Trump Sued Over Rule That Could Separate US Citizens From Parents - Newsweek

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from Newsweek (newsweek.com). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
The Trump administration is being sued over a new federal housing rule that could force some U.S. citizens living in mixed-status families to choose between losing housing assistance and living apart from relatives who are not eligible for the aid.

The Trump administration is being sued over a new federal housing rule that could force some U.S. citizens living in mixed-status families to choose between losing housing assistance and living apart from relatives who are not eligible for the aid.

The lawsuit challenges a Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) rule published November 12 that changes how citizenship and immigration status are verified for people living in federally assisted housing.

The rule is scheduled to take effect December 14. The plaintiffs are asking a judge to postpone that date and block enforcement of the rule in the Central District of California while the case proceeds.

Public Counsel, Kendall Brill & Kelly LLP and Bird Marella LLP filed the lawsuit on Monday in the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California against the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development and HUD Secretary Scott Turner. The plaintiffs are three Los Angeles County residents and two tenant organizations, People Organized for Westside Renewal, or POWER, and Union de Vecinos.

For decades, mixed-status families have been allowed to live together in federally assisted housing, with assistance based only on family members who qualify. HUD has also allowed other household members to decline to claim eligible immigration status under a provision known as "do not contend."

The new rule eliminates that option and expands verification requirements. It generally requires family members to establish U.S. citizenship or an eligible immigration status. Plaintiffs argue the change will effectively end ongoing prorated assistance for many mixed-status households, leaving families with the choice of separating or losing their housing assistance.

"No family should have to choose between staying together and keeping a roof over their heads. Yet HUD’s rule would force precisely that choice on families across the country, including U.S. citizen children who could lose their homes because of their parents’ immigration status. Congress did not require this. HUD chose it," Amanda Mangaser Savage, strategic litigation counsel at Public Counsel, told Newsweek.

U.S. Housing and Urban Development Secretary Scott Turner told Newsweek that “HUD’s final rule fully implements the 1980 Housing and Community Development Act and ends the exploitation of taxpayer dollars. This rule guarantees ONLY AMERICAN citizens and certain eligible noncitizens will reside in HUD-funded housing.

"This change represents a reallocation of up to $218 million which will now go to eligible Americans that are currently on a waitlist."

The HUD rule is one of several moves by the Trump administration to tighten immigrants' access to government assistance and expand the potential immigration consequences of using public benefits. The administration has implemented the public charge rule, giving immigration officers greater discretion to consider benefits including Medicaid, food stamps, and housing assistance when reviewing some green card applications. The changes have come alongside increased immigration enforcement and a campaign encouraging people in the country illegally to self-deport.

About 79,300 people, including roughly 36,000 eligible children, live in mixed-status households receiving HUD assistance, according to HUD figures cited in the lawsuit.

HUD estimated that maintaining the same level of housing assistance under the rule would require an additional $311 million to $385 million, according to the court filings.

“This new HUD rule would push thousands of mixed-status families, including U.S. citizen children, out of their homes,” David Alpert, Kendall Brill & Kelly LLP attorney, said in a statement shared with Newsweek. “Our clients are among them."

One plaintiff, identified as M.R., is a U.S. citizen with cerebral palsy who has lived in public housing since age 1 and relies on his family for support. His parents and sister, a DACA recipient, cannot establish HUD-eligible immigration status, according to the complaint. The lawsuit says the family could lose its home or M.R. could be separated from relatives who help care for him.

A second plaintiff, J.L., lives with a mother, stepfather and two brothers. J.L. and the brothers are U.S. citizens, while the parents do not have HUD-eligible immigration status, according to the filing. The family has lived in public housing for about 15 years and similarly faces losing assistance or separating if the rule takes effect, the complaint says.

Families that continue allowing an ineligible household member to live in the home could also lose housing assistance for at least two years under the rule. The rule also requires housing authorities and certain property owners to report household members they determine are unlawfully in the country to the Department of Homeland Security.

The case could have particular consequences in Los Angeles, where the plaintiffs live and the two organizations operate. The complaint cites a shortage of about 486,000 affordable homes for lower-income renters in Los Angeles County and a homeless population of about 73,040. It says the fair market rent for a two-bedroom apartment is $2,964 a month and estimates a household would need to earn $57 an hour to afford that rent without becoming rent-burdened.

“Los Angeles is home to some of our nation’s largest populations of mixed-status families, and the HUD rule would disproportionately threaten our most vulnerable communities—especially children—by putting their housing stability at risk simply because of their parents' immigration status,” Alexander H. Tran, counsel at Bird Marella, said in a statement.

The lawsuit argues that HUD exceeded its authority and violated federal housing law and the Constitution. The plaintiffs say Congress intended to allow eligible members of mixed-status families to receive reduced assistance and that HUD failed to adequately consider the risks of displacement, family separation and homelessness.

The plaintiffs are asking the court to block the rule before it takes effect on December 14 and ultimately declare it unlawful and set it aside.

Update, 11/18/26, 11:05 a.m. ET: This article was updated with comment from U.S. Housing and Urban Development Secretary Scott Turner.

Original Source
https://www.newsweek.com/trump-sued-over-rule-that-could-separate-us-citizens-from-parents-12732062
Visit Newsweek ↗
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in Politics