Tim Hortons app sending user data to Israeli cybertech company, advocacy group confirms - Middle East Eye
The Tim Hortons app has been sharing sensitive user data with Forter, an Israeli cybertech company founded by alumni of the Israeli military's infamous intelligence Unit 8200, Canadians for Justice and Peace in the Middle East (CJPME) has confirmed.
An investigation by the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation (CBC) published last week found that the coffee chain app sends data to third-party companies overseas as soon as the app is launched.
Joel Reardon, an associate professor in the department of computer science at the University of Calgary who scanned the app's network traffic with his team, said the third party built into the app receives enough information to create a digital fingerprint of each device that can be identified later.
Some of the data includes the device's name and unique identifier, details of the device's camera and sensors, and the names of Wi-Fi routers nearby, which can be used to determine the user's location.
"This was beyond the pale," Reardon told the CBC.
Celeste Rollason, an independent analyst, told the CBC that the third party brands itself as a fraud protection service, but the amount of data collected "seems quite excessive" for simply purchasing a cup of coffee.
In its published investigation, CBC did not identify the third party or its location, saying that "accountability rests with the app developer".
Tim Hortons' director of communications, Michael Oliveira, responded to the CBC's investigation in a statement, saying the third party collects this information only for "fraud prevention, account protection, and payment abuse prevention".
He added that the third party is not allowed to sell the data and that Tim Hortons does not sell users' personal information to third-party companies or data brokers.
But after contacting the researcher at the University of Calgary, CJPME confirmed on Tuesday that the third party is Israeli cybertech company Forter, founded by alumni of the Israeli military's cyber intelligence units.
"Canadians ordering coffee should not have their unique and sensitive user data shared with an Israeli cyber-tech company whose infrastructure was built by alumni of a foreign military intelligence agency engaged in human rights violations," said Michael Bueckert, CJPME's vice president.
"The company's ties to an Israeli military unit that oversees the mass surveillance of Palestinians pose significant ethical issues, raising alarm bells for anyone concerned about cyber-security. Tim Hortons must cut ties with this company immediately."
Forter uses Israeli military intelligence and "sophisticated machine learning technologies... to create an ever-expanding identity database", according to The Jerusalem Post.
Unit 8200 is often compared to the US's National Security Agency.
Last year, Microsoft cut off Unit 8200 from using its technology after discovering it had been used to conduct mass surveillance against Palestinians under illegal Israeli occupation.
The division is associated with Lavender, Israel's AI technology that has created "kill lists" to target Palestinians in Gaza during Israel's military assault on the enclave, which has been deemed a genocide by the United Nations and Holocaust scholars.
CJPME also raised concerns with CBC's ombud regarding the omission of the Israeli cybertech company from its article.
"CBC's reporting obscures the true scale of the privacy risk Tim Hortons has exposed its users to. CBC is letting Tim Hortons and Forter off the hook. Canadians deserve to understand the truth," Jason Toney, CJPME's director of media advocacy, said.

