Tribunal rules restaurant’s automatic 10% service charge unlawful - IOL

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from IOL News (iol.co.za). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
The National Consumer Commission has welcomed a ruling against TriBeCa Standard over its automatic 10% service charge, warning restaurants that undisclosed fees violate the Consumer Protection Act.

The National Consumer Commission has welcomed a ruling against TriBeCa Standard over its automatic 10% service charge, warning restaurants that undisclosed fees violate the Consumer Protection Act.

The National Consumer Tribunal has ruled that a restaurant's practice of automatically adding a 10% service charge to customers' bills violates the Consumer Protection Act (CPA), following an investigation that found approximately 200 such charges were processed daily.

The ruling against Totafini (Pty) Ltd, trading as TriBeCa Standard, follows a complaint received by the National Consumer Commission (NCC), which uncovered a systematic practice of charging customers additional fees without their explicit consent.

The NCC welcomed the Tribunal's decision, saying the restaurant's conduct contravened provisions of the Consumer Protection Act 68 of 2008.

According to the Commission, its investigation established that the restaurant automatically added a 10% service fee to customers' bills, despite describing the charge as discretionary on its menu.

The investigation revealed that approximately 200 service charges were processed daily, indicating that the additional fee was routinely imposed rather than charged only in exceptional circumstances.

Customers who were dissatisfied with the service were also required to notify restaurant management, placing the responsibility on consumers to challenge a charge already included in their bills.

The Tribunal found that TriBeCa's practice contravened Section 23(6)(a) of the CPA because its menu failed to specify the additional services being charged for or display the full price payable.

The legislation prohibits suppliers from requiring consumers to pay more than the displayed price for goods or services.

The Tribunal also ruled that requiring customers to challenge the charge when they received poor service was unfair because it effectively forced them to waive their right to quality service.

The NCC explained that this conduct contravened Section 48(1), read with Sections 51(1)(a)(i) and 51(1)(b)(i) of the CPA.

The Tribunal consequently declared TriBeCa's conduct prohibited under the legislation.

While the ruling prohibits the restaurant's automatic service charge, the Tribunal clarified that customers remain free to tip restaurant staff voluntarily.

However, restaurants cannot impose such payments without consumers making a free and informed choice.

"On voluntary tips, the Tribunal clarified that genuine voluntary tips are not prohibited under the CPA. However, a tip must be freely chosen by the consumer and cannot be automatically added to the bill," the NCC said.

The distinction means restaurants may continue accepting gratuities from customers but cannot treat discretionary tips as compulsory payments.

NCC Acting Commissioner Hardin Ratshisusu welcomed the judgment, warning that restaurants imposing undisclosed charges could face regulatory scrutiny.

"This is a significant judgment and should deter other restaurants from the practice," Ratshisusu said.

"Restaurants are reminded that adding undisclosed charges not reflected on the menu prices contravenes the CPA."

The Commission said it would intensify its oversight of restaurants to ensure consumers are protected against similar practices.

"The NCC will be embarking on nationwide inspections targeted at restaurants to ensure that consumers who might be subjected to this practice are protected," Ratshisusu said.

The judgment reinforces consumers' right to transparent pricing and makes clear that restaurants cannot automatically add discretionary service charges to bills without allowing customers to decide whether to pay them.

Original Source
https://iol.co.za/news/south-africa/2026-11-20-tribunal-rules-restaurants-automatic-10-service-charge-unlawful/
Visit IOL News ↗
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in Markets