‘Worst thing to happen in my lifetime’: So You Are owner speaks out
The owner of the Melbourne Cup runner dumped in a public skip bin in Sydney has blasted those responsible for the disposal of its body as Premier Chris Minns weighed into the controversy, saying: “We expect these things not to happen”.
The shocking discovery of So You Are’s remains has made headlines around the world and placed the racing industry under scrutiny to address systematic problems with the handling of dead racehorses.
It was only 15 days ago that So You Are started as one of the favourites in the Melbourne Cup before finishing eighth in the race.
On Tuesday, this masthead revealed the deceased horse had been found in a skip bin by a builder at the Cleanaway Lucas Heights Resource Recovery Centre in southern Sydney before being buried. It had been euthanised after suffering a severe bout of colic.
Minns, whose government appoints the board of racing industry controlling body Racing NSW, said on Wednesday the incident was “distressing for everyone involved and needed to be fully investigated”.
“I’m not sure about the sequence, the reasons why a Melbourne Cup runner ends up in a skip bin in Lucas Heights, but we expect to get to the bottom of it,” Minns said.
So You Are before competing in the Melbourne Cup at Flemington earlier this month.Racing Photos via Getty ImagesMinns said he expected retired racehorses to be dealt with humanely and in most cases rehomed, and said the industry needed to find better ways of disposing dead horses.
“We expect these things not to happen,” he said.
So You Are’s owner and breeder Stuart Ramsey is also demanding answers, taking aim at the veterinary clinic which organised the disposal of the horse’s body after being unable to save him.
REC Equine Specialists has admitted it did not know what happened to deceased horses after they were taken away from its Horsley Park hospital by contractors.
“At the end of the day they’re professional people and they should be treated like professional people. They’ve done the wrong thing and should be gone. This is the worst thing to happen in my lifetime.
“These horses try their heart out and they’re allowed to do what they like to them.”
Waste management giant Cleanaway said So You Are had been transported to its Lucas Heights facility in a small tipper truck and held in a skip bin before it was buried because it was unsafe for the vehicle to approach the landfill. The process followed “established procedures”, according to Cleanaway.
Veterinarians who treat racehorses are licensed by racing authorities and can face penalties, including deregistration.
The Racing NSW board is expected to meet soon to discuss introducing standards around the disposal of horse carcasses in response to So You Are’s disposal. There are no current requirements for disposing of a horse carcass beyond recommending that those handling them wear protective equipment to avoid contracting disease.
Racing NSW chief executive Graeme Hinton said the way So You Are was treated after his death was “totally unacceptable”.
So You Are was found dead and dumped in a skip bin at Lucas Heights in Sydney. Facebook“Our industry has worked tirelessly to develop and maintain the world’s best welfare standards for our horses throughout their lives. That same level of care and respect should also be shown after their deaths,” he said.
“We are currently reviewing these industry practices for burial and cremation of deceased horses and considering what additional rules and minimum standards need to be introduced. We will act swiftly and decisively on this. We know the vast majority of our participants do the right thing, but we need to set and enforce the standards to ensure that every horse receives a timely and respectful burial.”
Hinton also plans to speak to other state racing bodies to develop a national response.
Racing Victoria has three burial options for horses euthanised off the racecourse: burial at an approved Environment Protection Agency site, at a private property subject to strict EPA requirements or cremation.
RV requires stock removalists to ensure the horse’s body is placed within the burial site, which would then be covered by dirt inside 30 minutes.
Racing NSW, which has $82 million in cash reserves and $287 million in total current assets, is also being encouraged to invest in a facility like a specialist equine crematorium as racing authorities in New Zealand have done.
Dr Cameron Collins, a veterinarian who sits on the board of the Hunter Valley Equine Research Centre, said dead racehorses could be disposed of at such a site by means including chemical biodigestion if not by cremation.
“It’s something that should be considered,” Collins said. “It’d be a carcass disposal facility. Effectively, it could be done as a user-pays system or it could be subsidised by Racing NSW.”
Despite the suggestion, burial remains a legitimate way to deal with horse carcasses, according to Collins.
A spokesperson for the Department of Primary Industries said its “initial consideration” was that its guidelines were followed. It added that it was a matter for “Racing NSW, the landfill operator and contractor who picked up the carcass, so that in future they better manage the disposal of racehorse carcasses to better protect the reputation of the industry”.
Ramsey was upset he was not given the opportunity to bury So You Are on his stud farm near Scone.
He said he had been travelling in western Queensland when So You Are fell ill on Monday and was rushed to emergency surgery from a spelling paddock near Camden.
So You Are’s trainer, Bjorn Baker, was distraught, he said.
“I was in western Queensland and very hard to contact. They contacted me as soon as they could. Bjorn rang me and he was very upset,” Ramsey said.
“I was speaking to him the other morning and he broke down. His wife had to get on the phone, the poor bastard.”
Ramsey had been joined by about 30 long-time friends at Flemington to see So You Are compete in the Melbourne Cup a fortnight ago and could not envisage what was to come.
He said he was devastated to lose the horse and learn how its body had been handled but was more concerned for the family of apprentice jockey Izzy Neale, who died 10 days ago following a race fall in central western NSW.
“She was 22. I’m bloody 74. She hadn’t lived,” he said. “We lost a daughter 20 years ago. There is always someone worse off than yourself.”
You have reached your maximum number of saved items.
Remove items from your saved list to add more.
You've used all of your gift articles. 3 more will become available on the 1st of every month.

