obstruct full Nato membership? Without the Donbas defensive line, and with restrictions on Nato’s military presence, Ukraine could find itself in a strategically far more vulnerable position than it is today.

This is the fundamental problem with negotiating with Putin: territorial concessions are tangible and immediate, whereas Russian promises about future security are worth very little without enforceable guarantees. We must not forget the Budapest Memorandum of 1994.

Witkoff and Kushner suggested a move that would allow Russia to claim complete control over the front line of the Donbas regions Credit: AFP/Vyacheslav Prokofyev If Putin is genuinely and honestly considering this proposal, there may finally be a glimmer of hope that the guns could fall silent on Nato’s eastern frontier. But it would require a remarkable change of direction from a Russian president who has invested so much in this disastrous war.

Russia has suffered catastrophic military losses, with estimates of casualties approaching two million killed and wounded. Its oil industry has come under sustained pressure, while sanctions, labour shortages and the enormous cost of the war have placed the wider Russian economy under increasing strain. Putin has paid an extraordinary price for his imperial ambitions, and yet he still appears unwilling to accept that he cannot achieve his original objectives militarily.

The Trump administration’s approach has, until now, arguably made Ukraine’s position more difficult rather than less. Thankfully, the US military, notwithstanding the political turbulence in Washington, has continued to provide critical intelligence and military assistance that has helped keep Ukraine in the fight.

Ultimately, any peace agreement must be judged not by the photographs of smiling presidents or the political accolades claimed in Washington, but by whether it prevents another Russian invasion.

Ukraine must not be forced to exchange its territorial integrity for a piece of paper containing security guarantees that nobody is prepared to enforce. Nato membership could be a genuine strategic game-changer, but only if it is full membership, with Article V protection and no Kremlin-imposed restrictions on Ukraine’s ability to defend itself.

Putin must understand that he cannot invade a sovereign country, destroy its cities, kill and maim millions of people and be rewarded for it.

There is perhaps a narrow window for diplomacy. But peace at any price is not peace at all. It is simply an invitation to the next war.

Original Source
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/11/16/ukraine-nato-russia-putin-donbas-war-fortress/
Visit The Telegraph ↗
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in Defense