Trump officials demand investigation into ‘ghostwritten’ study that dismissed Covid lab leak - The Telegraph
Tim Röhn. Sarah Knapton Science Editor Published 18 November 2026 2:00pm GMT The Trump administration has demanded an investigation into claims that senior government scientists secretly helped shape an influential Nature paper that was used to dismiss the Covid-19 lab-leak theory.
The US National Institutes of Health (NIH) has asked Nature Medicine to examine allegations that Dr Anthony Fauci, Francis Collins and British scientist Sir Jeremy Farrar made substantial contributions to the article without being credited.
The paper, The Proximal Origin of SARS-Cov-2, became one of the most influential scientific publications of the pandemic, helping to shape the way politicians, public health officials and news organisations discussed the origins of the virus.
Published in March 2020, it argued against the possibility that the virus had been engineered or emerged through laboratory manipulation, and was widely cited by those dismissing the theory that Covid-19 had escaped from a laboratory in Wuhan.
Senior Republicans have since claimed that the paper was secretly shaped by public health officials who wanted to discourage investigations into the lab leak theory.
Virologists working in a lab at Wuhan Institute of Virology in China before the pandemic Credit: Shutterstock In a letter seen by The Telegraph, which is part of the Axel Springer Global Reporters’ Network, the NIH has called on Nature Medicine to conduct a “formal, independent investigation” into allegations of ghostwriting and undisclosed contributions, and to consider whether the paper should be corrected or retracted.
The study’s five officially credited authors rejected concerns that Covid-19 may have escaped from the Wuhan Institute of Virology (WIV), where scientists had been collecting and manipulating bat viruses. The paper has been viewed millions of times and cited in thousands of scientific papers.
Subsequently released emails revealed that the three senior health figures were involved in discussions surrounding the paper’s development, despite none being named as an author or acknowledged contributor. The emails also revealed that they had privately considered the possibility of a laboratory accident before the paper was published.
At the time of the report, Dr Fauci was the US government’s top expert on infectious diseases, Dr Collins headed the US National Institutes of Health , while Sir Jeremy Farrar was director of the Wellcome Trust and a prominent UK government Covid adviser.
All three played a critical role during the pandemic, helping to steer government policy in the US and UK, and publicly arguing in favour of a theory that the virus had evolved in animals in the wild before jumping to humans. Dr Fauci referred to the study during a White House briefing in April 2020, as the pandemic was beginning to spread around the world.
The intervention comes after the US department of health and human services issued an advisory opinion examining how contributions to scientific publications should be disclosed. This mentioned the Nature Medicine paper and the involvement of Dr Fauci, Dr Collins and Sir Jeremy.
Mr Bhattacharya also published a statement last month about the importance of transparency in scientific contributions.
He wrote: “Intellectual contributions play a central role in shaping the scientific story. Authorship and acknowledgement in scientific publications must accurately and ethically reflect all substantive input.”
Republican legislators, scientists and other critics have alleged that Dr Fauci and his colleagues sought to suppress the lab-leak hypothesis to avoid scrutiny of US-funded coronavirus research in Wuhan and criticism of China, claims that have been strenuously denied.
Donald Trump and Dr Anthony Fauci at a White House press briefing in April 2020, as the pandemic was beginning to take hold Credit: Getty/Jim Watson Emails released under Freedom of Information laws in the last few years show that before the article’s publication, Sir Jeremy, Dr Fauci, and Dr Collins communicated with each other and several of the paper’s authors to discuss the virus’s origins.
In an email exchange between the three in February 2020, Sir Jeremy, who was then director of the Wellcome Trust, shared another scientist’s view that “a likely explanation” was that Covid had evolved rapidly at a low-security lab from a Sars-like virus inside human tissue.
He warned that research in Wuhan was “like the Wild West” and said Chinese scientists had been researching bat-coronaviruses with worrying levels of biosecurity.
Emails show that by Feb 4 2020, Sir Jeremy had estimated the chance of a lab leak at 50:50 while Prof Eddie Holmes, of the University of Sydney, one of the paper’s authors, gave a 60:40 estimate in favour of an accidental release.
However, Sir Jeremy was warned that further debate about a lab leak “would do unnecessary harm to science in general and science in China”, while Dr Collins argued it could damage “international harmony and called for a “confidence-inspiring framework” to stop the “voices of conspiracy”.
By the time the paper had been published, there was no reference to biosecurity problems in Wuhan and the authors roundly dismissed a lab leak. After the publication, debate about the lab theory effectively shut down.
Drafts of the manuscript were sent to Dr Fauci, Dr Collins and Sir Jeremy, with the latter even suggesting specific wording changes, arguing that laboratory manipulation should be reworded as “improbable” rather than “unlikely”.
Security personnel keep watch outside the Wuhan Institute of Virology in February 2021 Credit: Reuters Emails show that the three were thanked by the authors for their “advice and leadership”. The NIH is asking Nature Medicine to conduct an independent review of their contributions and make a correction or retraction if warranted.
Conversations on Slack, a messaging platform, released earlier this year by Rand Paul, a US senator, show that in the months following publication, the paper’s authors continued to discuss a potential lab leak. Prof Kristian Andersen of Scripps Research, California, wrote that “we can’t rule it out”.
Prof Andersen also admitted that, although their paper claimed bat virus manipulation had been happening around the world, in fact it had “exclusively been going at WIV”.
Senator Paul argued that the documents demonstrated a significant discrepancy between the scientists’ private assessments and their public statements.
Slack messages show that another paper author, Andrew Rambaut, Professor of Molecular Evolution at the University of Edinburgh, warned there would be a “s--t show” if anyone accused the Chinese of accidental release.
He told Prof Andersen over email in February 2020: “My feeling is we should say there is no evidence of a specifically engineered virus, we cannot possibly distinguish between natural evolution and escape, so we are content with ascribing it to a natural process.”
In July 2023, a Republican-led house investigation headed by Brad Wenstrup accused Dr Fauci and Dr Collins of exercising undue influence over the paper.
Wenstrup alleged that its conclusions had been shaped by political considerations and suggested that senior public health officials had sought to discourage scrutiny of the laboratory-origin theory.
Prof Andersen and Prof Robert Garry, one of his co-authors, defended the paper during congressional testimony in 2023, saying the change in their assessment reflected the scientific process.
A Democratic staff investigation found no evidence Dr Fauci or Dr Collins had directed or influenced the preparation or publication of the article.
The Telegraph contacted those involved but had not heard back at the time of publication.

