Treasury opposes Milburn proposal to reverse National Insurance raid - The Telegraph
Alan Milburn urged the Government to make it ‘cheaper and less risky’ for employers to hire young people Credit: PA/Stefan Rousseau Melissa Lawford Economics Correspondent. Szu Ping Chan Economics Editor Published 19 November 2026 12:05pm GMT Proposals to reverse Labour’s National Insurance (NI) raid risk a Cabinet backlash, with the Treasury opposing plans to tackle Britain’s youth unemployment crisis.
Treasury officials are understood to be resisting proposals to reduce the tax burden for employers hiring under-25s, which they argue is too expensive.
A long-anticipated review of youth employment by Alan Milburn, the former health secretary, outlined this week how the Government ought to make it “cheaper and less risky” for companies to hire young people.
He urged the Chancellor to double the earnings threshold at which employers pay NI contributions (NICs) from £5,000 to £10,000 for workers aged 21 to 24, though he acknowledged that this should be done as “fiscal conditions allow”.
Mr Milburn said the changes should be phased in during a five-year period, with the retail and hospitality sectors, which combined provide more than a third of jobs for young people, to benefit first.
The change would reverse a part of the £25bn increase in employer NICs announced by Rachel Reeves, the former chancellor, in her 2024 Budget, which was criticised for deterring companies from hiring young people.
Company bosses have argued that the Government must ease the burden on businesses if it wants to reduce the number of young people who are not in education, employment or training.
James Reed, the chief executive of Reed, Britain’s biggest recruitment firm, told The Telegraph: “The cost of employing a young person aged 21 has gone up by 20pc for employers since the general election, and 47pc of that increase has gone in taxation.
“The worst thing that could be happening now is making it more expensive to employ people because businesses everywhere are looking at how to use AI to automate things.
“That is the challenge here. We cannot fix this problem without reducing the cost of hiring people.”
But the Treasury argues that taxpayer interventions to boost youth employment must be well-targeted to deliver value for money and cutting the NICs threshold would risk simply being a dead-weight subsidy.
Treasury officials are said to have said in private briefings that it will not be implementing the cut because it is expensive and largely untargeted, the Financial Times reported.
A Treasury source told The Telegraph: “Pound-for-pound NICs [changes] are not particularly effective.”
They pointed to analysis published by the Resolution Foundation, which found that raising the earnings threshold for employer NICs for under-25s from £5,000 to £9,100 would have an “underwhelming” effect on youth employment.
The think tank estimated that the measure would cost £1bn per year but would increase the number of jobs for young people by just 7,000 – a total cost of £137,000 per additional worker.
The Treasury’s position shows how difficult it will be for Andy Burnham to deliver on Mr Milburn’s proposals, despite the Prime Minister’s promise this week that he will “move quickly” on the reforms.
Mr Burnham told the BBC on Wednesday: “This isn’t about waiting forever and a long-off-promised reform; I want to get stuck into it right now.”
However, he also told LBC on Tuesday that decisions on tax changes will have to wait until next year’s Budget and “we’re going to look at the whole of the report in the round”.