UN bets on controversial carbon clean-up tech at climate summit
ANTALYA, Turkey — The world needs new ideas to save the planet from runaway global warming. Diplomats and lobbyists, gathered for annual climate talks in Turkey, are edging toward one of the most controversial.
As the COP31 conference draws to a close this week, carbon dioxide removal is gaining traction as a potential solution to the climate crisis. It stakes global hopes for cooling the planet on drawing harmful emissions from the atmosphere, whether through massive tree-planting schemes or pollution-sucking machines.
Detractors label CDR a “fantasy.” But science is clear it's a necessity and, amid dire warnings about the state of the climate, diplomats say the issue is coming up in negotiations.
Just before world leaders and negotiators headed to the conference in Antalya, the U.N. announced countries had polluted the atmosphere so much that halting global warming at 1.5C, the most ambitious of the Paris Agreement goals, was now impossible.
But there is a sliver of hope, the U.N. and scientists said. If the world cleans enough CO2 out of the atmosphere — while also slashing planet-warming emissions — temperatures could return to the 1.5C threshold by the end of the century.
That is where CDR comes in. Lobbyists for the industry roam the summit venue, and the case for carbon removals has filtered into the negotiations.
A draft of the final COP31 decision text, published Thursday, suggests the world “recognizes that carbon dioxide removal has a role ... in achieving the long-term temperature goal” and “welcomes efforts that contribute to urgently and rapidly scaling up the development, dissemination and deployment” of the tech.
If approved, it would be the first time CDR has been explicitly referenced in a COP decision, aside from a brief mention in 2023. The draft text also asks countries to scale up carbon capture and storage, a related technology that prevents ongoing pollution rather than taking past emissions out of the atmosphere.
On Wednesday, Ethiopia — the host of next year’s climate conference — joined Denmark as co-chair of an eight-country push to become net-negative emitters, meaning they would draw down more CO2 than they release with the help of CDR.
“We must act now to mitigate all possible emissions and in addition scale up both nature-based and technological solutions to remove emissions from the atmosphere,” said Samira Nawa, Denmark's climate minister.
But many green groups are aghast at the idea of promoting carbon removal efforts, which they view as a get-out-of-jail-free card for fossil fuel producers to keep polluting and a distraction from the essential work of cutting emissions.
Crucially, they note, CDR has never been proven to work at scale.
“Relying on fantasy techno-fixes to come on scale at some point in the future – it doesn't solve the problem,” said Mary Church, geoengineering campaign manager at the nonprofit Center for International Environmental Law.
But the companies behind the tech say the U.N.’s recent findings, and their uptake in the Antalya talks, are finally shifting the discussion their way.
“It buttresses the case that we've been making for years,” said Mathieu Bouchard, vice president for government affairs and policy at Canadian carbon removal firm Deep Sky. “The [U.N.] report [on exceeding 1.5C], as catastrophic as it is, has the merit of saying things as they are and changing the conversation around CDR as well.”
Carbon removal has long battled a credibility problem.
Removal efforts come in two main flavors — those that rely on nature and those that rely on technology. Land-based methods, such as large-scale tree planting or restoring peatlands, are the only ones proven to work at a meaningful scale.
More novel methods — which include using machines to hoover up CO2, speeding up the breakdown of rocks to seal away carbon, or adding nutrients to the ocean to increase its carbon uptake — are in their infancy.
An assessment of the industry, released earlier this year, found the world currently removes 2.2 gigatons of CO2 every year. Novel CDR methods are responsible for just 0.002 gigatons —roughly equivalent to the annual emissions of small island countries such as Fiji or Malta. To reverse warming to 1.5C, the U.N. said the world must find a way to permanently sequester 320 gigatons over the course of this century.
Such scaling up takes time, the firms say.
“We have to start somewhere,” said Bouchard. “We hear the criticism — ‘it’s too expensive, it’s not efficient enough.’ True. Cell phones in 1979 were extremely expensive and had a battery life of about 30 minutes. We could have said we're going to stop there and not improve them.”
Critics point to reliability as well. While some technologies can theoretically lock away CO2 for millennia, trees do so only temporarily and only as long as they remain standing — after which that carbon risks being rereleased.
Fossil fuel firms and petrostates are among the biggest backers of CCS, prompting fears the tech will be used to prolong pollution rather than fight it. In the negotiations in Antalya, two diplomats said references to CCS and CDR might be used to persuade oil-rich Saudi Arabia to back the final text.
Where to deploy CDR raises its own questions about environmental damage. India has raised concerns during negotiations that removal efforts through creating new forests could gobble up agricultural land, the same two diplomats said.
Lynda Tabuya, Fiji’s climate minister, told POLITICO that CDR has been coming up in the talks but said Pacific island nations are taking a cautious approach. She worries about the ecological impact of ocean-based carbon removal in particular. “It’s not something that is huge on our agenda,” Tabuya said.
Church, the campaigner, acknowledged large-scale use of CDR was the “only theoretical way” to return to 1.5C after overshooting the target, but said doing so would “cause profound harm to ecosystems.” She warned that highlighting CDR at the U.N. talks “risks normalizing these really problematic technologies.”
But some on the ground insist the tech’s time has come.
CDR “is something which has been ignored for almost a decade by many policymakers. This is an inevitable ingredient of a successful climate policy,” said climate economist and EU adviser Ottmar Edenhofer. It’s “high time” to start discussing it, he urged.
For CDR companies, the increased attention is a boon. For the second COP running, industry lobbyists have a dedicated events pavilion set up inside the venue.
According to the Center for International Environmental Law, the number of carbon capture lobbyists at COP — counting both representatives of carbon removal firms and people working on CCS for oil majors — has increased from around 530 last year to 700 this year.
They are there to chip away at the skepticism.
“We see the way to achieve CDR scale is actually building the technologies up to scale and building trust — amongst investors and customers and the public and governments,” said Ameen Bou Diab, project development manager at Dutch carbon removal firm Skytree. He said he had been meeting with governments and other businesses on the sidelines of the Antalya summit.
CDR’s namecheck in the draft decision “is an achievement, because we're putting the spotlight on CDR as a must-have and a must-do, not a nice-to-have,” he added.
Deep Sky’s Bouchard hopes the discussions will eventually lead countries to include carbon removal targets in their Paris Agreement-mandated climate plans, “where governments commit not only to reduce their emissions but to actually remove carbon out of the atmosphere.”
The mention of CDR in the Antalya draft text is “very encouraging,” agreed Molly Tinker, head of carbon markets at Swiss direct air capture company Climeworks, who attended the Antalya conference last week.
The text, she noted, recognizes CDR can’t be a substitute for cutting emissions. “It’s a complementary measure,” Tinker said. “But we are 24 years away from net zero for many countries, and to scale a carbon removal sector to the scale that is needed, that really needs to start now.”
That view is winning out among governments.
“There is no alternative than to continue to push for sustained and more substantial emission reductions, full stop,” said Wopke Hoekstra, the European Union’s climate chief, last week.
“But given the complexity of the problem, given the fact that certain sectors have just much more difficulty decarbonizing, given the fact that we need negative emissions in any case … this [CDR] definitely is part of the solution space,” he added.
And while island nations are wary of messing with the ocean, they also see CDR as a necessity, given that warming above 1.5C threatens their very survival.
Ilana Seid, chair of the Alliance of Small Island States, told reporters on Tuesday that she is “skeptical” about ocean-based methods that aren’t yet proven to work. Like so many colleagues, she stressed that cutting emissions quicker was the key to limiting global warming.
“But carbon dioxide removal will need to be at the tail end of the equation,” she said. “I think we recognize that.”
Sara Schonhardt contributed to this report.
