Why has Prince William not spoken about his Indian ancestry? - The Telegraph
Prince William’s family history could help him to forge bonds in India Credit: Andrew Parsons/Kensington Palace Christopher Wilson. Victoria Ward Deputy Royal Editor Published 18 November 2026 2:13pm GMT With adoring crowds swarming around him and the Princess of Wales in Mumbai, might Prince William now finally take the opportunity to explore his own Indian heritage?
The Prince of Wales descends from the dark-skinned Eliza “Betsy” Kewark, a native of Mumbai, but has not spoken publicly about his ancestor – even though in our ultra-confessional age, a drop of personal history never goes amiss.
Despite his warm welcome in Mumbai, Prince William has held back from publicly discussing his Indian heritage Credit: PA/Chris Jackson The story has all the makings of a Bollywood saga. Eliza, born of an Armenian father and Indian mother in 1790, is the future King’s five-times-great-grandmother. She married an up-and-coming man in the mighty East India Company, though because of her colour, she appears in official papers as his housekeeper, not his wife.
Maybe that’s what has held William back from discussing this Indian heritage – Eliza’s heartless treatment by a man who, for eight years, she considered to be her husband. A product of the British class system, Theodore Forbes, son of a Scottish laird, dumped her the moment he was told he would face social oblivion if he brought her back to Britain.
But William’s family history could help him to forge bonds in India. “I think the moment has finally come when Prince William should say: ‘I am proud of the Indian ancestry I have,’” says Susan Harvard, an academic, art restorer and sheep farmer who first uncovered Eliza’s story.
“His visit is about strengthening the ties between India and Britain, and this would be the ideal moment to talk about this significant part of his DNA. He’s a clever boy, and he can find the words to make the very best out of this connection.”
Harvard, who spent more than two decades researching Eliza’s life, says the Indian connection has been known to the Spencer side of William’s family for some time. “There are letters in Armenian from Eliza in the library at Althorp, and I am certain that William has heard all about it from them,” she says.
The current Earl Spencer named his first two daughters Eliza and Kitty – the same name as Eliza’s only daughter – although The Telegraph understands that this is a coincidence. Earl Spencer is believed to have been aware of this branch of his mother’s ancestry for around 15 years.
The DNA connection between the future King and the Bombay belle was confirmed in 2013 by Dr Jim Wilson of Edinburgh University, whose researchers analysed saliva samples from two living direct-line descendants sharing the same maternal lineage as the late Princess Diana. Tracing a rare mitochondrial DNA thread back through seven generations, they discovered a unique South Asian lineage found only in a minute handful of people in India and Nepal.
William can be assured of this part of his family history. His problem is extricating these attractive antecedents with a degree of pride from the greater story of the East India Company (EIC), which even today is regarded as a bulldozer that exploited India’s wealth, undermined its political independence, and used military force and political intrigue to establish colonial domination.
Theodore Forbes, Eliza’s husband, was an up-and-coming man in the mighty East India Company Credit: Alamy Stock Photo/Peter Barritt If India despises the memory of the British Raj, it positively detests all mention of the EIC, which operated for nearly 300 years from 1600 onwards and sucked the modern equivalent of £10tn from the subcontinent. To that could be added the tally of abandoned wives, including Eliza, left to fend for themselves when their “husbands” went home having made their fortune.
Theodore, who counted among his relatives the powerful Earls of Angus and Douglas, and could trace his family back to the 12th century, might have looked forward to a comfortable life in the rural Highlands – until he made a local girl pregnant and was speedily dispatched to India in 1809.
There he met Eliza, and they married in an Armenian church ceremony involving the donning of golden crowns.
Theirs was a happy marriage – or so it seemed. But it was the Indian part of Eliza’s ancestry that was to cause the final breach in the couple’s eight years together: Armenia, a landlocked country in the southern Caucasus, was considered to be European and therefore socially acceptable as far as marriage went. India, however, was not.
At the age of 23, Theodore was dispatched to Mocha in Yemen, a crucial staging post for ships plying their trade between Britain and the East. Eliza went with him and remained there, while Theodore continued to base himself in Bombay.
“He wasn’t just any old East India employee,” says Harvard, “he was posted to the city as the British resident in the Arabian Gulf. Not only was he responsible for all the coffee purchases of the East India Company, but he was also a member of the secret and political department of the [British] government in Bombay. He had to keep an eye on the French – it was 1812 – and deal with pirate threats.”
It was here in this dusty Red Sea port that William’s ancestor, Kitty, was born. Two years later came her brother, Alexander, but here the story takes a tragic turn.
Kitty Forbes, Eliza and Theodore’s daughter, is an ancestor of William through his mother, Diana It is clear from surviving diaries that Theodore, by now shooting his way up the company ladder, wanted to have his family with him in Bombay. But he was warned off. It was one thing to have a native wife stuck somewhere up in the hills, but she could not be brought into polite society.
“The head of house told him not to have his wife and children in Bombay,” says Harvard. “Indeed, I found a letter telling Theodore to ‘live his life with due propriety’. The instruction was stark and unequivocal.”
The choice was a simple one for Theodore– ruin his career chances by returning to Mocha, or ruin his career chances by bringing the family into Bombay.
He chose another route. He decided to send Kitty home to Scotland, with the plan that he would soon follow. Alexander would stay behind with Eliza. The plan fell apart when Theodore finally followed his daughter home in 1820. His ship, the Blenden Hall, got as far as the American coast when he succumbed to an illness and died.
From that moment, Eliza became a non-person.
With Kitty now safe and living in luxury at her grandparents’ castle, Eliza discovered under the terms of her husband’s will that her monthly allowance had been reduced to a miserly 100 rupees a month (by comparison, Theodore left Kitty 50,000 rupees). Fourteen years after her husband’s death, so desperate was her plight that she wrote to Theodore’s kinsman, Sir Charles Forbes, asking for financial help.
In true East India style, Charles forwarded the letter to her children – and that was that. Either her children never received it or (less likely) declined to act on it. Either way, Eliza was never heard of again.
Though Kitty’s mixed parentage meant she would be discouraged by Scottish society from marrying into their aristocracy, she happily settled for James Crombie, an up-and-coming wool manufacturer whose family speciality was the making of coats – a name still familiar today.
Kitty happily settled with James Crombie after returning to Scotland Credit: Art UK Kitty’s granddaughter, Ruth, married the wealthy Colonel William Gill, whose home, Dalhebity, was a stately mansion on the outskirts of Aberdeen. Ruth’s daughter, also Ruth, married Maurice Burke Roche, an Irish peer bearing the title of Lord Fermoy, in 1931, while that couple’s daughter, Frances, married Johnnie Althorp, soon to become Earl Spencer. The fabled daughter of that marriage, Diana, married the then-Prince of Wales and gave birth to William, the future King.
A tangled tale, as family histories so often are. But surely one worth exploiting while William goes about the job of wooing the entire Indian nation?


