Will I owe tax for selling stuff online? - Toronto Star
If your reselling looks like a business, it could be taxed like one.
As of 2024, the CRA receives seller information directly from online platforms and can match that data against your tax returns.
Lora Grady is a personal finance reporter for the Star. Reach her via email at lgrady@thestar.ca.
Q: I want to sell some used household items — including clothing, appliances and furniture — online. Will I owe tax on the income?
A: Resale platforms like Facebook Marketplace and Poshmark are booming, as many Canadians look to make some extra cash by unloading used items. But when does the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) expect you to pay tax on those sales — and when are you essentially running a business?
As of 2024, the CRA receives seller information directly from online platforms such as Poshmark and can match that data against your tax returns. This excludes sellers who conducted fewer than 30 sales and whose gross income from sales did not exceed $2,800 during the reportable period.
“If you bought items for your own use and later sold them, that’s generally considered a disposition of personal-use property,” says Ryan Minor, director of taxation for Chartered Professional Accountants of Canada. “It stays that way even if you sell a lot of items at once.”
Selling an item for less than what you paid does not generate income, so it is generally not deductible and not reportable. When you sell a personal-use item, the CRA applies a $1,000 floor to the proceeds and the cost. A gain on a personal item is only a taxable capital gain when the proceeds for that single item exceed $1,000 and are greater than the item’s initial cost.
If you buy an item with the intention of reselling it at a profit, the CRA is likely to treat that profit as business income, Minor says. Any gain is then generally considered business income rather than a capital gain, and you must report it on your tax return. “That applies whether you’re buying at garage sales to flip online, buying limited-edition sneakers to resell, or something similar.”
In determining whether you are essentially running a business, the CRA will also consider how frequently you buy and sell, how long you hold items before selling, how organized the activity is (sourcing inventory, repairing or improving items, advertising, keeping records), whether you have special knowledge of the market, and whether the activity resembles an existing business you operate. Even a single transaction can be classified as business income if the item was bought specifically to flip for a profit. In that case, the $1,000 rule doesn’t apply, and the full profit is business income and fully taxable.
One important threshold resellers should know: if your gross taxable revenue exceeds $30,000 in a single quarter or over four consecutive quarters, you must register for and collect GST/HST, just as you would for any other business.
If you don’t report income from reselling and the CRA later discovers an unreported gain, it can reassess your return and add interest and penalties. “Regular or high-value selling is more likely to draw attention, particularly if it looks like a business,” Minor says.
If you’ve missed reporting income in past years, you may be able to reduce or avoid penalties and interest by voluntarily correcting your tax return or applying to the Voluntary Disclosures Program — a CRA program that allows taxpayers to correct errors in exchange for potential penalty relief — if certain conditions are met.
Money Coach is a biweekly feature that helps Canadians find helpful solutions to personal finance challenges. If you have a question, email Lora at lgrady@thestar.ca.
Opinion articles are based on the author’s interpretations and judgments of facts, data and events. More details
Lora Grady is a personal finance reporter for the Star. Reach her via email at lgrady@thestar.ca.

