Winners and Losers From Trump, Xi and Putin’s Summit to Decide World’s Fate - Newsweek

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from Newsweek (newsweek.com). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
President Donald Trump, Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin touted how they were deciding the fate of the world ahead of their trilateral meeting this week on the sidelines of the APEC summit in Shenzhen, China.

President Donald Trump, Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin touted how they were deciding the fate of the world ahead of their trilateral meeting this week on the sidelines of the APEC summit in Shenzhen, China.

As such, the joint statement from the U.S., China and Russia after their leaders' 90-minute meeting will be pored over about which issues were prioritized, what was omitted and who emerged on top. The talks addressed global issues like reducing nuclear threats, UN reform and increasing the world's supply of petroleum products amid an energy crisis.

Putin benefited from criticism of the International Criminal Court (ICC), which has issued an arrest warrant for him linked to the Ukraine War, a topic absent from a readout after the meeting.

Xi used the meeting to demonstrate Beijing's unique and growing convening power on the world stage, William Yang, Northeast Asia senior analyst at the International Crisis Group told Newsweek on Thursday.

"China probably emerges from the trilateral summit feeling confident," Yang said.

The closed-door meeting at the Kylin Villa in Shenzhen lasted for 90 minutes, a half-hour longer than the scheduled time.

The U.S. released the statement after Russia and China as they outlined their roles as permanent members of the UN Security Council as key to reforming the body. The statement also committed to the importance of energy flows and petroleum products in a pledge that comes amid a spike in global energy prices exacerbated by the U.S. war with Iran.

The trio reaffirmed that a nuclear war cannot be won, must not be fought and would engage in dialogue "on reducing nuclear risks and preventing nuclear proliferation."

But the trio also said that the ICC "and other similar bodies must not abuse their jurisdiction."

The joint readout, which highlighted Trump and Putin thanking Xi for hosting the summit, suggested that the U.S. and Russian leaders need to curry favor from Xi, Yang said.

"On the other hand, China avoided committing itself to a trilateral nuclear negotiation that it views as unfair to its interests and position," Yang said.

Since the meeting yielded no meaningful conclusion on settling the Russia-Ukraine war, China also avoided souring its relationship with European countries by hosting the summit.

"Overall, Beijing will feel relatively confident about its relative position vis-a-vis Washington and Moscow following this meeting," Yang added.

After years of isolation and sanctions caused by his invasion of Ukraine on February 24, 2022, Putin's presence at the top table of global diplomacy was welcomed by Russian media.

Trump's comments about the ICC and the statement against it will serve Russian leader well, as will rhetoric during the summit that reinforces his vision of a global order that pivots away from Western dominance.

“Nobody expected everything to go so well," Putin said as part of his goodbye to Xi.

Trump said he had raised the wars in Iran and Ukraine with the leaders earlier in the day, but the conflicts were not mentioned in the statement released by Russia and China.

The trilateral meeting had been roughly compared to the 1945 Yalta Conference that divided the post-World War II world into spheres of influence. Like Yalta, the APEC summit was seen as a way for the fate of a nation to be decided by other players.

While expectations had been managed over the prospect of any breakthrough on the war started by Putin, the absence of any immediate public pledge about Putin ending the war will be of concern for Kyiv as well as Europe.

Europe bears the consequences of the war in Ukraine, and while it is not part of APEC, the meeting throws into play how the continent has been sidelined by Trump in his efforts to negotiate an end to the war. Russia's resistance to European efforts to get to the negotiating table may have been legitimized by APEC.

Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk posted on X: "God, protect us from such friends."

The ICC was the focus of criticism in the joint statement and in comments made by Trump before the three leaders went behind closed doors.

Trump said at the start of the meeting that the ICC was "out of control," a statement that would be welcomed by Putin, who was issued with an international arrest warrant in 2023 for allegations linked to the abduction of Ukrainian children.

The statement about how the "respect for the immunity of state officials are of paramount importance" could be taken as a pledge of support for Putin and the war crimes of which he is accused.

Before the meeting, the White House said that the leaders could thrash out rules for controlling nuclear weapons.

Trump's remarks before the meeting that the countries were "uniquely positioned to discuss how to reduce the number of nuclear weapons on Earth" shows how much of a legacy issue it is for his presidency.

The New START treaty controlling arms of Russia and the U.S. expired in February and Trump has said he wants a new deal involving China, which could have 1,000 warheads by the end of the decade.

Beijing is reluctant at having limits places on its arsenal, so the joint statement on Thursday has been greeted with cautious optimism. The statement said that the three countries will engage in dialogue on reducing nuclear risks and preventing nuclear proliferation.

"It is positive that the leaders of the countries with the three largest nuclear arsenals reaffirmed that a nuclear cannot be won and must never be fought and wish to remain in dialogue on nuclear nonproliferation," Daryl G. Kimball, executive director of the Arms Control Association, told Newsweek on Thursday.

But Kimball said for serious progress, the leaders need "to task their senior diplomats and experts to develop and discuss balanced proposals to cap and reduce their deadly arsenals and be ready to engage in give-and-take talks that produce real results."

Trump tried to portray Xi and Putin as his friends while showing he could negotiate with the biggest U.S. rivals.

In his bilateral dealings with Xi, Trump treated his personal rapport as insurance against a crisis because he believes the leaders can preserve calm while their countries compete, said Craig Singleton from the Foundation for the Defense of Democracies.

"Xi is seeking to collect on that insurance by securing American restraint on Taiwan," Singleton told Newsweek.

Meanwhile, Trump’s warnings about nuclear devastation reflect his ambition to make disarmament a legacy achievement, Singleton added.

While Xi placed Beijing at the center of diplomacy among the three great powers and Putin stood there as a peer, the U.S. president "gained a platform for his legacy ambitions."

"In that sense, each secured a diplomatic dividend before resolving any underlying dispute," Singleton said. "Each gained prestige while giving up little policy ground. Xi treated Trump with respect in Shenzhen. He will test his resolve in Miami next month, when the bill for Beijing’s trade commitments comes due.”

After the meeting, Trump quickly left the villa and boarded Air Force One without speaking to reporters. The U.S. release of the joint statement came some time after Russia's and China's.

The White House Press Pool said that reporters travelling with Trump had their phones removed in a "highly unusual move."

Agence France-Presse correspondent Aurelia End posted that "our phones are being taken away for now for security reasons."

Jacqui Heinrich, a senior White House correspondent for Fox News, said that the move raised suspicion that Air Force One "may not be heading straight home" as she added on X that phones were not taken after Trump's departure from his state visit to Beijing in May.

The New York Post connected it to speculation that Trump planned to meet North Korean dictator Kim Jong Un, which the U.S. leader had teased as a possibility earlier in the week.

"White House officials surrendered their own 'burner' phones following Trump's May visit to Beijing for fear of Chinese espionage software, but taking journalists' phones is unusual," the publication reported.

Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Henry Holloway and Dave Siminoff.

Original Source
https://www.newsweek.com/winners-losers-trump-xi-putins-summit-decide-worlds-fate-12739952
Visit Newsweek ↗
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in International Relations