Tree protestors ordered to pay $150k for failed bid to halt golf course - ABC News & Headlines – Australian Broadcasting Corporation

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from ABC News Australia (abc.net.au). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
Tree protestors ordered to pay $150k for failed bid to halt golf course  ABC News & Headlines – Australian Broadcasting Corporation

Edwin Kemp Attrill and Janette Milera have been ordered to pay around a third of the SA government's legal costs. (ABC News)

The litigants who launched an unsuccessful legal challenge against the Malinauskas government's upgrade of the North Adelaide Golf Course have been ordered to pay costs. 

Edwin Kemp Attrill and Janette Milera have previously said the government application for costs would "probably" bankrupt them.

Mr Kemp Attrill has raised more than $120,000 but says he will need more to cover legal fees.

The litigants behind a failed challenge to the North Adelaide Golf Course upgrade have been ordered to pay $150,000 of the state government's legal costs.

The ruling, handed down by Federal Court Judge Natalie Charlesworth on Thursday, comes after the proponents of the case — public servant Edwin Kemp Attrill and Kaurna woman Janette Milera — turned down an earlier $150,000 government settlement offer.

The government's total legal bill was around $450,000 to $550,000, SA Premier Peter Malinauskas has previously said.

Mr Kemp Attrill and Ms Milera had sought to halt the golf course upgrade and its felling of 585 trees, arguing the redevelopment of the North Adelaide parklands breached federal conservation laws.

But Justice Charlesworth ruled against them in October, finding she was not satisfied the plans were "likely to have significant impact on species".

The litigants, who were represented by pro bono lawyers, have since said a government application for costs would "probably" bankrupt them.

Mr Kemp Attrill has raised $132,000 via a GoFundMe for his legal challenge.

Janette Milera and Edwin Kemp Attrill launched a legal challenge to stop the golf course upgrade. (ABC News: Eugene Boisvert)

His barrister on Wednesday argued the case was "purely in the public interest" and the judge should weigh special circumstances in awarding costs.

The government's lawyer rejected this argument but indicated she would not object to a costs order of $150,000.

Justice Charlesworth rejected a number of arguments from Mr Kemp Attrill and Ms Milera's lawyers about why they should not be subject to an adverse costs order.

This included their claims it could have a "chilling effect" on similar court cases being lodged.

"Whilst I accept that the prospect of an adverse cost order may have a chilling effect on the commencement of a proceeding of the kind commenced in this case, that is not a sufficient basis in and of itself to dismiss the respondent's application for costs," she said.

But she also rejected the government's submission that there "was no public benefit in the adjudication of the controversy in this court".

Justice Charlesworth said the litigation "served the public purpose of both clarifying the National Heritage Values and assisting the public's understanding of how the law's applied".

"I am … satisfied the litigation served a public interest in clarifying the meaning of the National Heritage Values as they apply to the Adelaide parklands and city layout," she said.

Justice Charlesworth said she also gave "significant weight" to the government's position that $150,000 was adequate recompense.

An estimated 585 trees would be cut down for the North Adelaide golf club redevelopment. (ABC News: Lincoln Rothall)

Speaking outside the court, Edwin Kemp-Attrill said they may need to raise a total of $170,000 to meet the ordered costs and other expenses incurred as part of their legal action.

"This case has always been about accountability, and we have to be accountable to our actions as well, we respect the decision of the judge," he said.

"This case has been a huge case for South Australia, it has taken a personal toll on us, but we're very proud to have done it."

Original Source
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2026-11-19/tree-protestors-ordered-to-pay-government-legal-fees/107402694
Visit ABC News Australia ↗
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in Technology