Toronto tenants face fourth above-guideline rent hike as landlord racks up 26 AGI applications since 2020 - Toronto Star

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from Toronto Star (thestar.com). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
The landlord says AGIs are needed to maintain aging buildings; tenants' advocates say low-income residents end up bearing the burden.

The landlord says AGIs are needed to maintain aging buildings; tenants' advocates say low-income residents end up bearing the burden.

Tenant Drew Erickson stands outside 50 Cosburn Ave., which has received a fourth above-guideline increase since 2017.

East York tenants facing a fourth rent hike over the provincial limit for their rent-controlled apartment since 2017 are sounding the alarm after learning their landlord has filed for 26 above-guideline increases (AGIs) across more than a dozen buildings since 2020.

Landlord M&R Holdings requested a 6.67 per cent AGI to cover the 173-unit building’s balcony and garage repairs plus a garage ramp restoration, show documents the Fifty Cosburn Tenants’ Association shared with the Star.

When the tenant group requested data on their landlord’s other properties from the Landlord and Tenant Board (LTB), they found the same company had applied for 26 AGIs across 14 of their 20 Toronto buildings since 2020.

The landlord says the AGIs are necessary to ensure the building is well maintained. The tenants group, however, says they hurt longtime renters in the building, many of whom rely on pensions or fixed incomes.

“It is particularly disappointing to see a landlord with substantial assets and multiple sources of income repeatedly pursue AGIs that place additional financial burdens on tenants, simply because the legislation allows it,” said the tenant group’s chair Drew Erickson. “Four AGI applications in less than ten years raises legitimate questions about how often tenants should be expected to shoulder the costs of a landlord’s investment decisions.”

As large companies have bought up more of Toronto’s rental apartments in recent decades and tenant advocates have become increasingly organized, AGIs have become a major point of contention in the province. Ontario landlords have the right to apply for rent hikes above the rent-control guideline amount if they incur certain building expenses or an “extraordinary” municipal tax hike, and for security costs. 

Large landlords often argue that Ontario has aging housing stock, and that AGIs are an important part of maintaining infrastructure while sustaining their business. Tenant advocates, however, say landlords have an obligation to maintain their buildings in exchange for rent. AGI rules, they say, lead to greater landlord profits and instability for renters. 

“We have a pandemic of AGIs in Ontario,” said Bruno Dobrusin, co-chair of the Toronto Tenant Union. “It is the number one issue that we hear (about) at the tenant union.”

Danny Roth, M&R Property Management spokesperson, said the landlord is committed to maintaining 50 Cosburn Ave. and ensuring that the building continues to meet residents’ needs.

“Ontario’s Residential Tenancies Act recognizes the importance of reinvesting in aging rental housing and establishes a carefully regulated process through which landlords may recover costs of qualifying capital expenditures,” Roth said. “These increases are subject to full review and approval by the Landlord and Tenant Board.” 

According to its website, M&R Holdings is a developer, builder and property manager with a portfolio of 20 apartment buildings in Toronto and 21 commercial properties across the GTA.

While tenants shared the LTB data showing the number of AGI applications at M&R Holdings’ properties, the Star has not seen the applications themselves.

Tenants shared four AGI application documents for 50 Cosburn Ave. showing that in a 2017 application, M&R Holdings requested an AGI for windows and doors, a roof slab and riser valves. 

Erickson says many of the residents have lived there for decades and have limited income.

In 2018, it requested an AGI for a roof replacement, balcony canopy repairs, a boiler repair, interior painting and wallpaper repair, and pigeon netting.

The 2022 application requested an AGI for a garage roof repair, exterior concrete repairs, elevator room air conditioning, and security cameras. 

This year, it requested the AGI to cover balcony and garage repairs as well as a garage ramp restoration.

Dobrusin, on behalf of the Toronto Tenant Union, said the group is active in two M&R buildings, and there are patterns that show up in those buildings, and in others where landlords regularly apply for AGIs. He said landlords sometimes neglect regular building maintenance that would prevent larger repairs. They may also neglect regular maintenance on units, he added.

“That, I think, creates a double frustration,” Dobrusin said. “So people don’t get their faucets fixed; they have mould in the bathroom, and on top of that, they get charged extra rent for things they didn’t ask for.”

Toronto-Danforth MPP Peter Tabuns said he has spoken with residents of other M&R buildings in his riding who, “feel like they’re continuously being hit with AGIs.”

It’s tough, he said, when incomes are not rising even at the rate of inflation — especially for tenants who are retired or on social assistance.

Original Source
https://www.thestar.com/real-estate/toronto-tenants-face-fourth-above-guideline-rent-hike-as-landlord-racks-up-26-agi-applications-since-2020/article_9ce813c2-2ba3-473d-8f5b-501cc8cc72ca.html
Visit Toronto Star ↗
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in Business