Trump, Putin and Xi have sent Europe a humiliating message - The Independent
Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later? Start your Independent Membership today.
Where’s Europe?” That is the screaming, not to say humiliating, question prompted by the posturing of the supposed global “Big Three” in Shenzhen.
This should never have been a trilateral meeting at the Apec summit but rather a quad, with the interests of European nations properly represented. Even if the hour-long talks achieved nothing of substance, with no meaningful decisions taken, it served its purpose as a vanity project: three morally compromised leaders reading from scripts in an elaborately staged spectacle designed for their audiences back home.
The world was invited to believe that its future would be determined by these three powers. It is obscene. With no sense of irony, let alone history, Donald Trump observed in the public exchange of views on nuclear arms control that: “Once you have the nuclear weapons, it's very hard to not have them. It's very hard to give them up as a leader of a country.”
He seems not to have noticed that one of the few nations ever to unilaterally disarm itself of such weapons was Ukraine after it left the Soviet Union. In return, Russia, the US, and the UK signed the Budapest Memorandum in 1994, pledging to respect the independence, sovereignty and existing borders of Ukraine. Much good it has done since.
Russia, America and China may well be “uniquely well-placed” to remove the nuclear “sword of Damocles” hovering over humanity, as President Xi says – but that is only because of the sheer size and costs of their armouries. Their concern for the peace of humanity and the international rule of war has been much less obviously displayed in recent years as this trio of callous authoritarians has shredded the human rights of their own people, let alone anyone else.
Little wonder that one point of agreement was that the International Criminal Court and other similar institutions “must not abuse their jurisdiction." Impunity from prosecution for war crimes and crimes against humanity, then, for this Gang of Three.
In the past, the West as a whole could rely on an American president to protect it; based on shared values and convergent interests, it might be tolerable, even advantageous to have US leadership on issues such as nuclear proliferation and ending the wars in the Middle East and Ukraine. But no longer.
We have reached a point where an American president in front of the world media can stride across a room to warmly greet the Butcher of Bucha, and call indicted war criminal President Putin a “friend”. It is intolerable.
At the summit, Europe and other major powers, including India, Japan, Canada, Australia and South Korea, found themselves sidelined – at least symbolically. Sadly, it was hardly the first time, and it will not be the last. True, the talks took place on the margins of a summit of Pacific nations. But given the EU's status as the world's largest trading bloc, its immense wealth, industrial and military potential, and natural resources, it had every right to a seat at the table.
United, the nations of Europe could be a superpower in their own right. Indeed, that was precisely the ambition of the visionaries who founded the European Communities in the 1950s: to ensure that Europe's declining, former imperial powers could still wield influence on the world stage.
It’s fair to say that project is not faring well, particularly after Brexit further fractured European unity. As the prime minister points out, our enemies were indeed delighted by the outcome of the 2016 referendum. Even now, Vladimir Putin feels emboldened to invite each of Europe’s governments to talks in Moscow about the Ukraine war, and has floated the notion of negotiating individual “non-aggression pacts” with each country, from Norway to Luxembourg and Malta to Britain. It is so blatantly an attempt to divide and rule; it is surprising the Russians can keep a straight face.
The brutality of the power politics symbolised in the images emanating from the tripartite summit should not be lost on the twin summits convening in Europe now. These are the Berlin meeting of the “coalition of the willing”, and the EU-UK summit in Brussels. The best that can be said for them is that they show Europe is still trying to go in the right direction.
More long-range missiles are being dispatched to Ukraine, and the British are waking up to the reality of life outside the European Union – poorer, more isolated and less secure than seemed likely 10 years ago. The three-ring circus over in China ought to serve as a prompt for action and unity, but there’s little sign of it.

