Twickenham crowd drowning out haka with Swing Low is uninspired and witless - The Telegraph

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from The Telegraph (telegraph.co.uk). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
The combination of New Zealand’s haka and Wales’ ‘Dragon’s breath’ was spine-tingling cinema Credit: PA/David Davies Oliver Brown Chief Sports Writer Show biography Oliver Brown leads coverage of the greatest events in sport all over the world. He has reported on multiple Olympic...

The combination of New Zealand’s haka and Wales’ ‘Dragon’s breath’ was spine-tingling cinema Credit: PA/David Davies Oliver Brown Chief Sports Writer Show biography Oliver Brown leads coverage of the greatest events in sport all over the world. He has reported on multiple Olympic Games, World Cups, Ashes series and Super Bowls, plus all major golf and tennis tournaments. His awards include Sports Feature Writer of the Year and Sports Interviewer of the Year. He was named Sports Journalist of the Year in 2024 by the London Press Club. You can find him on X at @oliverbrown_tel.

For pure, spine-tingling cinema, Wales’s response to the haka in Cardiff was just about perfect. As the Principality Stadium plunged into darkness, a spotlight picked out the All Blacks in war-dance mode, while the home side suddenly became silhouetted against a smoke of livid red, looking every inch like gladiators girding themselves for combat.

“Dragon’s breath”, the effect was called, and it took master choreographer Alex Luff and his team a year to achieve. The reaction everywhere has been rapturous, with ITV’s footage of the spectacle attracting 1.1 million hits on YouTube in six days, more than double the total for highlights of Wales’s first triumph over New Zealand in 73 years.

Haka meets y Ddraig Goch 💥🏟 #CymruAmByth https://t.co/iKznzs9Gru

This wonderfully theatrical flourish should, in theory, up the ante for Twickenham. England have hardly been averse to facing down the haka in memorable style, with their “flying V” formation ahead of the 2019 World Cup semi-final in Yokohama – a belligerent move summed up by Owen Farrell’s knowing smirk – setting the stage for their finest win of the past two decades.

Sadly, we should prepare to be underwhelmed. It is not just Twickenham’s lack of a roof that precludes a repeat of the dazzling Welsh pyrotechnics ahead of a 2.10pm kick-off, but the fact that England fans now appear determined to drown out the haka with the loudest, lairiest rendition of Swing Low, Sweet Chariot they can muster.

England players look on in their ‘flying V’ formation while New Zealand players perform a haka in 2019 Credit: Getty Images/Dan Mullan The habit has been growing for a while, and it is tiresome. Last year’s example was the worst yet, with the Swing Low chants so neutering the gravitas of the moment that you might as well have been watching 15 large men put on a puppet show. You could hear nothing of Codie Taylor’s guttural war cries beneath the beery swell of England’s appropriated anthem. All of which, I understand, is the whole point.

Given the All Blacks can clearly gain a psychological edge from the haka, then it is the supporters’ prerogative to try to wrest the advantage straight back. But after the sheer creativity of Wales’s riposte last Saturday, yet another drowning chorus of Swing Low feels at best uninspired, at worst witless.

A haka in rugby lasts two minutes at most. The Twickenham match-day experience can, at its fullest expression, stretch out to 10 hours. And at every stage of that marathon, you can savour Swing Low to your heart’s content. You can hear it on a loop at the Cabbage Patch pub outside the train station, or on South Western Railway when your service grinds to a halt outside Strawberry Hill. You can listen to it endlessly on the concourses afterwards, especially if England win. So is there not an argument, given the haka’s status as one of the most popular cultural curiosities in sport, just to let it speak for itself without the same wearyingly familiar soundtrack?

The haka was barely audible before the 2025 Nations Series match at the Allianz Stadium as the England fans drowned it out Credit: PA /Adam Davy My own view of the haka has evolved over the years. I used to think the Kiwis were far too po-faced about their beloved ritual, especially when they churlishly decided in 2006 – in a fit of pique about Wales’s plan to sing Hen Wlad Fy Nhadau (Land of My Fathers) after the haka concluded – to perform it in their dressing room instead.

But with ever more sophisticated pre-match light shows, especially in Cardiff and Paris, its power has only increased. Just as the latest version at the Principality was magnificent, so too was the 2024 instalment at the Stade de France. And the reason? That the 80,000 fans, some of the most boisterous and partisan on the planet, stayed quiet to relish a sumptuous production under the Paris lights.

Kapo O Pango under the lights of Stade de France 😤 #AllBlacks https://t.co/vGzMV8M9zw

Rugby, whether it likes it or not, needs the odd viral moment to showcase its appeal beyond its core constituency. The haka is perhaps the surest means of accomplishing this. Often, it is the opposition response that renders it iconic. Think of the scenes in 2007 at the World Cup quarter-final in Cardiff, when the French stood right in the All Blacks’ faces throughout the haka, with Sébastien Chabal wearing an expression of murderous rage.

Sebastien Chabal does not fear the All Blacks Haka 🥶 #RWC2007 https://t.co/XO1QPW365h

Thierry Dusautoir was so wound up that he proceeded to make a staggering 38 tackles during the game. It was the all-time individual record in an international match until Wales’s Dafydd Jenkins equalled it last weekend. Could it be more than coincidence that these two barnstorming matches were both prefaced by superbly dramatic hakas?

France’s strategy in 2007 was to make their presence felt during the haka performed before their quarter-final match Credit: AP/Ross Land Wales stood up to the haka in a fashion that respected New Zealand but also elevated the stature of their own players. Dewi Lake, lit up in the deepest red, looked as if he could have run through the Hoover Dam by the end of it. Somehow, the staging managed to be both confrontational and classy. Burying the haka beneath the 1,000th refrain of Swing Low is neither of these things. England, surely, can do better.

Original Source
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/rugby-union/2026/11/20/dont-drown-out-haka-with-swing-low-its-uninspired/
Visit The Telegraph ↗
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in Sports